Grammatical gender
In linguistics, a grammatical gender system is a specific form of a noun class system, where nouns are assigned to gender categories that are often not related to the real-world qualities of the entities denoted by those nouns. In languages with grammatical gender, most or all nouns inherently carry one value of the grammatical category called gender. The values present in a given language, of which there are usually two or three, are called the genders of that language. Determiners, adjectives, and pronouns also change their form depending on the noun to which they refer.
According to one estimate, gender is used in approximately half of the world's languages.
Overview
Languages with grammatical gender usually have two to four different genders, but some are attested with up to 20.Common gender divisions include masculine and feminine; masculine, feminine, and neuter; or animate and inanimate.
Depending on the language and the specific word, the assignment of grammatical gender may correlate with the noun's meaning or may be entirely arbitrary.
In a few languages, the assignment of any particular noun to one grammatical gender is solely determined by that noun's meaning, or attributes, like biological sex, humanness, or animacy. However, the existence of words that denote male and female, such as the difference between "aunt" and "uncle" is not enough to constitute a gender system.
In other languages, the division into genders usually correlates to some degree, at least for a certain set of nouns, such as those denoting humans, with some property or properties of the things that particular nouns denote. Such properties include animacy or inanimacy, "humanness" or non-humanness, and biological sex.
However, in most languages, this semantic division is only partially valid, and many nouns may belong to a gender category that contrasts with their meaning, e.g. the word for "manliness" could be of feminine gender, as it is in French with "la masculinité" and "la virilité". In such a case, the gender assignment can also be influenced by the morphology or phonology of the noun, or in some cases can be apparently arbitrary.
Usually each noun is assigned to one of the genders, and few or no nouns can occur in more than one gender.
Gender is considered an inherent quality of nouns, and it affects the forms of other related words, a process called "agreement". Nouns may be considered the "triggers" of the process, whereas other words will be the "target" of these changes.
These related words can be, depending on the language: determiners, pronouns, numerals, quantifiers, possessives, adjectives, past and passive participles, articles, verbs, adverbs, complementizers, and adpositions. Gender class may be marked on the noun itself, but will also always be marked on other constituents in a noun phrase or sentence. If the noun is explicitly marked, both trigger and target may feature similar alternations.
Functions
Three possible functions of grammatical gender include:- In a language with explicit inflections for gender, it is easy to express gender distinctions in animate beings.
- Grammatical gender "can be a valuable tool of disambiguation", rendering clarity about antecedents or homophones.
- In literature, gender can be used to "animate and personify inanimate nouns". Languages with gender distinction generally have fewer cases of ambiguity concerning, for example, pronominal reference. In the English phrase "a flowerbed in the garden which I maintain", only context tells us whether the relative clause refers to the whole garden or just the flowerbed. In German, in cases where the objects in question have different grammatical gender, gender distinction prevents such ambiguity. The word for "flowerbed" is neuter, whereas that for "garden" is masculine. Hence, if a neuter relative pronoun is used, the relative clause refers to "flowerbed", and if a masculine pronoun is used, the relative clause refers to "garden". Because of this, languages with gender distinction can often use pronouns where in English a noun would have to be repeated in order to avoid confusion. It does not, however, help in cases where the words are of the same grammatical gender.
Gender contrasts
Common systems of gender contrast include:- masculine–feminine gender contrast
- masculine–feminine–neuter gender contrast
- animate–inanimate gender contrast
- common–neuter gender contrast
Masculine–feminine contrast
Nouns that denote specifically male persons are normally of masculine gender; those that denote specifically female persons are normally of feminine gender; and nouns that denote something that does not have any sex, or do not specify the sex of their referent, have come to belong to one or other of the genders, in a way that may appear arbitrary. Examples of languages with such a system include most of the modern Romance languages, the Baltic languages, the Celtic languages, some Indo-Aryan languages, and the Afroasiatic languages.Masculine–feminine–neuter contrast
This is similar to systems with a masculine–feminine contrast, except that there is a third available gender, so nouns with sexless or unspecified-sex referents may be either masculine, feminine, or neuter. There are also certain exceptional nouns whose gender does not follow the denoted sex, such as the German Mädchen, meaning "girl", which is neuter. This is because it is actually a diminutive of "Magd" and all diminutive forms with the suffix -chen are neuter. Examples of languages with such a system include later forms of Proto-Indo-European, Sanskrit, some Germanic languages, most Slavic languages, a few Romance languages, Marathi, Latin, and Greek grammar|Greek].Animate–inanimate contrast
Here nouns that denote animate things generally belong to one gender, and those that denote inanimate things to another. Examples include earlier forms of Proto-Indo-European and the earliest family known to have split off from it, the extinct Anatolian languages. Modern examples include Algonquian languages such as Ojibwe.- In Northern Kurdish language, the same word can have two genders according to the context. For example, if the word dar is feminine, it means that it is a living tree, but if it is masculine, it means that it is dead, no longer living. So if one wants to refer to a certain table that is made of wood from an apple tree, one cannot use the word dar with a feminine gender, and if one wants to refer to an apple tree in a garden, one cannot use dar with a masculine gender.
Common–neuter contrast
Here a masculine–feminine–neuter system previously existed, but the distinction between masculine and feminine genders has been lost in nouns, though not in pronouns that can operate under natural gender. Thus nouns denoting people are usually of common gender, whereas other nouns may be of either gender. Examples include Danish and Swedish, and to some extent Dutch.The dialect of the old Norwegian capital Bergen also uses common gender and neuter exclusively. The common gender in Bergen and in Danish is inflected with the same articles and suffixes as the masculine gender in Norwegian Bokmål. This makes some obviously feminine noun phrases like "a cute girl", "the well milking cow" or "the pregnant mares" sound strange to most Norwegian ears when spoken by Danes and people from Bergen since they are inflected in a way that sounds like the masculine declensions in South-Eastern Norwegian dialects.
The same does not apply to Swedish common gender, as the declensions follow a different pattern from both the Norwegian written languages. Norwegian Nynorsk, Norwegian Bokmål and most spoken dialects retain masculine, feminine and neuter even if their Scandinavian neighbors have lost one of the genders. As shown, the merger of masculine and feminine in these languages and dialects can be considered a reversal of the original split in Proto-Indo-European.
Other types of division or subdivision of gender
Some gender contrasts are referred to as classes. In some of the Slavic languages, for example, within the masculine and sometimes feminine and neuter genders, there is a further division between animate and inanimate nouns—and in Polish, also sometimes between nouns denoting humans and non-humans. A human–non-human distinction is also found in Dravidian languages.How gender contrasts can influence cognition
It has been shown that grammatical gender causes a number of cognitive effects. For example, when native speakers of gendered languages are asked to imagine an inanimate object speaking, whether its voice is male or female tends to correspond to the grammatical gender of the object in their language. This has been observed for speakers of Spanish, French, and German, among others.Caveats of this research include the possibility of subjects "using grammatical gender as a strategy for performing the task", and the fact that even for inanimate objects the gender of nouns is not always random. For example, in Spanish, female gender is often attributed to objects that are "used by women, natural, round, or light", but male gender to objects "used by men, artificial, angular, or heavy". Apparent failures to reproduce the effect for German speakers has also led to a proposal that the effect is restricted to languages with a two-gender system, possibly because such languages are inclined towards a greater correspondence between grammatical and natural gender.
Another kind of test, the semantic differential, asks people to describe a noun, and attempts to measure whether it takes on gender-specific connotations depending on the speaker's native language. For example, one study found that German speakers describing a bridge more often used the words 'beautiful', 'elegant', 'pretty', and 'slender', while Spanish speakers, whose word for 'bridge' is masculine, used 'big', 'dangerous', 'strong', and 'sturdy' more often. However, studies of this kind have been criticized on various grounds and yield an unclear pattern of results overall.
Related linguistic concepts
Noun classes
A noun may belong to a given class because of characteristic features of its referent, such as sex, animacy, shape, although in some instances a noun can be placed in a particular class based purely on its grammatical behavior. Some authors use the term grammatical gender as a synonym of noun class, but others use different definitions for each.Many authors prefer the term noun class when none of the inflections in a language relate to sex, such as when an animate–inanimate distinction is made. However, the word gender derives from Latin genus which originally meant 'kind, type', so it does not necessarily have a sexual meaning.
Noun classifiers
A classifier, or measure word, is a word or morpheme used in some languages together with a noun, principally to enable numbers and certain other determiners to be applied to the noun. They are not regularly used in English or other European languages, although they parallel the use of words such as piece and head in phrases like "three pieces of paper" or "thirty head of cattle". They are a prominent feature of East Asian languages, where it is common for all nouns to require a classifier when being quantified—for example, the equivalent of "three people" is often "three people". A more general type of classifier can be found in sign languages.Classifiers can be considered similar to genders or noun classes, in that a language which uses classifiers normally has a number of different ones, used with different sets of nouns. These sets depend largely on properties of the things that the nouns denote, although sometimes a noun is associated with a particular classifier more by convention than for any obvious reason. However it is also possible for a given noun to be usable with any of several classifiers; for example, the Mandarin Chinese classifier 个 is frequently used as an alternative to various more specific classifiers.
Manifestation
Grammatical gender can be realized as inflection and can be conditioned by other types of inflection, especially number inflection, where the singular-plural contrast can interact with gender inflection.As inflection
The grammatical gender of a noun manifests itself in two principal ways: in the modifications that the noun itself undergoes, and in modifications of other related words.As noun inflection
Grammatical gender manifests itself when words related to a noun like determiners, pronouns or adjectives change their form according to the gender of noun they refer to. The parts of speech affected by gender agreement, the circumstances in which it occurs, and the way words are marked for gender vary between languages. Gender inflection may interact with other grammatical categories like number or case. In some languages the declension pattern followed by the noun itself will be different for different genders.The gender of a noun may affect the modifications that the noun itself undergoes, particularly the way in which the noun inflects for number and case. For example, a language like Latin, German or Russian has a number of different declension patterns, and which pattern a particular noun follows may be highly correlated with its gender. A concrete example is provided by the German word, which has two possible genders: when it is masculine its genitive singular form is Sees, but when it is feminine, the genitive is See, because feminine nouns do not take the genitive -s.
Gender is sometimes reflected in other ways. In Welsh, gender marking is mostly lost on nouns; however, Welsh has initial mutation, where the first consonant of a word changes into another in certain conditions. Gender is one of the factors that can cause one form of mutation. For instance, the word "girl" changes into ferch after the definite article. This only occurs with feminine singular nouns: "son" remains unchanged. Adjectives are affected by gender in a similar way.
Additionally, in many languages, gender is often closely correlated with the basic unmodified form of the noun, and sometimes a noun can be modified to produce masculine and feminine words of similar meaning.
As agreement or concord
, or concord, is a grammatical process in which certain words change their form so that values of certain grammatical categories match those of related words. Gender is one of the categories which frequently require agreement. In this case, nouns may be considered the "triggers" of the process, because they have an inherent gender, whereas related words that change their form to match the gender of the noun can be considered the "target" of these changes.These related words can be, depending on the language: determiners, pronouns, numerals, quantifiers, possessives, adjectives, past and passive participles, verbs, adverbs, complementizers, and adpositions. Gender class may be marked on the noun itself, but can also be marked on other constituents in a noun phrase or sentence. If the noun is explicitly marked, both trigger and target may feature similar alternations.
As an example, we consider Spanish, a language with two gender categories: "natural" vs "grammatical". "Natural" gender can be masculine or feminine, while "grammatical" gender can be masculine, feminine, or neuter. This third, or "neuter" gender is reserved for abstract concepts derived from adjectives: such as lo bueno, lo malo. Natural gender refers to the biological sex of most animals and people, while grammatical gender refers to certain phonetic characteristics of a noun. Among other lexical items, the definite article changes its form according to this categorization. In the singular, the article is: , and . Thus, in "natural gender", nouns referring to sexed beings who are male beings carry the masculine article, and female beings the feminine article.
| "Natural" gender | Phrase |
| Masculine | |
| Feminine |
| "Grammatical" gender | Number | Phrase |
| Masculine | Singular | |
| Masculine | Plural | |
| Feminine | Singular | |
| Feminine | Plural |
Gender inflection and number inflection
In some languages the gender is distinguished only in singular number but not in plural. In terms of linguistic markedness, these languages neutralize the gender opposition in the plural, itself a marked category. So adjectives and pronouns have three forms in singular but only one in plural . As a consequence pluralia tantum nouns cannot be assigned a gender. Example with Bulgarian: клещи, гащи, очила, хриле.Other languages, e.g. Serbo-Croatian, allow doubly marked forms both for number and gender. In these languages, each noun has a definite gender no matter the number. For example, deca "children" is feminine singularia tantum and vrata "door" is neuter pluralia tantum.
On pronouns
Pronouns may agree in gender with the noun or noun phrase to which they refer. Sometimes, however, there is no antecedent—the referent of the pronoun is deduced indirectly from the context: this is found with personal pronouns, as well as with indefinite and dummy pronouns.Personal pronouns
With personal pronouns, the gender of the pronoun is likely to agree with the natural gender of the referent. Indeed, in most European languages, personal pronouns are gendered; for example English. A parallel example is provided by the object suffixes of verbs in Arabic, which correspond to object pronouns, and which also inflect for gender in the second person :- "I love you", said to a male: '
- "I love you", said to a female: '
Issues may arise in languages with gender-specific pronouns in cases when the gender of the referent is unknown or not specified; this is a matter that arises frequently in relation to gender-neutral language, as with English usage of Singular they.
In some cases, the gender of a pronoun is not marked in the form of the pronoun itself, but is marked on other words by way of agreement. Thus the French word for 'I' is, regardless of who is speaking; but this word becomes feminine or masculine depending on the sex of the speaker, as may be reflected through adjective agreement: je suis forte ; je suis fort.
In null-subject languages, such agreement may take place even though the pronoun does not in fact appear. For example, in Portuguese:
- ' very grateful', said/written by a male: muito obrigado
- the same, by a female: muito obrigada
Indefinite and dummy pronouns
A dummy pronoun is a type of pronoun used when a particular verb argument is nonexistent, but when a reference to the argument is nevertheless syntactically required. They occur mostly in non-pro-drop languages, such as English. Examples in English are the uses of it in "It's raining" and "It's nice to relax."When a language has gendered pronouns, the use of a particular word as a dummy pronoun may involve the selection of a particular gender, even though there is no noun to agree with. In languages with a neuter gender, a neuter pronoun is usually used, as in German es regnet, where is the neuter third person singular pronoun. In languages with only masculine and feminine genders, the dummy pronoun may be the masculine third person singular, as in the French for "it's raining": il pleut ; although some languages use the feminine, as in the equivalent Welsh sentence: mae hi'n bwrw glaw.
A similar, apparently arbitrary gender assignment may need to be made in the case of indefinite pronouns, where the referent is generally unknown. In this case the question is usually not which pronoun to use, but which gender to assign a given pronoun to. For example, the French pronouns , and are all treated as masculine—this is in spite of the fact that the last two correspond to feminine nouns.
Grammatical vs. natural gender
The natural gender of a noun, pronoun or noun phrase is a gender to which it would be expected to belong based on relevant attributes of its referent. Although grammatical gender can coincide with natural gender, it does not need to.Grammatical gender can match natural gender
This usually means masculine or feminine, depending on the referent's sex. For example, in Spanish, is feminine whereas is masculine; these attributions occur solely due to the semantically inherent gender character of each noun.Grammatical gender need not match natural gender
The grammatical gender of a noun does not always coincide with its natural gender. An example of this is the German word ; this is derived from , umlauted to Mäd- with the diminutive suffix -chen, and this suffix always makes the noun grammatically neuter. Hence the grammatical gender of Mädchen is neuter, although its natural gender is feminine.Other examples include:
- Old English and , meaning "woman"
- German , meaning "woman"
- Irish cailín meaning "girl", and stail meaning "stallion"
- Portuguese mulherão, meaning "voluptuous woman"
- Scottish Gaelic boireannach, meaning "woman"
- Slovenian dekle, meaning "girl"
- Polish babsztyl, meaning "unpleasant woman"
- Czech děvče, meaning "a young girl"
When a noun with conflicting natural and grammatical gender is the antecedent of a pronoun, it may not be clear which gender of pronoun to choose. There is a certain tendency to keep the grammatical gender when a close back-reference is made, but to switch to natural gender when the reference is further away. For example, in German, the sentences "The girl has come home from school. She is now doing her homework" can be translated in two ways:
- Das Mädchen ist aus der Schule gekommen. Es macht jetzt seine Hausaufgaben.
- Das Mädchen ist aus der Schule gekommen. Sie macht jetzt ihre Hausaufgaben.
This phenomenon is quite popular in Slavic languages: for example Polish is feminine but can be used to refer to both man, woman, child or even animate nouns. Similarly with other deprecatory nouns as,,,, ; can be used deprecatively as described previously, and then can be used for verbs marked for the male and female genders.
Gender contrasts on human versus sentient referents
In the case of languages which have masculine and feminine genders, the relation between biological sex and grammatical gender tends to be less exact in the case of animals than in the case of people. In Spanish, for instance, a cheetah is always un guepardo and a zebra is always una cebra, regardless of their biological sex. In Russian a rat and a butterfly are always and . In French, a giraffe is always une girafe, whereas an elephant is always un éléphant. To specify the sex of an animal, an adjective may be added, as in un guepardo hembra, or una cebra macho. Different names for the male and the female of a species are more frequent for common pets or farm animals, English cow and bull, Spanish vaca "cow" and toro "bull", Russian баран "ram" and овца "ewe".As regards the pronouns used to refer to animals, these generally agree in gender with the nouns denoting those animals, rather than the animals' sex. In a language like English, which does not assign grammatical gender to nouns, the pronoun used for referring to objects is often used for animals also. However, if the sex of the animal is known, and particularly in the case of companion animals, the gendered pronouns may be used as they would be for a human.
In Polish, a few general words such as zwierzę or bydlę are neuter, but most species names are masculine or feminine. When the sex of an animal is known, it will normally be referred to using gendered pronouns consistent with its sex; otherwise the pronouns will correspond to the gender of the noun denoting its species.
Syntactic structure
There are multiple theoretical approaches to the position and structure of gender in syntactic structures.Categorization of nouns into genders
There are three main ways by which natural languages categorize nouns into genders:- according to their form
- according to logical or symbolic similarities in their meaning
- according to arbitrary convention.
Form-based morphological criteria
In many languages, nouns are assigned to gender largely without any semantic basis—that is, not based on any feature of the person or thing that a noun represents. In such languages there may be a correlation, to a greater or lesser degree, between gender and the form of a noun.For example, in Portuguese and Spanish, nouns that end in -o are mostly masculine, whereas those that end in -a are mostly feminine, regardless of their meaning. Nouns that end in some other vowel or a consonant are assigned a gender either according to etymology, by analogy, or by some other convention. These rules may override semantics in some cases: for example, the noun membro/miembro is always masculine, even when it refers to a girl or a woman, and pessoa/persona is always feminine, even when it refers to a boy or a man, a kind of form-meaning mismatch.
In other cases, meaning takes precedence: the noun comunista "communist" is masculine when it refers or could refer to a man, even though it ends with -a. Nouns in Spanish and Portuguese, as in the other Romance languages such as Italian and French, generally follow the gender of the Latin words from which they are derived. When nouns deviate from the rules for gender, there is usually an etymological explanation: problema is masculine in Spanish because it was derived from a Greek noun of the neuter gender, whereas foto and radio are feminine because they are clippings of fotografía and radiodifusión respectively, both grammatically feminine nouns.
Most Spanish nouns in -ión are feminine. They derive from Latin feminines in -ō, accusative -iōnem. The opposite is correct with Northern Kurdish language or Kurmanci. For example, the words endam and heval can be masculine or feminine according to the person they refer to.
- Keça wî hevala min e.
- Kurrê wî hevalê min e.
In Irish, most nouns ending with a broad consonant are masculine, those ending with a slender consonant are feminine, with significant exceptions: nouns ending in -óir/-eoir and -ín are always masculine, whereas those ending -óg/-eog or -lann are always feminine.
In Arabic, nouns whose singular form ends in a tāʾ marbūṭah are of feminine gender, the only significant exceptions being the word خليفة and certain masculine personal names. However, many masculine nouns have a "broken" plural form ending in a tāʾ marbūṭa; for example أستاذ has the plural أساتذة, which might be confused for a feminine singular noun. Gender may also be predictable from the type of derivation: for instance, the verbal nouns of Stem II are always masculine.
In French, nouns ending in -e tend to be feminine, whereas others tend to be masculine, but there are many exceptions to this, note the many masculine nouns ending in -e preceded by double consonants. Certain suffixes are quite reliable indicators, such as -age, which when added to a verb indicates a masculine noun; however, when -age is part of the root of the word, it can be feminine, as in plage or image. On the other hand, nouns ending in -tion, -sion and -aison are almost all feminine, with a few exceptions, such as cation, bastion.
Nouns can sometimes vary their form to enable the derivation of differently gendered cognate nouns; for example, to produce nouns with a similar meaning but referring to someone of a different sex. Thus, in Spanish, niño means "boy", and niña means "girl". This paradigm can be exploited for making new words: from the masculine nouns abogado "lawyer", diputado "member of parliament" and doctor "doctor", it was straightforward to make the feminine equivalents abogada, diputada, and doctora.
In the same way, personal names are frequently constructed with affixes that identify the sex of the bearer. Common feminine suffixes used in English names are -a, of Latin or Romance origin ; and -e, of French origin.
Although gender inflection may be used to construct nouns and names for people of different sexes in languages that have grammatical gender, this alone does not constitute grammatical gender. Distinct words and names for men and women are also common in languages which do not have a grammatical gender system for nouns in general. English, for example, has feminine suffixes such as -ess, and also distinguishes male and female personal names, as in the above examples.
Differentiation of personal names
Given names are proper nouns and they follow the same gender grammatical rules as common nouns. In most Indo-European languages female grammatical gender is created using an "a" or an "e" ending.Classical Latin typically made a grammatical feminine gender with -a and this was reflected in feminine names originating in that period, like Emilia. Romance languages preserved this characteristic. For example, in Spanish, approximately 89% of nouns that end in -a or -á are classified as feminine; the same is true for 98% of given names with the -a ending.
In the Germanic languages the female names have been Latinized by adding -e and -a: Brunhild, Kriemhild and Hroswith became Brunhilde, Kriemhilde and Hroswitha.
Slavic feminine given names: Olga, Małgorzata, Tetiana, Oksana, Eliška, Bronislava, Milica, Darina, Lucja, Lamija and Zala.
Differentiation of nouns with human referents
In some languages, nouns with human references have two forms, a male and a female one. This includes not only proper names, but also names for occupations and nationalities. Examples include:- English proper names:
- # male: Andrew
- # female: Andrea
- # common: Chris for both male and female
- English occupation names
- # male: waiter
- # female: waitress
- # common: doctor for both male and female
- Greek proper names Κωνσταντίνος and Κωνσταντίνα
- Greek occupation names ηθοποιός "actor" for both male and female in Greek and γιατρός "doctor" for both, but with informal female variants γιατρίνα and γιάτραινα
- Greek nationality names have five possibilities for 'English'.
- # male: Άγγλος
- # female: Αγγλίδα
- # masculine: αγγλικός
- # feminine: αγγλική
- # neuter: αγγλικό
Meaning-based semantic criteria
In some languages, gender is determined by strictly semantic criteria, but in other languages, semantic criteria only partially determine gender.Strict semantic criteria
In some languages, the gender of a noun is directly determined by its physical attributes, and there are few or no exceptions to this rule. There are relatively few such languages. The Dravidian languages use this system as described below.Another example is the Dizi language, which has two asymmetrical genders. The feminine includes all living beings of female sex and diminutives; the masculine encompasses all other nouns. In this language, feminine nouns are always marked with -e or -in.
Another African language, Defaka, has three genders: one for all male humans, one for all female humans, and a third for all the remaining nouns. Gender is only marked in personal pronouns. Standard English pronouns are very similar in this respect, although the English gendered pronouns are used for domestic animals if the sex of the animal is known, and sometimes for certain objects such as ships, e.g. "What happened to the Titanic? She sank."
Mostly semantic criteria
In some languages, the gender of nouns can mostly be determined by physical attributes, although there remain some nouns whose gender is not assigned in this way. The world view of the speakers may influence the division of categories.- Zande has four genders: male human, female human, animal, and inanimate. However, there are about 80 nouns representing inanimate entities which are nonetheless animate in gender: heavenly objects, metal objects, edible plants, and non-metallic objects. Many have a round shape or can be explained by the role they play in mythology.
- Ket has three genders, and most gender assignment is based on semantics, but there are many inanimate nouns outside the neuter class. Masculine nouns include male animates, most fish, trees, the moon, large wooden objects, most living beings and some religious items. Feminine nouns include female animates, three types of fish, some plants, the sun and other heavenly objects, some body parts and skin diseases, the soul, and some religious items. Words for part of a whole, as well as most other nouns that do not fall into any of the aforementioned classes, are neuter. The gender assignment of non-sex-differentiable things is complex. In general, those of no importance to the Kets are feminine, whereas objects of importance are masculine. Mythology is again a significant factor.
- Alamblak has two genders, masculine and feminine. However, the masculine also includes things which are tall or long and slender, or narrow, whereas the feminine gender has things which are short, squat or wide.
- In French, the distinction between the gender of a noun and the gender of the object it refers to is clear when nouns of different genders can be used for the same object, for example vélo = bicyclette.
Contextual determination of gender
There are certain situations where the assignment of gender to a noun, pronoun or noun phrase may not be straightforward. This includes in particular:- groups of mixed gender;
- references to people or things of unknown or unspecified gender.
In English, the problem of gender determination does not arise in the plural, because gender in that language is reflected only in pronouns, and the plural pronoun they does not have gendered forms. In the singular, however, the issue frequently arises when a person of unspecified or unknown gender is being referred to. In this case it the Singular they has been traditional.
Since the 18th century it has been prescribed to use the masculine, but other solutions are now often preferred.
In languages with a neuter gender, such as Slavic and Germanic languages, the neuter is often used for indeterminate gender reference, particularly when the things referred to are not people. In some cases this may even apply when referring to people, particularly children. For example, in English, one may use it to refer to a child, particularly when speaking generically rather than about a particular child of known sex.
In Icelandic, the neuter plural can be used for groups of people of mixed gender, when specific people are meant. For example:
- þau had met in the forest when the old woman was a young girl and the emperor was only a prince.'
- Sumir, have been replaced with masculine ones as men have started becoming more represented in these professions: hjúkrunarfræðingur 'nurse' and leikskólakennari 'nursery school teacher'.
In Polish, where a gender-like distinction is made in the plural between "masculine personal" and all other cases, a group is treated as masculine personal if it contains at least one male person.
In languages which preserve a three-way gender division in the plural, the rules for determining the gender of a coordinated noun phrase may be quite complex. Czech is an example of such a language, with a division between masculine animate, masculine inanimate, feminine, and neuter. The rules for gender and number of coordinated phrases in that language are summarized at.
Arbitrary conventional criteria
In some languages, any gender markers have been so eroded over time that they are no longer recognizable. Many German nouns, for example, do not indicate their gender through either meaning or form. In such cases a noun's gender must simply be memorized, and gender can be regarded as an integral part of each noun when considered as an entry in the speaker's lexicon.Second-language learners are often encouraged to memorize a modifier, usually a definite article, in conjunction with each noun—for example, a learner of French may learn the word for "chair" as la chaise ; this carries the information that the noun is chaise, and that it is feminine.
Gender shifts
It is possible for a noun to have more than one gender. Such gender shifts are sometimes correlated with meaning shifts, and sometimes yield doublets with no difference in meaning. Moreover, gender shifts sometimes crosscut number contrasts, such that the singular form of a noun has one gender, and plural form of the noun has a different gender.Meaningful
Gender shift may be associated with a difference in the sex of the referent, as with nouns such as comunista in Spanish, which may be either masculine or feminine, depending on whether it refers to a male or a female. It may also correspond to some other difference in the meaning of the word. For example, the German word See meaning "lake" is masculine, whereas the identical word meaning "sea" is feminine. The meanings of the Norwegian noun ting have diverged further: masculine en ting is "a thing", whereas neuter et ting is "an assembly".It is a matter of analysis how to draw the line between a single polysemous word with multiple genders and a set of homonyms with one gender each. For example, Bulgarian has a pair of homonyms пръст which are etymologically unrelated. One is masculine and means "finger"; the other is feminine and means "soil".
Meaningless
In other cases, a word may be usable in multiple genders indifferently. For example, in Bulgarian the word пу̀стош, may be either masculine or feminine without any change in meaning and no preference in usage.In Norwegian, many nouns can be either feminine or masculine according to the dialect, level of formality or whim of the speaker/writer. Even the two written forms of the language have many nouns whose gender is optional. Choosing the masculine gender will often seem more formal than using the feminine. This might be because before the creation of Norwegian Nynorsk and Norwegian Bokmål in the late 19th century, Norwegians wrote in Danish, which has lost the feminine gender, thus usage of the masculine gender is more formal sounding to modern Norwegians.
The word for "sun" can be another example. One might decline it masculine: En sol, solen, soler, solene, or feminine: Ei sol, sola, soler, solene, in Norwegian Bokmål. The same goes for a lot of common words like bok, dukke, bøtte and so forth. Many of the words where it is possible to choose gender are inanimate objects that one might suspect would be conjugated with the neuter gender. Nouns conjugated with the neuter gender cannot normally be conjugated as feminine or masculine in Norwegian. There is also a slight tendency towards using the masculine indefinite article even when choosing the feminine conjugation of a noun in many eastern Norwegian dialects. For instance, the word for "girl" is declined: En jente, jenta, jenter, jentene.
Associated with number contrasts
Sometimes a noun's gender can change between its plural and singular forms, as with the French words amour, délice and orgue, all of which are masculine in the singular but feminine in the plural. These anomalies may have a historical explanation or result from slightly different notions. Further examples are the Italian words uovo and braccio. These are masculine in the singular, but form the irregular plurals uova and braccia, which have the endings of the feminine singular, but have feminine plural agreement. In other cases, the anomaly can be explained by the form of the noun, as is the case in Scottish Gaelic. Masculine nouns which form their plural by palatalization of their final consonant can change gender in their plural form, as a palatalized final consonant is often a marker of a feminine noun, e.g. balach beag, but balaich bheaga, with the adjective showing agreement for both feminine gender and plural number.Gender across languages
Related languages need not assign the same gender to a noun: this shows that gender can vary across related languages. Conversely, unrelated languages that are in contact can impact how a borrowed noun is assigned gender, with either the borrowing or the donor language determining the gender of the borrowed word.Gender can vary across related languages
Nouns which have the same meanings in different languages need not have the same gender. This is particularly so in the case of things with no natural gender, such as sexless objects. For example, there is, by all appearances, nothing about a table that should cause it to be associated with any particular gender, and different languages' words for "table" are found to have various genders: feminine, as with the French table; masculine, as with German Tisch; or neuter, as with Norwegian bord.Cognate nouns in closely related languages are likely to have the same gender, because they tend to inherit the gender of the original word in the parent language. For instance, in the Romance languages, the words for "sun" are masculine, being derived from the Latin masculine noun sol, whereas the words for "moon" are feminine, being derived from the Latin feminine luna. However, there are exceptions to this principle. For instance, latte is masculine in Italian, whereas Spanish leche is feminine and Romanian lapte is neuter. Likewise, the word for "boat" is neuter in German, but common gender in Swedish.
Some more examples of the above phenomena are given [|below].
- The Russian word луна is feminine, whereas месяц is masculine. In Polish, another Slavic language, the word for moon is księżyc, which is masculine.
- Russian also has two words for "potato": картофель which is masculine, and картошка which is feminine.
- In Polish the loanword tramwaj is masculine, whereas the cognate loanword in Czech, tramvaj, is feminine.
- The Polish word tysiąc is masculine, whereas the cognate in Russian, тысяча, is feminine, while the Icelandic cognate þúsund is neuter.
- The Spanish word origen is masculine, but its close relatives origem, orixe and origem/ orixe from Galician are feminine.
- The French word équipe is feminine, while the Spanish word equipo is masculine. The Spanish form contrasts with the Portuguese equipa/equipe, both of which are feminine.
- The Italian word scimmia is feminine, whereas the Spanish word simio is masculine.
- The French word mer is feminine, but the Spanish cognate mar is generally masculine, whereas the Catalan cognate mar can be masculine or feminine, depending on the dialect. All these words mean "sea" and are descended from the Latin mare, which was neuter.
How languages assign gender to borrowed words
Borrowed words are assigned gender in one of two ways:- via criteria determined by the borrowing language;
- via criteria determined by the donor language.
Borrowing language can determine gender
Ibrahim identifies several processes by which a language assigns a gender to a newly borrowed word; these processes follow patterns by which even children, through their subconscious recognition of patterns, can often correctly predict a noun's gender.- If the noun is animate, natural gender tends to dictate grammatical gender.
- The borrowed word tends to take the gender of the native word it replaces. According to Ghil'ad Zuckermann, morphemic adaptations of English words into American Italian or British Italian are abundant with such cases. For example, the feminine gender of the British Italian word bagga "bag" was induced by the feminine gender of the Italian word borsa "bag".
- If the borrowed word happens to have a suffix that the borrowing language uses as a gender marker, the suffix tends to dictate gender.
- If the borrowed word rhymes with one or more native words, the latter tend to dictate gender.
- The default assignment is the borrowing language's unmarked gender.
- Rarely, the word retains the gender it had in the donor language. This tends to happen more frequently in more formal language such as scientific terms, where some knowledge of the donor language can be expected.
Donor language can determine gender
argues that the cross-lingual retention of grammatical gender can change not only the lexis of the target language but also its morphology. For example, gender can indirectly influence the productivity of noun-patterns in what he calls the "Israeli" language: the Israeli neologism מברשת is fitted into the feminine noun-pattern mi⌂⌂é⌂et because of the feminine gender of the matched words for "brush" such as Arabic, Yiddish barsht, Russian, Polish kiść and szczotka, German Bürste and French brosse, all feminine.Similarly, argues Zuckermann, the Israeli neologism for "library", ספריה, matches the feminine gender of the parallel pre-existent European words: Yiddish, Russian, Polish biblioteka, German Bibliothek and French bibliothèque, as well as of the pre-existent Arabic word for "library": مكتبة as a productive feminine locative suffix ).
Distribution of gender in the world's languages
Grammatical gender is a common phenomenon in the world's languages. A typological survey of 174 languages revealed that over one quarter of them had grammatical gender. Gender systems rarely overlap with numerical classifier systems. Gender and noun class systems are usually found in fusional or agglutinating languages, whereas classifiers are more typical of isolating languages. Thus, according to Johanna Nichols, these characteristics correlate positively with the presence of grammatical gender in the world's languages:- location in an area with languages featuring noun classes;
- preference for head-marking morphology;
- moderate to high morphological complexity;
- non-accusative alignment.
Conversely, grammatical gender is usually absent from the Koreanic, Japonic, Tungusic, Turkic, Mongolic, Austronesian, Sino-Tibetan, Uralic and most Native American language families.
Modern English makes use of gender in pronouns, which are generally marked for natural gender, but lacks a system of gender concord within the noun phrase which is one of the central elements of grammatical gender in most other Indo-European languages.
Indo-European
Many Indo-European languages, but not English, provide examples of grammatical gender.Research indicates that the earliest stages of Proto-Indo-European had two genders, as did Hittite, the earliest attested Indo-European language. The classification of nouns based on animacy and inanimacy and the lack of gender are today characteristic of Armenian. According to the theory, the animate gender, which had independent vocative and accusative forms, later split into masculine and feminine, thus originating the three-way classification into masculine, feminine and neuter.
Many Indo-European languages retained the three genders, including most Slavic languages, Latin, Sanskrit, Ancient and Modern Greek, German, Icelandic, Romanian and Asturian. In them, there is a high but not absolute correlation between grammatical gender and declensional class. Many linguists believe that to be true of the middle and late stages of Proto-Indo-European.
However, many languages reduced the number of genders to two. Some lost the neuter, leaving masculine and feminine as in [Vulgar Latin#Loss of neuter gender|Vulgar Latin then most Romance languages]; a few traces of the Latin neuter remain, such as the distinct Spanish pronoun ello and Italian nouns with so-called "mobile gender"). Hindustani and the Celtic languages also dropped neuter. Others merged feminine and masculine into a common gender but retained the neuter, as [Gender in Danish and Swedish|in Swedish and Danish], and to some extent in Dutch grammar|in Dutch]. Finally, some languages, such as English and Afrikaans, have nearly completely lost grammatical gender ; Armenian, Bengali, Persian, Sorani Kurdish, Ossetic, Odia, Khowar, and Kalasha-mun have lost it entirely.
On the other hand, some Slavic languages can be argued to have added new genders to the classical three.
Germanic: English
Although grammatical gender was a fully productive inflectional category in Old English, Modern English has a much less pervasive gender system, primarily based on natural gender and reflected essentially in pronouns only.There are a few traces of gender marking in Modern English:
- Some words take different derived forms depending on the natural gender of the referent, such as waiter/waitress and widow/widower.
- The third-person singular personal pronouns are gender specific: he/him/his, she/her, the singular they/them/their, and it/its.
Only a relatively small number of English nouns have distinct male and female forms; many of them are loanwords from non-Germanic languages. English has no live productive gender markers. An example of such a marker might be the suffix -ette, but this is seldom used today, surviving mostly in either historical contexts or with disparaging or humorous intent.
The gender of an English pronoun typically coincides with the natural gender of its referent, rather than with the grammatical gender of its antecedent. The choice between she, he, they, and it comes down to whether the pronoun is intended to designate a woman, a man, or someone or something else. There are certain exceptions, however:
- With animals, it is usually used, but when the sex of the animal is known, it may be referred to as he or she, particularly when expressing an emotional connection with the animal, as with a pet.
- Certain non-human things can be referred to with the pronoun she, particularly countries and ships, and sometimes other vehicles or machines. This figure of speech is referred to as metaphorical gender. It is in decline, and advised against by many style guides.
Slavic languages
The Slavic languages mostly continue the Proto-Indo-European system of three genders, masculine, feminine and neuter. Gender correlates largely with noun endings but there are many exceptions, particularly in the case of nouns whose stems end in a soft consonant. However, some of the languages, including Russian, Czech, Slovak and Polish, also make certain additional grammatical distinctions between animate and inanimate nouns: Polish in the plural, and Russian in the accusative case, differentiate between human and non-human nouns.In Russian, the different treatment of animate nouns involves their accusative case being formed identically to the genitive rather than to the nominative. In the singular that applies to masculine nouns only, but in the plural it applies in all genders.
A similar system applies in Czech, but the situation is somewhat different in the plural: Only masculine nouns are affected, and the distinctive feature is a particular inflective ending for masculine animate nouns in the nominative plural, and for adjectives and verbs agreeing with those nouns.
Polish morphology might be said to distinguish five genders: personal masculine, animate non-personal masculine, inanimate masculine, feminine, and neuter. The animate–inanimate opposition for the masculine gender applies in the singular, and the personal–impersonal opposition, which classes animals along with inanimate objects, applies in the plural. The manifestations of the differences are as follows:
- In the singular, masculine animates have an accusative form identical to the genitive, and masculine inanimates have accusative identical to the nominative. The same applies to adjectives qualifying these nouns, the same as in Russian and Czech. Also, Polish masculine animates always form their genitive in -a, whereas in the case of inanimates some use -a and some -u:
- :animate: dobry klient ; dobrego klienta
- :animate: dobry pies ; dobrego psa
- :inanimate: dobry ser ; dobrego sera
- In the plural, masculine personal nouns take accusatives that are identical to the genitives; they also typically take different endings in the nominative . Examples of the Polish system:
- :personal: dobrzy klienci ; dobrych klientów
- :impersonal: dobre psy ; dobrych psów
- :impersonal: dobre sery ; dobrych serów