Linguistic areas of the Americas
The indigenous languages of the Americas form various linguistic areas or Sprachbunds that share various common traits. The following list of linguistic areas is primarily based on Campbell.
Overview
The languages of the Americas often can be grouped together into linguistic areas or Sprachbunds. The linguistic areas identified so far deserve more research to determine their validity. Knowing about Sprachbunds helps historical linguists differentiate between shared areal traits and true genetic relationship. The pioneering work on American areal linguistics was a dissertation by Joel Sherzer, which was published as Sherzer.Lyle Campbell lists over 20 linguistic areas, many of which are still hypothetical.
Note: Some linguistic areas may overlap with others.
Lexical diffusion
Pache, et al. note that the word ‘dog’ is shared across various unrelated language families of the Americas, and use this word as a case study of lexical diffusion due to trade and contact.In California, identical roots for ‘dog’ are found in:
- Yurok cʼišah, Karuk čišiːh, Takelma cʼíxi, Yokuts *cʼɨːsas
- Chimariko šičela, Wintu se-cilaː ‘to tear apart’
- Wintun *suku, Maiduan *sɨː, Washo súkuʔ, Miwok *hayu, Costanoan. Pache, et al. posit a Wintun origin for this root.
- *hayu root in Miwok, Pomoan, Wappo, and Hill Patwin
- Ramaytush puku, Uto-Aztecan *punku
- Costanoan, Esselen hučumas, Salinan, Chumash
- Proto-Mixe-Zoquean *ʔuku > Proto-Zapotec *kweʔkkoʔ > Huastec pik’oʔ, Yucatec pè:k’
- P’urhépecha wiču > Chontal wičuʔ
- Totonacan čiči > Classical Nahuatl ''čiči''
North America
Northern Northwest Coast
This linguistic area was proposed by Jeff Leer, and may be a subarea of the Northwest Coast Linguistic Area. This sprachbund contains languages that have strict head-final syntax. Languages are Aleut, Haida, Eyak, and Tlingit.Leer considers the strong areal traits to be:
- lack of labial obstruents
- promiscuous number marking
- periphrastic possessive construction
Northwest Coast
This linguistic area is characterized by elaborate consonant systems. Languages are Eyak, Tlingit, Athabaskan, Tsimshian, Wakashan, Chimakuan, Salishan, Alsea, Coosan, Kalapuyan, Takelma, and Lower Chinook. Phonological areal traits include:- Series of glottalized stops and affricates
- Labiovelars
- Multiple laterals
- s/š opposition
- c/č opposition
- voiceless uvular stop q
- one fricative series, which is voiceless
- velar fricatives
- highly limited inventory of labial consonants
- large inventory of uvular consonants
- limited vowel systems
- reduplication processes: including iterative, continuative, progressive, plural, collective
- numeral classifiers
- alienable/inalienable oppositions in nouns
- pronominal plural
- nominal plural
- verbal reduplication signifying distribution, repetition, etc.
- suffixation of tense-aspect markers in verbs
- verbal evidential markers
- locative-directional markers in the verb
- visibility/invisibility opposition in demonstratives
- nominal and verbal reduplication signaling the diminutive
- passive-like constructions
- negative appearing as the first element in a clause regardless of the usual word order
- lexically paired singular and plural verb stems
Plateau
The Plateau linguistic area includes Sahaptian, Upper Chinook, Nicola, Cayuse, Molala language, Klamath, Kutenai, and Interior Salishan. Primary shared phonological features of this linguistic area include:- glottalized stops
- velar/uvular contrasting series
- multiple laterals
- labiovelars
- one fricative series
- velar fricatives
- series of glottalized resonants contrasting with plain resonants
- word-medial and word-final consonant clusters of four or more consonants
- vowel systems of only 3 or 4 vowel positions
- vowel-length contrast
- size-shape-affective sound symbolism involving consonantal interchanges
- pronominal plural
- nominal plural
- prefixation of subject person markers of verbs
- suffixation of tense-aspect markers in verbs
- several kinds of reduplication
- numeral classifiers
- locative-directional markers in verbs
- different roots of the singular and the plural for various actions, such as 'sit', 'stand', 'take'
- quinary-decimal numerical system
Northern California
The Northern California linguistic area consists of many Hokan languages. Languages include Algic, Athabaskan, Yukian, Miwokan, Wintuan, Maiduan, Klamath-Modoc, Pomo, Chimariko, Achomawi, Atsugewi, Karuk, Shasta, Yana,.Features of this linguistic area have been described by Mary Haas. They include:
- rarity of uvular consonants: they occur in Klamath, Wintu, Chimariko, and Pomoan
- retroflexed stops
- rarity of a distinct series of voiced stops except in the east–west strip of languages including Kashaya Pomo, Wintu-Patwin, and Maidu
- consonant sound symbolism: in Yurok, Wiyot, Hupa, Tolowa, Karuk, and Yana
- pronominal dual
- quinary/decimal numeral system
- absence of vowel-initial syllables
- free stress
Northwest California
Northwest California is a subarea of the Northern California linguistic area. It includes Wiyot, Yurok, Hupa, and Karuk.Central California
Golla notes that Esselen shares typological features with Utian, Miwok, Costanoan, such as "the absence of a glottalized series, and... a relatively analytic morphosyntax", which are also similar to typological features found in Northern Uto-Aztecan languages. He suggests that there was a linguistic area that stretched from the Sierra Nevada through Sacramento, and from the San Joaquin Delta to the San Francisco Bay.Shaul also proposes typological connections between Esselen, Salinan, Chumashan, some Utian languages, and Uto-Aztecan. Similarities between Utian and various neighboring language families have also been noted by Callaghan.
Clear Lake
Clear Lake is clearly a linguistic area, and is centered around Clear Lake, California. Languages are Lake Miwok, Patwin, East and Southeastern Pomo, and Wappo. Shared features include:- retroflexed dentals
- voiceless l
- glottalized glides
- 3 series of stops
South Coast Range
Languages in Sherzer's "Yokuts-Salinan-Chumash" area, which includes Chumash, Esselen, and Salinan, share the following traits.- 3 series of stops - also in the Clear Lake area
- retroflexed sounds - also in the Clear Lake area
- glottalized resonants
- prefixation of verbal subject markers)
- presence of /h, ɨ, c, ŋ/ in the Greater South Coast Range area
- t/ṭ contrast in the Greater South Coast Range area, as well as other parts of California
Great Basin
This linguistic area is defined by Sherzer and Jacobsen. Languages are Numic and Washo. Shared traits include:- k/kʷ contrast
- bilabial fricatives /ɸ, β/
- presence of /xʷ, ŋ, ɨ/
- overtly marked nominal system
- inclusive/exclusive pronominal distinction
Southern California–Western Arizona
This linguistic area has been demonstrated in Hinton. Languages are Yuman, Cupan, and less extensively Takic. Shared traits include:- k/q distinction
- presence of /kʷ, tʃ, x/
- kʷ/qʷ contrast
- s/ʂ contrast
- r/l contrast
- presence of /xʷ, ɲ, lʲ/
- small vowel inventory
- sound symbolism
Shaul and Andresen have proposed a Southwestern Arizona linguistic area as well, where speakers of Piman languages are hypothesized to have interacted with speakers of Yuman languages as part of the Hohokam archaeological culture. The single trait defining this area is the presence of retroflex stops.
Pueblo
The Pueblo linguistic area consists of Keresan, Tanoan, Zuni, Hopi, and some Apachean branches.Plains
The Plains Linguistic Area, according to Sherzer, is the "most recently constituted of the culture areas of North America." Languages are Athabaskan, Algonquian, Siouan, Tanoan, Uto-Aztecan, and Tonkawa. The following areal traits are characteristic of this linguistic area, though they are also common in other parts of North America.- prefixation of subject person markers in verbs
- pronominal plurals
- one stop series
- the voiceless velar fricative /x/
- alienable/inalienable opposition in nouns
- nominal plural suffix
- inclusive/exclusive opposition
- nominal diminutive suffix
- animate/inanimate gender
- evidential markers in verbs
- lack of labiovelars
- presence of /ð/
- phonemic pitch
- presence of /kʷ, r/
- voiced/voiceless fricatives
Northeast
The Northeast linguistic area consists of Winnebago, Northern Iroquoian, and Eastern Algonquian. Central areal traits of the Northeast Linguistic Area include the following.- a single series of stops
- a single series of fricatives
- presence of /h/
- nominal plural
- noun incorporation
- vowel system with /i, e, o, a/
- nasalized vowels
- pronominal dual
- nasalized vowels ; for instance, Proto-Eastern Algonquian
* a- is nasalized due to influence from Iroquioan languages, which have two nasalized vowels in its proto-language,* ɛ̃ and* õ. - pronominal dual
Southeast
Gulf languages include Muskogean, Chitimacha, Atakapa, Tunica language, Natchez, Yuchi, Ofo, Biloxi –sometimes also Tutelo, Catawban, Quapaw, Dhegiha ; Tuscarora, Cherokee, and Shawnee.
Bilabial or labial fricatives are considered by Sherzer to be the most characteristic trait of the Southeast Linguistic Area. Various other shared traits have been found by Robert L. Rankin and T. Dale Nicklas.
Mesoamerican
This linguistic area consists of the following language families and branches.Some languages formerly considered to be part of the Mesoamerican sprachbund, but are now considered to lack main diagnostic traits of Mesoamerican area languages, include Cora, Huichol, Lenca, Jicaquean, and Misumalpan.
Mayan
The Mayan Linguistic Area is considered by most scholars to be part of the Mesoamerican area. However, Holt & Bright distinguish it as a separate area, and include the Mayan, Xincan, Lencan, and Jicaquean families as part of the Mayan Linguistic Area. Shared traits include:- presence of glottalized consonants and alveolar affricates
- absence of voiced obstruents and labiovelar stops
South America
Colombian–Central American
Colombian–Central American consists of Chibchan, Misumalpan, Mangue, and Subtiaba; sometimes Lencan, Jicaquean, Chocoan, and Betoi are also included.This linguistic area is characterized by SOV word order and postpositions. This stands in contrast to the Mesoamerican Linguistic Area, where languages do not have SOV word order.
Holt & Bright define a Central American Linguistic Area as having the following areal traits. Note that these stand in direct opposition to the traits defined in their Mayan Linguistic Area.
- presence of voiced obstruents and labiovelar stops
- absence of glottalized consonants and alveolar affricates
- voicing opposition in stops and fricatives
- exclusive SOV word order
- postpositions
- mostly Genitive-Noun order
- Noun-Adjective order
- Noun-Numeral order
- clause-initial question words
- suffixation or postposed particle for negatives
- absence of gender opposition in pronouns and inflection
- absence of possessed/nonpossessed and alienable/inalienable possession oppositions
- "morpholexical economy" - presence of lexical compounds rather than independent roots. This is similar to calques found in Mesoamerica, but with a more limited number of compounding elements. For instance, in Guatuso, there is one compounding element of liquid substances, one compounding element for pointed extremities, one for flat surfaces, and so on.
Venezuelan–Antillean
This linguistic area, consisting of Arawakan, Cariban, Guamo, Otomaco, Yaruro, and Warao, is characterized by VO word order, and is described by Constenla. Shared traits are:- exclusive VO word order, and absence of SOV word order
- absence of voicing opposition in obstruents
- Numeral-Noun order
- Noun-Genitive order
- presence of prepositions
Andean
This linguistic area, consisting of Quechuan, Aymaran, Callahuaya, and Chipaya, is characterized by SOV word order and elaborate suffixing.Quechuan and Aymaran languages both have:
- SOV basic word order
- suffixing morphology; other similar morphological structures
- glottalized stops and affricates
- aspirated stops and affricates
- uvular stops
- presence of /ɲ, lʲ/
- retroflexed affricates - more limited in distribution
- absence of glottal stop /ʔ/
- limited vowel systems with /i, a, u/
- absence of the high-mid opposition in back vowels
- absence of the opposition of voiced/voiceless affricates
- presence of the voiceless alveolar affricate, voiceless prepalatal fricative, palatal lateral, palatal nasal, retroflexed fricatives or affricates
- Adjective-Noun order
- clause-initial interrogative words
- accusative case
- genitive case
- passive construction
Statistical studies
Quantitative studies on the Andes and overlapping areas have found the following traits to be characteristic of these areas in a statistically significant way.Morphosyntactic features
A statistical study of argument marking features in languages of South America found that both the Andes and Western South America constitute linguistic areas, with some traits showing a statistically significant relationship to both areas. The unique and shared traits of the two areas are shown in the following table.| Andes only | Both Andes and Western South America | Western South America only |
| Subject-object-verb constituent order | Use of both case and indexation as argument marking strategies | Marked neutral case marking patterns in ditransitive constructions |
| Suffixes as verbal person markers | Verbally marked applicative constructions | |
| The R argument role can be indexed in ditransitive constructions | ||
| Accusative case alignment for NP arguments |
Phonological features
Phonologically, the following segments and segmental features are areal for the Andes:Consonants
- A contrast between aspirated and ejective in the stops and the postalveolar affricate
- A "comparatively large number of affricates, fricatives, and liquids"
- The palatal place of articulation
- The uvular place of articulation
- The absence of the following types of consonants:
- *Voiced alveolar stop and affricate
- *Labialized velar voiceless stop and nasal
- *Voiced bilabial and voiceless labiodental fricatives
- *Glottal stop and fricative
Vowels
- The presence of short /u/ and long /iː, uː, aː/
- The absence of mid and non-low central vowels and nasal vowels, and "long versions of many of these vowels."
Amazon
The Amazon linguistic area includes the Arawakan/Maipurean, Arauan/Arawan, Cariban, Chapacuran, Ge/Je, Panoan, Puinavean, Tacanan, Tucanoan, and Tupian families.Derbyshire & Pullum and Derbyshire describe the characteristics of this linguistic area in detail. Traits include:
- objects preceding subjects, such as VOS, OVS, and OSV; word order in OVS and OSV languages tends to be highly flexible
- verb agreement with both subject and object
- predictability of when subjects and objects will be full noun phrases or when they will be signalled by verbal affixes
- use of nominalizations for relative clauses and other subordinate clauses
- nominal modifiers following their head nouns
- no agentive passive constructions
- indirect-speech forms are nonexistent in most languages and rare in the languages that do have them; thus, they rely on direct speech constructions
- absence of coordinating conjunctions
- extensive use of right-dislocated paratactic constructions
- extensive use of particles that are phrasal subconstituents syntactically and phonologically, but are sentence operators or modifiers semantically
- tendency toward ergative subject marking
- highly complex morphology
- Numeral: lexico-syntactic forms, which are often obligatory in expressions of quantity and normally are separate words.
- Concordial: a closed grammatical system, consisting of morphological affixes or clitics and expressing class agreement with some head noun. However, they may also occur on nouns or verbs.
- Verb incorporation: lexical items are incorporated into the verb stem, signalling some classifying entity of the associated noun phrase.
- ergatively organized systems
- evidence of historical drift from ergative to accusative marking
- certain types of split systems
Lucy Seki has also proposed an Upper Xingu Linguistic Area in northern Brazil.
Validity
The validity of Amazonia as a linguistic area has been called into question by recent research, including quantitative studies. A study of argument marking parameters in 74 South American languages by Joshua Birchall found that “not a single feature showed an areal distribution for Amazonia as a macroregion. This suggests that Amazonia is not a good candidate for a linguistic area based on the features examined in this study.” Instead, Birchall finds evidence for three “macroregions” in South America: the Andes, Western South America, and Eastern South America, with some overlap in features between the Andes and Western South America.Based on that study and similar findings, Patience Epps and Lev Michael claim that “an emerging consensus points to Amazonia not forming a linguistic area sensu strictu.”
Epps shows that Wanderwörter are spread across the languages of Amazonia. Morphosyntax is also heavily borrowed across neighboring unrelated Amazonian languages.
Ecuadorian–Colombian
This is a subarea of the Andean Linguistic Area, as defined by Constenla. Languages include Páez, Guambiano, Cuaiquer, Cayapa, Colorado, Camsá, Cofán, Esmeralda, and Ecuadorian Quechua. Shared traits are:- high-mid opposition in front vowels
- absence of glottalized consonants
- presence of the glottal stop /ʔ/ and voiceless bilabial fricative /ɸ/
- absence of uvular stops /q, ɢ/
- rounding opposition in non-front vowels
- lack of person inflection in nouns
- prefixes expressing tense or aspect distinctions
Vaupés (Vaupés–Içana)
The Vaupés linguistic area includes Eastern Tukanoan, Arawakan, Nadahup, and Kakua–Nukak language families, along with the local lingua franca Nheengatú. The linguistic area has been well studied by various linguists.Shared areal traits include:
- nominal classification systems
- evidentiality
- serial verb constructions
- shared tense-aspect-mood values
- lexical calquing
Caquetá–Putumayo
The Caquetá–Putumayo linguistic area includes:Shared traits include:
- first-person plural inclusive/exclusive contrast
- second-position tense-aspect-mood clitics
- loss of object cross-referencing suffixes
- verbal morphology restructuring
- borrowing of classifiers
- inhibition against lexical borrowing
- classifier systems
- /ɨ/
Orinoco–Amazon
The Orinoco–Amazon Linguistic Area, or the Northern Amazon Culture Area, is identified by Migliazza. Languages include Yanomaman, Piaroa, Arawakan/Maipurean, Cariban, Jotí, Uruak/Ahuaqué, Sapé, and Jukude. Common areal traits are:- a shared pattern of discourse redundancy
- ergative alignment
- objects preceding verbs, such as SOV and OVS word order
- lack of active-passive distinction
- relative clauses formed by apposition and nominalization
- nasalization
- aspiration
- glottalization
Southern Guiana (Northeastern Amazonian)
The Southern Guiana linguistic area includes mostly Cariban languages, some Arawakan languages, Sálivan languages, Tupí-Guaranían languages, and Taruma. Yanomaman, Warao, Arutani, Sapé, and Jukude are sometimes also included.According to Carlin, the Arawakan language Mawayana has borrowed many grammatical features from Cariban languages, particularly Tiriyó and Waiwai. On the other hand, Wapishana, an Arawakan language that is closely related Mawayana, lacks these features.
Shared grammatical features, Epps and Michael, and Lüpke et al. ) include:
- first-person plural exclusive distinction
- nominal tense marking
- marking on nouns or verbs to express ‘pity’ or ‘recognition of unfortunate circumstance’
- frustrative marker on verbs
- ‘similative’ marker on nominals
Tocantins–Mearim Interfluvium
The Tocantins–Mearim Interfluvium linguistic area includes several Tupí–Guaranían and Jêan languages.- Teneteháran branch: Guajajára, Tembé, and Turiwára
- Northern Tupí-Guaranían branch: Guajá and Urubú-Ka'apór
- Xingu branch: Anambé, Amanajé, and Ararandewára
- Tupí branch: Tupinambá and Língua Geral Amazônica
- Jêan: Timbira
- change in a grammatical particle
- change in gerund
- loss of first-person plural inclusive-exclusive contrast
- argumentative case
Upper Xingu
The Upper Xingu linguistic area includes more than a dozen languages belonging to the Cariban, Arawakan, Jêan, and Tupían families, as well as the language isolate Trumai.Lucy Seki Xingu is an "incipient" linguistic area, since many of the languages had arrived in the Upper Xingu area after the arrival of the Portuguese. Shared linguistic traits include:
- loss of a masculine-feminine gender distinction in the Arawakan languages of the region
- diffusion of /ɨ/ into Xingu Arawakan languages from their Cariban or Tupí-Guaranían neighbors
- p > h shift in Cariban and Tupí-Guaranían
- change to CV syllable structure in Cariban
- diffusion of /ts/ into the Xingu Cariban languages from Arawakan
- diffusion of nasal vowels into the Xingu Arawakan and Cariban languages from neighboring Tupí-Guaranían languages
Mamoré–Guaporé
Crevels and van der Voort propose a Mamoré–Guaporé linguistic area in eastern lowland Bolivia and Rondonia, Brazil. In Bolivia, many of the languages were historically spoken at the Jesuit Missions of Moxos and also the Jesuit Missions of Chiquitos.According to Campbell, the Mamoré–Guaporé or Guaporé–Mamoré linguistic area includes over 50 languages from 17 different families. Language families and branches in the linguistic area include Arawakan, Chapacuran, Jabuti, Rikbaktsá, Nambikwaran, Pano-Tacanan, and Tupian languages. Language isolates in the linguistic area are Cayuvava, Itonama, Movima, Chimane/Mosetén, Canichana, Yuracaré, Leco, Mure, Aikanã, Kanoê, and Kwazá, Irantxe, and Chiquitano. Areal features include:
- a high incidence of prefixes
- evidentials
- directionals
- verbal number
- lack of nominal number
- lack of classifiers
- inclusive/exclusive distinction
Chaco
According to Campbell, the Gran Chaco linguistic area includes Charrúan, Enlhet-Enenlhet, Guaicurúan, Guachí, Lule-Vilelan, Matacoan, Payaguá, Zamucoan, and some Tupí-Guaranían languages.Campbell and Grondona consider the Mataco–Guaicuru, Mascoyan, Lule-Vilelan, Zamucoan, and some southern Tupi-Guarani languages to be part of a Chaco linguistic area. Common Chaco areal features include SVO word order and active-stative alignment. Other shared traits, some of which are also found outside the Gran Chaco area, include:
- gender that is not overtly marked on nouns, but is present in demonstratives, depending on the gender of the nouns modified
- genitive classifiers for possessed domestic animals
- SVO word order
- active-stative verb alignment
- large set of directional verbal affixes
- demonstrative system with rich contrasts including visible vs. not visible
- some adjectives as polar negatives
- resistance to borrowing foreign words
South Cone
The languages of the South Cone area, including Mapudungun, Guaycuruan, and Chon, share the following traits :- Semantic notions of position signaled morphologically by means of "many devices to situate the visual location of the noun subject or object relative to the speaker; tense, aspect and number are expressed as part of the morphology of location, direction, and motion".
- palatalization
- more back consonants than front consonants
- SVO basic word order