| Institution | Location | Founded | Affiliation | Enrollment | Nickname | Joined | Left | FB? | Current
primary
conference |
| Alfred State College | Alfred, New York | 1908 | Public | 3,500 | Pioneers | 2013 | 2017 | Yes | Allegheny Mountain (AMCC) |
| Alverno College | Milwaukee, Wisconsin | 1887 | Catholic
| 1,664 | Inferno | 2000 | 2004 | No | Northern Athletics (NACC) |
| Asbury University | Wilmore, Kentucky | 1890 | Christian | 1,054 | Eagles | 2021 | 2024 | No | C.C. South (CCS) |
| Bard College | Annandale-on-
Hudson, New York | 1860 | Episcopal | 1,958 | Raptors | 1990 | 2004 | No | Liberty (LL) |
| Berea College | Berea, Kentucky | 1855 | Christian
| 1,613 | Mountaineers | 2014 | 2017 | No | Heartland (HCAC) |
| Binghamton University | Vestal, New York | 1844 | Public | 17,768 | Bearcats | 1997 | 1998 | No | America East (AmEC) |
| Bluffton University | Bluffton, Ohio | 1899 | Mennonite | 1,094 | Beavers | 1996 | 1998 | Yes | Heartland (HCAC) |
| Bob Jones University | Greenville, South Carolina | 1927 | Nondenominational | 2,916 | Bruins | 2020 | 2023 | No | NCCAA Independent |
| Bryn Athyn College | Bryn Athyn, Pennsylvania | 1877 | New Church | 330 | Lions | 2013 | 2014 | No | N/A |
| Cairn University | Langhorne, Pennsylvania | 1913 | Nondenominational | 2,200 | Highlanders | 2001 | 2004 | No | United East |
| Castleton University | Castleton, Vermont | 1787 | Public | 2,399 | Spartans | 1973 | 2001 | Yes | N/A |
| Centenary University | Hackettstown,
New Jersey | 1867 | United Methodist | 1,597 | Cyclones | 1997 | 2003 | No | Atlantic East (AEC) |
| Chapman University | Orange, California | 1861 | DoC & UCC | 10,001 | Panthers | 1994 | 2011 | Yes | Southern California (SCIAC) |
| Chowan University | Murfreesboro,
North Carolina | 1848 | Baptist | 981 | Hawks | 2004 | 2007 | Yes | Carolinas (CC) |
| Clarks Summit University | Clarks Summit, Pennsylvania | 1932 | Baptist | 1,142 | Defenders | 1996 | 2004 | No | Closed in 2024 |
| Colorado College | Colorado Springs,
Colorado | 1874 | Nonsectarian | 2,266 | Tigers | 1973 | 2006 | No | Southern (SCAC) |
| Irving, Texas | 1956 | Catholic | 2,538 | Crusaders | 2001;
2010 | 2008;
2011 | No | Southern (SCAC) |
| Defiance College | Defiance, Ohio | 1850 | UCC | 1,000 | Yellow Jackets | 1995 | 1997 | Yes | Wolverine–Hoosier (WHAC) |
| Farmingdale State College | East Farmingdale,
New York | 1912 | Public | 8,162 | Rams | 2001 | 2003 | No | Skyline |
| Finlandia University | Hancock, Michigan | 1896 | Lutheran
| 507 | Lions | 2002 | 2017 | No | Closed in 2023 |
| Franciscan University of Steubenville | Steubenville, Ohio | 1946 | Catholic
| 2,716 | Barons | 2007 | 2008 | No | Presidents' (PAC) |
| Green Mountain College | Poultney, Vermont | 1834 | United Methodist | N/A | Eagles | 2005 | 2008 | No | Closed in 2019 |
| Husson University | Bangor, Maine | 1898 | Nonsectarian | 3,476 | Eagles | 2001 | 2003 | Yes | North Atlantic (NAC) |
| Illinois Institute of Technology | Chicago, Illinois | 1890 | Nonsectarian | 2,977 | Scarlet Hawks | 2013 | 2018 | No | Northern Athletics (NACC) |
| La Sierra University | Riverside, California | 1922 | Seventh-day
Adventist | 2,199 | Golden Eagles | 2006 | 2010 | No | California Pacific (CalPac) |
| Lancaster Bible College | Lancaster, Pennsylvania | 1933 | Nondenominational | 954 | Chargers | 2006 | 2011 | No | United East |
| Lincoln University | Oxford, Pennsylvania | 1854 | Public | 2,650 | Lions | 1973 | 2008 | Yes | Central (CIAA) |
| Lyon College | Batesville, Arkansas | 1872 | Presbyterian
| 700 | Scots | 2022 | 2023 | Yes | St. Louis (SLIAC) |
| Farmington, Maine | 1863 | Public | 1,861 | Beavers | 1999 | 2003 | No | North Atlantic (NAC) |
| Presque Isle, Maine | 1903 | Public | 1,469 | Owls | 2005 | 2017 | No | North Atlantic (NAC) |
| Meredith College | Raleigh, North Carolina | 1891 | Nonsectarian | 1,990 | Avenging
Angels | 1986 | 2007 | No | USA South |
| Mills College | Oakland, California | 1852 | Nonsectarian | 1,345 | Cyclones | 1994;
2016 | 2013;
2017 | No | N/A |
| Milwaukee School of Engineering | Milwaukee, Wisconsin | 1903 | Nonsectarian | 2,122 | Raiders | 2006 | 2007 | No | Northern Athletics (NACC) |
| Mississippi University for Women | Columbus, Mississippi | 1884 | Public | 2,479 | Owls | 2019 | 2023 | No | St. Louis (SLIAC) |
| Mitchell College | New London, Connecticut | 1938 | Nonsectarian | 572 | Mariners | 2005 | 2008 | No | Great Northeast (GNAC) |
| Mount Mary University | Milwaukee, Wisconsin | 1913 | Catholic
| 1,209 | Blue Angels | 2007;
2016 | 2015;
2018 | No | Chicagoland (CCAC) |
| Mount St. Joseph University | Delhi Township, Ohio | 1920 | Catholic
| 1,889 | Lions | 1996 | 1998 | Yes | Heartland (HCAC) |
| Nebraska Wesleyan University | Lincoln, Nebraska | 1887 | United Methodist | 1,600 | Prairie Wolves | 1982 | 2016 | Yes | American Rivers (ARC) |
New Jersey City University
| Jersey City, New Jersey | 1929 | Public | 7,300 | Gothic Knights | 2004 | 2005 | No | New Jersey (NJAC)
|
| New Rochelle, New York | 1904 | Catholic
| N/A | Blue Angels | 1982 | 2019 | No | N/A |
New York University Tandon School of Engineering
| Brooklyn, New York | 1854 | Nonsectarian | 4,487 | Fighting
Blue Jays | 1979 | 2004 | No | N/A |
| Newbury College | Brookline, Massachusetts | 1962 | Nonsectarian | N/A | Nighthawks | 2001 | 2008 | No | Closed in 2019 |
| North Central University | Minneapolis, Minnesota | 1930 | Assemblies of God | 1,200 | Rams | 2006 | 2013 | No | Upper Midwest (UMAC) |
| Northern Vermont University-Johnson | Johnson, Vermont | 1881 | Public | 1,803 | Badgers | 1973 | 2001 | No | N/A |
| Northern Vermont University-Lyndon | Lyndon, Vermont | 1911 | Public | 1,519 | Hornets | 2006 | 2008 | No | N/A |
| Pine Manor College | Chestnut Hill,
Massachusetts | 1911 | Nonsectarian | 419 | Gators | 1983;
2016 | 1995;
2017 | No | N/A |
| Russell Sage College | Albany and Troy, New York | 1916 | Nonsectarian | 2,389 | Gators | 1993 | 2007 | No | Empire 8 (E8) |
| Rust College | Holly Springs, Mississippi | 1866 | United Methodist | 900 | Bearcats | 1988 | 2017 | No | HBCU (HBCUAC) |
| Saint Elizabeth University | Morristown, New Jersey | 1899 | Catholic
| 1,200 | Eagles | 1988 | 2009 | No | United East |
| Saint Joseph's College of Maine | Standish, Maine | 1912 | Catholic
| 1,987 | Monks | 1975 | 2007 | No | Great Northeast (GNAC) |
| Salem College | Winston-Salem,
North Carolina | 1772 | Moravian | 565 | Spirits | 2005 | 2009 | No | USA South |
| Sarah Lawrence College | Yonkers, New York | 1926 | Nonsectarian | 1,782 | Gryphons | 2013 | 2014 | No | Skyline |
| Savannah College of Art and Design | Savannah, Georgia | 1978 | Non-profit art school | 11,897 | Bees | 1992 | 2003 | No | The Sun (TSC) |
| Spalding University | Louisville, Kentucky | 1814 | Catholic
| 1,692 | Golden Eagles | 2007 | 2009 | No | St. Louis (SLIAC) |
| St. Joseph's University, New York – Brooklyn Campus | Brooklyn, New York | 1916 | Catholic
| 1,261 | Bears | 2007 | 2015 | No | Skyline |
| Stephens College | Columbia, Missouri | 1833 | Nonsectarian | 754 | Stars | 1994 | 2004 | No | American Midwest (AMC) |
| Stevenson University | Stevenson, Maryland | 1947 | Catholic | 3,621 | Mustangs | 1994 | 2004 | Yes | MAC Commonwealth |
| Stony Brook University | Stony Brook, New York | 1957 | Public | 26,782 | Seawolves | 1994 | 1995 | Yes | Coastal (CAA) |
| Canton, New York | 1906 | Public | 3,122 | Kangaroos | 2011 | 2017 | No | S.U. New York (SUNYAC) |
| Morrisville, New York | 1908 | Public | 2,486 | Mustangs | 2006 | 2007 | Yes | S.U. New York (SUNYAC) |
| Thomas College | Waterville, Maine | 1894 | Nonsectarian | 1,949 | Terriers | 2001 | 2003 | No | North Atlantic (NAC) |
| Thomas More University | Crestview Hills, Kentucky | 1921 | Catholic
| 1,963 | Saints | 1996 | 2005 | Yes | Great Midwest (G-MAC) |
| University of California, Santa Cruz | Santa Cruz, California | 1965 | Public | 19,700 | Banana Slugs | 1980 | 2019 | No | Coast to Coast (C2C) |
| Phoenixville, Pennsylvania | 1939 | Assemblies of God | 742 | Patriots | 2013 | 2017 | No | United East |
| Warren Wilson College | Swannanoa,
North Carolina | 1894 | Presbyterian
| 650 | Owls | 2020 | 2022 | No | Coast to Coast (C2C) |
| William Peace University | Raleigh, North Carolina | 1857 | Presbyterian
| 950 | Pacers | 2001 | 2003 | No | USA South |
| Wilmington College | Wilmington, Ohio | 1870 | Quakers | 990 | Quakers | 1996 | 1998 | Yes | Ohio (OAC) |
| Milwaukee, Wisconsin | 1956 | Public | 22,481 | Panthers | 1980 | 1985 | No | Horizon |