American Idol season 16


The sixteenth season of American Idol premiered on March 11, 2018, on the ABC television network. It was the show's first season to air on ABC, and after 15 years, Ryan Seacrest continued his role as host, while Katy Perry, Luke Bryan, and Lionel Richie joined the show as judges. Maddie Poppe won the season on May 21, 2018, while Caleb Lee Hutchinson was the runner-up, and Gabby Barrett finished in third place.

Background

In early 2017, Variety reported that FremantleMedia was in talks to revive the show for either NBC or Fox, the show's original network. A dispute between Fremantle and Core Media Group derailed these plans. In May 2017, it was announced that ABC was making a bid to revive the program. Later, ABC announced that it had acquired the rights to the series and that American Idol would return for the 2017–18 television season. On November 6, 2017, it was announced that the revival would premiere on March 11, 2018.
On July 20, 2017, it was announced on Live with Kelly and Ryan that Ryan Seacrest would return as host for the revival season. On May 16, 2017, Katy Perry was the first judge to be announced by ABC. On September 23, Luke Bryan was announced for a second judge, and on September 29, Lionel Richie was announced as the final. On February 21, 2018, it was announced that iHeartRadio radio personality Bobby Bones would serve as the mentor for the top 24 this season.
On April 23, 2018, ABC announced that the April 29, May 6, and May 13 live shows of the season would air across all mainland U.S. time zones, a first for American Idol.

Regional auditions

In June 2017, it was announced that American Idol would begin two bus tours in 19 cities, and this was later increased to 22, for auditions beginning on August 17, 2017. Those who passed the first audition went in front of the producers, where they would be selected to appear before the judges in different cities. Instead of focusing on a city in each episode as had been the case in previous seasons, each episode this season showed a compilation of auditions from different cities.
CityFilming dateFilming venue
New York City, New YorkOctober 3–4, 2017Madison Square Garden
New Orleans, LouisianaOctober 14, 2017Mardi Gras World
Nashville, TennesseeOctober 19–20, 2017Country Music Hall of Fame and Museum
Savannah, GeorgiaOctober 28–29, 2017Kehoe Iron Works
Los Angeles, CaliforniaNovember 16–17, 2017Hollywood and Highland Center

During the live broadcast of the 2017 American Music Awards, three contestants who did not advance after their auditions in front of the judges were given one more chance to convince the audience to vote for them. The contestants were Britany Holmes, Maris, and Dominique Smith. The winner of the golden ticket to Hollywood was then revealed the next night on an episode of Dancing with the Stars. Lionel Richie appeared in the show and announced that the vote was in favor of Britney Holmes, a 28-year-old vocal coach from Texas, who advanced to Hollywood as the first semifinalist of the season.

Hollywood week

Hollywood Week aired over two episodes on March 26 and April 1. It featured three rounds: lines of ten, a group round, and a solo round. In the first round, each contestant sang individually, and after ten had sung, they gathered in a line. Those who impressed the judges and the producers were advanced to the next round, where the contestants performed together in groups of four or five. The contestants who passed the group rounds performed their final solos before advancing to the Showcase round.

Showcase round

The Showcase round aired on April 2, which featured the top 50 performing for the judges and a live audience at Exchange LA, a nightclub in Los Angeles. On April 3, the judges narrowed the number of contestants down from 50 to 24. The top 24 contestants then moved on to perform solos and celebrity duets.
Here is a list of the contestants who reached the top 24 and the song they performed at the Showcase. Contestants are listed in the order they performed.
ContestantSong
Layla Spring"Proud Mary"
Michael J. Woodard"You Oughta Know"
Gabby Barrett"Church Bells"
Michelle Sussett"24K Magic"
Dominique"Landslide"
Trevor McBane"Wake Me Up"
Maddie Poppe"Me and Bobby McGee"
Ron Bultongez"All I Want"
Alyssa Raghu"Every Breath You Take"
Catie Turner"Bad Romance"
Jurnee"Never Enough"
Shannon O'Hara"Unconditionally"
Kay Kay"Brokenhearted"
Amelia Hammer Harris"Paint It Black"
Brandon Diaz"Let's Get It On"
Adam Sanders "Creep"
Jonny Brenns"Lay Me Down"
Mara Justine"Something's Got a Hold on Me"
Caleb Lee Hutchinson"I Was Wrong"
Garrett Jacobs"Knock on Wood"
Cade Foehner"No Good"
Effie Passero"The Dance"
Marcio Donaldson"If You Really Love Me"
Dennis Lorenzo"A Song for You"

Top 24

The top 24 contestants were split into two groups of twelve. Prerecorded performances of the first group aired on April 8 and 9, and the second group on April 15 and 16. On the first episode, each contestant performed one solo; and on the second episode, each contestant performed one duet with a celebrity singer. The judges then eliminated five contestants from each group on the second episode.
The artists who performed duets with the top 24 were Banners, Aloe Blacc, Bishop Briggs, Cam, Colbie Caillat, Luis Fonsi, Andy Grammer, Lea Michele, Patrick Monahan, Rachel Platten, Bebe Rexha, Sugarland, and Allen Stone.
Color key:

Group 1

Contestants are listed in the order they performed.

Group 2

Contestants are listed in the order they performed.

Top 14

The Top 14 performances aired on Sunday, April 22, followed by the live results show on Monday, April 23.
Color key:

Contestants are listed in the order they performed.
ContestantSongResult
Caleb Lee Hutchinson"Midnight Train to Memphis"Advanced
Michelle Sussett"Friends"Wild Card
Marcio Donaldson"It's a Miracle"Wild Card
Mara Justine"This Is Me"Wild Card
Garrett Jacobs"Raging Fire"Wild Card
Ada Vox"The [Show Must Go On (Queen song)|The Show Must Go On]"Wild Card
Catie Turner"Take Me to Church"Advanced
Cade Foehner"Black Magic Woman"Advanced
Dennis Lorenzo"In My Blood"Wild Card
Maddie Poppe"Homeward Bound"Advanced
Jurnee"Bang Bang (Jessie J, [Ariana Grande and Nicki Minaj song)|Bang Bang]"Wild Card
Jonny Brenns"This Is Gospel"Wild Card
Michael J. Woodard"Titanium"Advanced
Gabby Barrett"The Climb"Advanced

Top 10 contestants

Top 10

Color key:

Top 10 – Disney (April 29)

served as a guest mentor this week. Each contestant performed one song from a Disney movie. Contestants are listed in the order they performed.
ContestantSongDisney filmResult
Maddie Poppe"The Bare Necessities"The Jungle BookSafe
Jurnee"How Far I'll Go"MoanaSafe
Cade Foehner"Kiss the Girl"The Little MermaidSafe
Ada Vox"Circle of Life"The Lion KingEliminated
Michelle Sussett"Remember Me"CocoEliminated
Gabby Barrett"Colors of the Wind"PocahontasSafe
Michael J. Woodard"Beauty and the Beast"Beauty and the BeastSafe
Caleb Lee Hutchinson"You've Got a Friend in Me"Toy StorySafe
Catie Turner"Once Upon a Dream"Sleeping BeautySafe
Dennis Lorenzo"Can You [Feel the Love Tonight]"The Lion KingEliminated

Top 7 – Prince & contestants' birth year (May 6)

served as a guest mentor this week. Each contestant performed two songs: one song from the Prince discography and one song from the year of their birth. Contestants are listed in the order they performed.
ContestantOrderSongResult
Jurnee1"Kiss"Eliminated
Jurnee11"Back at One"Eliminated
Gabby Barrett2"I Hope You Dance"Safe
Gabby Barrett10"How Come U [Don't Call Me Anymore?]"Safe
Michael J. Woodard3"I Would Die 4 U"Safe
Michael J. Woodard8"My Heart Will Go On"Safe
Cade Foehner4"Who Will Save Your Soul"Safe
Cade Foehner9"Jungle Love"Safe
Catie Turner5"Oops!... I Did It Again"Eliminated
Catie Turner12"Manic Monday"Eliminated
Caleb Lee Hutchinson6"Amazed"Safe
Caleb Lee Hutchinson14"When Doves Cry"Safe
Maddie Poppe7"Nothing Compares 2 U"Safe
Maddie Poppe13"If It Makes You Happy"Safe

Top 5 – Carrie Underwood & Mother's Day (May 13)

was a guest mentor this week. Each contestant performed two songs: one song from her discography and one song dedicated to their mothers in honor of Mother's Day. Contestants are listed in the order they performed.
ContestantOrderSongResult
Michael J. Woodard1"Flat on the Floor"Eliminated
Michael J. Woodard8"Still I Rise"Eliminated
Gabby Barrett2"Last Name"Safe
Gabby Barrett6"I Have Nothing"Safe
Cade Foehner3"Undo It"Eliminated
Cade Foehner7"Simple Man"Eliminated
Caleb Lee Hutchinson4"So Small"Safe
Caleb Lee Hutchinson9"Stars in Alabama"Safe
Maddie Poppe5"I Told You So"Safe
Maddie Poppe10"God Only Knows"Safe

Top 3 – Finale (May 21)

served as a guest mentor this week. Each contestant performed three songs: their winner's song, a reprise of their favorite performance from the season, and a song dedicated to their hometowns. Contestants are listed in the order they performed.
ContestantOrderSongResult
Caleb Lee Hutchinson1"Johnny Cash Heart"Runner-up
Caleb Lee Hutchinson4"Don't Close Your Eyes"Runner-up
Caleb Lee Hutchinson7"Folsom Prison Blues"Runner-up
Gabby Barrett2"Rivers Deep"Third place
Gabby Barrett5"Little Red Wagon"Third place
Gabby Barrett8"Don't Stop Believin'"Third place
Maddie Poppe3"Going Going Gone"Winner
Maddie Poppe6"Don't Ever Let Your Children Grow Up"Winner
Maddie Poppe9"Landslide"Winner

Elimination chart

'''Color key:'''

Reception

Critical response

On the review aggregation website Rotten Tomatoes, the premiere episode holds an approval rating of 70% based on 20 reviews, with an average rating of 6.51/10. Metacritic, which uses a weighted average, assigned the season a score of 60 out of 100 based on eight reviews, indicating "mixed or average" reviews.

Concert tour

The top 7 finalists performed for the summer tour along with eighth season Kris Allen.