| Award | Recipient | Result |
| Ultimate Scream | Cloverfield | Nomitated |
| Ultimate Scream | The Dark Knight | |
| Ultimate Scream | Hellboy II: The Golden Army | Nomitated |
| Ultimate Scream | Iron Man | Nomitated |
| Ultimate Scream | Lost | Nomitated |
| Ultimate Scream | The Mist | Nomitated |
| Best Fantasy Movie | Beowulf | Nomitated |
| Best Fantasy Movie | The Dark Knight | Nomitated |
| Best Fantasy Movie | Hancock | Nomitated |
| Best Fantasy Movie | Hellboy II: The Golden Army | |
| Best Fantasy Movie | The Incredible [Hulk |The Incredible Hulk] | Nomitated |
| Best Fantasy Movie | Wanted | Nomitated |
| Best Horror Movie | 30 Days of Night | Nomitated |
| Best Horror Movie | The Mist | Nomitated |
| Best Horror Movie | The Orphanage | Nomitated |
| Best Horror Movie | The Ruins | Nomitated |
| Best Horror Movie | The Strangers | Nomitated |
| Best Horror Movie | Sweeney Todd: [The Demon Barber of Fleet Street |Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street] | |
| Best Science Fiction Movie | Cloverfield | Nomitated |
| Best Science Fiction Movie | I Am Legend | Nomitated |
| Best Science Fiction Movie | Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull | Nomitated |
| Best Science Fiction Movie | Iron Man | |
| Best Science Fiction Movie | Southland Tales | Nomitated |
| Best Science Fiction Movie | WALL-E | Nomitated |
| Best Fantasy Actor | Christian Bale, The Dark Knight | Nomitated |
| Best Fantasy Actor | Heath Ledger, The Dark Knight | |
| Best Fantasy Actor | James McAvoy, Wanted | Nomitated |
| Best Fantasy Actor | Edward Norton, The Incredible Hulk | Nomitated |
| Best Fantasy Actor | Terry O'Quinn, Lost | Nomitated |
| Best Fantasy Actor | Ron Perlman, Hellboy II: The Golden Army | Nomitated |
| Best Horror Actor | Johnny Depp, Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street | |
| Best Horror Actor | Fernando Cayo, The Orphanage | Nomitated |
| Best Horror Actor | Thomas Jane, The Mist | Nomitated |
| Best Horror Actor | Stephen Moyer, True Blood | Nomitated |
| Best Horror Actor | Jared Padalecki, Supernatural | Nomitated |
| Best Horror Actor | Jonathan Tucker, The Ruins | Nomitated |
| Best Superhero | Christian Bale as Batman, The Dark Knight | |
| Best Superhero | Will Smith as John Hancock, Hancock | Nomitated |
| Best Superhero | Masi Oka as Iron Man, Heroes | Nomitated |
| Best Superhero | Robert Downey Jr. as Iron Man, Iron Man | Nomitated |
| Best Superhero | Edward Norton as Hulk, The Incredible Hulk | Nomitated |
| Best Superhero | Ron Perlman as Hellboy, Hellboy II: The Golden Army | Nomitated |
| Breakout Performance | Anna Friel, Pushing Daisies | Nomitated |
| Breakout Performance | Jessica Lucas, Cloverfield | Nomitated |
| Breakout Performance | T.J. Miller, Cloverfield | Nomitated |
| Breakout Performance | WALL-E, WALL-E | |
| Breakout Performance | Anna Walton, Hellboy II: The Golden Army | Nomitated |
| Breakout Performance | Odette Annable, Cloverfield | Nomitated |
| Best Horror Actress | as, Dexter | Nomitated |
| Best Horror Actress | as Amy, | Nomitated |
| Best Horror Actress | as, | Nomitated |
| Best Horror Actress | ' as ', | |
| Best Horror Actress | as, Funny Games | Nomitated |
| Best Horror Actress | as, Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street | Nomitated |
| Best Villain | Tobin Bell as Jigsaw, Saw IV | Nomitated |
| Best Villain | Jeff Bridges as Iron Monger, Iron Man | Nomitated |
| Best Villain | Aaron Eckhart as Two-Face, The Dark Knight | Nomitated |
| Best Villain | Zachary Quinto as Sylar, Heroes | Nomitated |
| Best Villain | Heath Ledger as The Joker, The Dark Knight | |
| Best Villain | Alan Rickman as Judge Turpin, Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street | Nomitated |
| Best Fantasy Actress | Amy Adams, Enchanted | Nomitated |
| Best Fantasy Actress | Selma Blair, Hellboy II: The Golden Army | Nomitated |
| Best Fantasy Actress | Maggie Gyllenhaal, The Dark Knight | Nomitated |
| Best Fantasy Actress | Angelina Jolie, Wanted | |
| Best Fantasy Actress | Hayden Panettiere, Heroes | Nomitated |
| Best Fantasy Actress | Charlize Theron, Hancock | Nomitated |
| Best Supporting Performance | Gary Oldman, The Dark Knight | |
| Best Supporting Performance | Jason Bateman, Hancock | Nomitated |
| Best Supporting Performance | Michael Caine, The Dark Knight | Nomitated |
| Best Supporting Performance | Terrence Howard, Iron Man | Nomitated |
| Best Supporting Performance | Doug Jones, Hellboy II: The Golden Army | Nomitated |
| Best Supporting Performance | Shia LaBeouf, Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull | Nomitated |
| Holy Sh%t Scene of the Year | The Batmobile/Batpod chase, The Dark Knight | Nomitated |
| Holy Sh%t Scene of the Year | Big Rig Flips Over, The Dark Knight | |
| Holy Sh%t Scene of the Year | Escape from Ten Rings hideout, Iron Man | Nomitated |
| Holy Sh%t Scene of the Year | Iron Man's First Flight, Iron Man | Nomitated |
| Holy Sh%t Scene of the Year | The Reverse Kill Shot, Wanted | Nomitated |
| Holy Sh%t Scene of the Year | The Statue of Liberty Attack, Cloverfield | Nomitated |
| Most Memorable Mutilation | Attacked by the Infected, I Am Legend | Nomitated |
| Most Memorable Mutilation | The Autopsy, Saw IV | Nomitated |
| Most Memorable Mutilation | The Pencil Trick, The Dark Knight | Nomitated |
| Most Memorable Mutilation | Penis Bitten off by Vagina with Teeth, Teeth | |
| Most Memorable Mutilation | The Leg Amputation, The Ruins | Nomitated |
| Most Memorable Mutilation | Attacked by the Flesh Eating Tooth Fairies, Hellboy II: The Golden Army | Nomitated |
| Best TV Show | Battlestar Galactica | Nomitated |
| Best TV Show | Dexter | |
| Best TV Show | Heroes | Nomitated |
| Best TV Show | Lost | Nomitated |
| Best TV Show | Reaper | Nomitated |
| Best TV Show | Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles | Nomitated |
| Best Screamplay | Cloverfield | Nomitated |
| Best Screamplay | The Mist | Nomitated |
| Best Screamplay | The Orphanage | Nomitated |
| Best Screamplay | WALL-E | Nomitated |
| Best Screamplay | The Dark Knight | |
| Best Screamplay | Iron Man | Nomitated |
| Best Scream to Comic Adaptation | Buffy the Vampire Slayer Season Eight | |
| Best Scream to Comic Adaptation | Army of Darkness | Nomitated |
| Best Scream to Comic Adaptation | Battlestar Galactica | Nomitated |
| Best Scream to Comic Adaptation | Freddy vs. Jason vs. Ash | Nomitated |
| Best Scream to Comic Adaptation | A [Nightmare on Elm Street |A Nightmare on Elm Street] | Nomitated |
| Best Scream to Comic Adaptation | The [Texas Chainsaw Massacre |The Texas Chainsaw Massacre] | Nomitated |
| Best Sequel | The Chronicles of Narnia: Prince Caspian | Nomitated |
| Best Sequel | The Dark Knight | |
| Best Sequel | Hellboy II: The Golden Army | Nomitated |
| Best Sequel | Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull | Nomitated |
| Best Sequel | Resident Evil: Extinction | Nomitated |
| Best Sequel | Saw IV | Nomitated |
| Best Director | Tim Burton, Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street | Nomitated |
| Best Director | Frank Darabont, The Mist | Nomitated |
| Best Director | Guillermo del Toro, Hellboy II: The Golden Army | Nomitated |
| Best Director | Jon Favreau, Iron Man | Nomitated |
| Best Director | Christopher Nolan, The Dark Knight | |
| Best Director | Rob Zombie, Halloween | Nomitated |
| Best Remake | The Eye | Nomitated |
| Best Remake | Funny Games | Nomitated |
| Best Remake | Halloween | |
| Best Remake | The Incredible Hulk | Nomitated |
| Best Remake | Journey to the [Center of the Earth |Journey to the Center of Earth] | Nomitated |
| Best Remake | Prom Night | Nomitated |
| Best Science Fiction Actor | Robert Downey Jr., Iron Man | |
| Best Science Fiction Actor | Harrison Ford, Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull | Nomitated |
| Best Science Fiction Actor | Dwayne Johnson, Southland Tales | Nomitated |
| Best Science Fiction Actor | Edward James Olmos, Battlestar Galactica | Nomitated |
| Best Science Fiction Actor | Will Smith, I Am Legend | Nomitated |
| Best Science Fiction Actor | David Tennant, Doctor Who | Nomitated |
| Best Science Fiction Actress | Summer Glau, Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles | Nomitated |
| Best Science Fiction Actress | Tricia Helfer, Battlestar Galactica | Nomitated |
| Best Science Fiction Actress | Lena Headey, Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles | Nomitated |
| Best Science Fiction Actress | Milla Jovovich, Resident Evil: Extinction | |
| Best Science Fiction Actress | Gwyneth Paltrow, Iron Man | Nomitated |
| Best Science Fiction Actress | Odette Annable, Cloverfield | Nomitated |
| Best F/X | Beowulf | Nomitated |
| Best F/X | Cloverfield | Nomitated |
| Best F/X | The Dark Knight | |
| Best F/X | Hellboy II: The Golden Army | Nomitated |
| Best F/X | Iron Man | Nomitated |
| Best F/X | Wanted | Nomitated |
| Best Comic Book | Astonishing X-Men | Nomitated |
| Best Comic Book | Hack/Slash | Nomitated |
| Best Comic Book | The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen: Black Dossier | Nomitated |
| Best Comic Book | The Umbrella Academy: Apocalypse Suite | Nomitated |
| Best Comic Book | Walking Dead |The Walking Dead] | Nomitated |
| Best Comic Book | Y: The Last Man | |
| Best Comic Book Movie | 30 Days of Night | Nomitated |
| Best Comic Book Movie | The Dark Knight | |
| Best Comic Book Movie | Hellboy II: The Golden Army | Nomitated |
| Best Comic Book Movie | The Incredible Hulk | Nomitated |
| Best Comic Book Movie | Iron Man | Nomitated |
| Best Comic Book Movie | Wanted | Nomitated |
| Best Comic Book Artist | Gabriel Ba, The Umbrella Academy: Apocalypse Suite | |
| Best Comic Book Artist | Darwyn Cooke, The Spirit | Nomitated |
| Best Comic Book Artist | Pia Guerra, Y: The Last Man | Nomitated |
| Best Comic Book Artist | Jim Lee, All Star [Batman & Robin, the Boy Wonder] | Nomitated |
| Best Comic Book Artist | Joe Quesada, The Amazing Spider-Man | Nomitated |
| Best Comic Book Artist | Alex Ross, Project Superpowers | Nomitated |
| Best Comic Book Writer | Warren Ellis, Anna Mercury / Black Summer / Doktor Sleepless / Fell / No Hero | Nomitated |
| Best Comic Book Writer | Robert Kirkman, Walking Dead | Nomitated |
| Best Comic Book Writer | Mike Mignola, Hellboy: Darkness Calls / Lobster Johnson: The Iron Prometheus | Nomitated |
| Best Comic Book Writer | Alan Moore, The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen: Black Dossier | Nomitated |
| Best Comic Book Writer | Grant Morrison, Batman / Final Crisis | |
| Best Comic Book Writer | Brian K. Vaughan, Ex Machina | Nomitated |
| Most Shocking Comic Book Plot Twist | The 70s heroes return!; Secret Invasion 1 | Nomitated |
| Most Shocking Comic Book Plot Twist | Buffy and Satsu in best together!, Buffy The Vampire Slayer: Season Eight | Nomitated |
| Most Shocking Comic Book Plot Twist | The plague is revealed!, Y: The Last Man | Nomitated |
| Most Shocking Comic Book Plot Twist | Kitty Pryde sacrifices herself to save the world!, Giant Sized Astonishing X-Men | Nomitated |
| Most Shocking Comic Book Plot Twist | The slaughter of Woodbury Prison!, Walking Dead | Nomitated |
| Most Shocking Comic Book Plot Twist | The X-Men disband after Professor X is shot in the head by Bishop, X-Men | |
| Best Line | "Hulk Smash", The Incredible Hulk | Nomitated |
| Best Line | "I believe whatever doesn't kill you makes you stranger", The Dark Knight | |
| Best Line | "I am Iron Man", Iron Man | Nomitated |
| Best Line | "I'm not a baby... I'm a tumor", Hellboy II: The Golden Army | Nomitated |
| Best Line | "I'm gonna make this pencil disappear", The Dark Knight | Nomitated |
| Best Line | "Why so serious?", The Dark Knight | Nomitated |