Mother's tied for first place in the "best old hometown restaurant" categoryWillamette Week 2002 reader's poll. The restaurant ranked number one in the "Best Omelet" category, and Schroeder was named "Best Chef", in the same poll in 2016. Mother's also ranked third place in The Oregonian "best brunch" poll in 2016. It ranked fifth in the same poll in 2025. Katherine Chew Hamilton and Brooke Jackson-Glidden included Mother's in Eater Portland 2025 list of the city's best restaurants and food cartpods for large groups.