The Washington Post considered the album "for light pop and diehard Dizzy fans only," writing that "the mood is more sentimental than moving." The Los Angeles Times wrote that Gillespie "plays exceptionally well." The Orlando Sentinel deemed Endlessly "an understated, comfortable, pop-oriented album," stating that "Gillespie's music is sweet enough these days without the extraserving of synthesized syrup." The San Diego Union-Tribuneopined that "Gillespie especially has a strong feel for Latin idioms, and his playing is not only respectful of other musical traditions, it is highly complementary." The Ottawa Citizen said that "the music is formula pop, the production is studio sterile and the playing is both uninspired and tentative."