| Performer | Song | | Allen Stone | "Is This Love" |
Top 20 (April 23 & 24)The top 20 performances aired on Sunday, April 23, followed by the live results show on Monday, April 24. Color key:
Contestants are listed in the order they performed.
| Contestant | Song | Result | | Zachariah Smith | "I Want to Know What Love Is" | Safe | | Matt Wilson | "Say You Won't Let Go" | Wild Card | | Nailyah Serenity | "Baby Love" | Wild Card | | Warren Peay | "Up There Down Here" | Safe | | Kaeyra | "Bruises" | Wild Card | | Mariah Faith | "Cry to Me" | Wild Card | | Iam Tongi | "The Winner Takes It All" | Safe | | Haven Madison | "Mean Girls" | Safe | | Oliver Steele | "Too Soon" | Safe | | Lucy Love | "Boulders" | Wild Card | | Hannah Nicolaisen | "Somebody to Love" | Wild Card | | Olivia Soli | "I Surrender" | Wild Card | | Marybeth Byrd | "People Pleaser" | Safe | | Michael Williams | "Lose You to Love Me" | Wild Card | | Paige Anne | "Say Something" | Wild Card | | Nutsa | "Un-Break My Heart" | Wild Card | | Tyson Venegas | "180" | Safe | | Megan Danielle | "Holy Water" | Safe | | Colin Stough | "Pretty Heart" | Safe | | Wé Ani | "Skyfall" | Safe |
| Performers | Song | | Smokey Robinson | "I Second That Emotion" "If We Don't Have Each Other" | | Noah Thompson & HunterGirl | "One Day Tonight" |
FinalsColor key: served as a guest mentor this week. Each contestant performed one song from inductees of the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. Contestants are listed in the order they performed.
| Contestant | Song | Result | | Tyson Venegas | "For Once in My Life" | Safe | | Warren Peay | "The House of the Rising Sun" | Safe | | Haven Madison | "Livin' on a Prayer" | Safe | | Lucy Love | "All Night Long " | Eliminated | | Oliver Steele | "Georgia on My Mind" | Safe | | Colin Stough | "Midnight Rider" | Safe | | Marybeth Byrd | "Dancing Queen" | Safe | | Wé Ani | "Something's Got a Hold on Me" | Safe | | Nutsa | "The Show Must Go On" | Eliminated | | Megan Danielle | "Angel from Montgomery" | Safe | | Zachariah Smith | "Don't Bring Me Down" | Safe | | Iam Tongi | "Bring It On Home to Me" | Safe | The judges chose songs for each of the contestants to perform. Katy Perry had the most song choices selected by the contestants, and was able to save one contestant from elimination. Contestants are listed in the order they performed.
| Contestant | Song | Selected by | Result | | Zachariah Smith | "Wanted Dead or Alive" | Lionel Richie | Safe | | Haven Madison | "The Only Exception" | Katy Perry | Safe | | Wé Ani | "I Have Nothing" | Luke Bryan | Safe | | Oliver Steele | "High and Dry" | Katy Perry | Saved by Katy Perry | | Warren Peay | "Colder Weather" | Lionel Richie | Safe | | Iam Tongi | "What a Wonderful World" | Luke Bryan | Safe | | Marybeth Byrd | "Wasted on You" | Lionel Richie | Eliminated | | Tyson Venegas | "Someone You Loved" | Katy Perry | Eliminated | | Megan Danielle | "Go Rest High on That Mountain" | Luke Bryan | Safe | | Colin Stough | "It's Been Awhile" | Katy Perry | Safe |
Top 8 – Alanis Morissette & Ed Sheeran (May 7)served as a guest mentor this week, and also served as a guest judge along with Ed Sheeran. Each contestant performed two songs: one solo from the Alanis Morissette discography and one song from the Ed Sheeran discography performed as a duet with a fellow contestant. Contestants are listed in the order they performed.
| Contestant | Order | Song | Result | | Warren Peay | 1 | "All I Really Want" | Eliminated | | Zachariah Smith | 2 | "Ironic" | Safe | | Haven Madison | 4 | "You Learn" | Eliminated | | Colin Stough | 6 | "Hand in My Pocket" | Safe | | Megan Danielle | 8 | "Head over Feet" | Safe | | Iam Tongi | 9 | "Guardian" | Safe | | Wé Ani | 10 | "Uninvited" | Safe | | Oliver Steele | 12 | "You Oughta Know" | Eliminated | Oliver Steele & Iam Tongi | 3 | "Photograph" | | Wé Ani & Warren Peay | 5 | "Perfect" | | Haven Madison & Zachariah Smith | 7 | "Thinking Out Loud" | | Megan Danielle & Colin Stough | 11 | "Dive" | |
|