Phycotoxin


Phycotoxins are complex allelopathic chemicals produced by eukaryotic and prokaryotic algal secondary metabolic pathways. More simply, these are toxic chemicals synthesized by photosynthetic organisms. These metabolites are not harmful to the producer but may be toxic to either one or many members of the marine food web. This page focuses on phycotoxins produced by marine microalgae; however, freshwater algae and macroalgae are known phycotoxin producers and may exhibit analogous ecological dynamics.
In the pelagic marine food web, phytoplankton are subjected to grazing by macro- and micro-zooplankton as well as competition for nutrients with other phytoplankton species. Marine bacteria try to obtain a share of organic carbon by maintaining symbiotic, parasitic, commensal, or predatory interactions with phytoplankton. Other bacteria will degrade dead phytoplankton or consume organic carbon released by viral lysis. The production of toxins is one strategy that phytoplankton use to deal with this broad range of predators, competitors, and parasites. Smetacek suggested that "planktonic evolution is ruled by protection and not competition. The many shapes of plankton reflect defense responses to specific attack systems". Indeed, phytoplankton retain an abundance of mechanical and chemical defense mechanisms including cell walls, spines, chain/colony formation, and toxic chemical production. These morphological and physiological features have been cited as evidence for strong predatory pressure in the marine environment. However, the importance of competition is also demonstrated by the production of phycotoxins that negatively impact other phytoplankton species.
Flagellates are the principle producers of phycotoxins; however, there are known toxigenic diatoms, cyanobacteria, prymnesiophytes, and raphidophytes. Because many of these allelochemicals are large and energetically expensive to produce, they are synthesized in small quantities. However, phycotoxins are known to accumulate in other organisms and can reach high concentrations during algal blooms. Additionally, as biologically active metabolites, phycotoxins may produce ecological effects at low concentrations. These effects may be subtle, but have the potential to impact the biogeographic distributions of phytoplankton and bloom dynamics.

Potential ecological effects

Anti-grazing effects

Phycotoxins may prevent grazing by several mechanisms: grazer death, infertility, or deterrence.
Some evidence of anti-grazing effects:
  1. Teegarden found that three different species of copepods were able to distinguish between a saxitoxin-producing Alexandrium sp. and morphologically similar non-toxigenic Alexandrium sp. by chemosensory means. These three different copepod species grazed predominantly on the non-toxigenic Alexandrium spp. and avoided the saxitoxin-producer. However, the effect of saxitoxin deterrence varied per copepod species. This implies that saxitoxin producing Alexandrium sp. have an advantage over non-toxigenic dinoflagellates.
  2. Miralto et al. reported a low hatching success of eggs laid by copepods that fed on diatoms containing polyunsaturated aldehydes. When ingested by copepods, these aldehydes appear to arrest embryonic development. This has the potential to decrease the future population of copepods and promote the survival of copepods which do not eat as many diatoms.

    Anti-microbial effects

Phycotoxins production may be useful to ward off parasitic or algicidal heterotrophic bacteria.
Some evidence of anti-microbial effects:
  1. Bates et al. was able to enhance domoic acid production in Pseudo-nitzschia multseries with the re-introduction of bacteria. Additionally, P. multiseries cultures which were completely axenic, produce less domoic acid than P. multiseries cultures which have contained bacteria for several generations.
  2. Sieburth found acrylic acid inhibited gut microflora in penguins. High concentrations of acrylic acid were ingested by penguins via their euphasid diet, which had been feeding on Phaeocystis. The antimicrobial effect of acrylic acid was verified by Slezak et al. who concluded that acrylic acid will inhibit bacterial production in situations where phytoplankton form aggregates. However, acrylic acid production may also serve to keep bacteria away from the phytoplankton in more dilute concentrations.

    Competitive effects

Since many different species of phytoplankton compete for a limited number of nutrients, it's possible that phycotoxin production is used as a method to either kill competitors or to keep other phytoplankton out of the producer's nutrients space.
Some evidence of competitive effects:
  1. Graneli showed that Prymnesium spp. will produce phycotoxins which kill competitors under nitrogen or phosphorus limitation.
  2. Fistarol et al. found that Alexandrium spp. produce toxins which decrease the growth rate of other phytoplankton and change community composition.
  3. Prince et al. showed that chemical exudates from the dinoflagellate Karenia brevis decreased the growth rate and sometimes killed competitor species by decreasing their photosynthetic efficiency and increasing membrane permeability.

    List of known phycotoxins and mechanisms of action

Most characterized phycotoxins have some economic or health impact on humans. Other well-studied phycotoxins are potential or existing pharmaceuticals or have some use in cellular research. Therefore, our level of knowledge on individual toxins does not necessarily reflect their ecological relevance. Additionally, the mode of action and level of toxicity are effects that have been documented in macroorganisms. These modes of action may be different in the pelagic marine environment. However, it is unlikely that the synthesis of complex and energetically expensive chemicals should be conserved over evolutionary time if they do not confer some advantage on the producer. Even if we do not yet know the effect of many toxins in their natural environment, their mere presence and impressive diversity indicates that they do serve some ecological purpose.
The phytoplankton species listed below do not encompass the entire range of known toxigenic species. There exists experimental evidence for phytoplankton species that have inhibitory effects on grazers or other phytoplankton species, but their toxins have not been identified.
Table generated using information from Cembella, Shimizu
Toxin groupToxin producing speciesClassCharacteristicsMode of actionStructure
Domoic acidPseudo-nitzschia spp.BacillariophyceaeHydrophilic N-toxinGlutamate receptor agonist
Saxitoxins Alexandrium spp., Pyrodinium bahamense, Gymnodinium catenatumDinophyceaeHydrophilic N-toxinNa+-channel blocker
Saxitoxins Anabaena spp., Aphanizomenon spp., Cylindrospermopsis spp., Lyngbya spp., Planktothrix spp., Oscillatoria spp.CyanobacteriaHydrophilic N-toxinNa+-channel blocker
CiguatoxinGambierdiscus toxicusDinophyceaeLadder-frame polyetherNa+-channel activator
Gambieric acidGambierdiscus toxicusDinophyceaeLadder-frame polyether
MaitotoxinsGambierdiscus toxicusDinophyceaeLadder-frame polyetherCa2+-channel effector
OsterotoxinOstreopsis lenticularisDinophyceaeLadder-frame polyetherUnknown
CooliatoxinCoolia monotisDinophyceaeLadder-frame polyetherUnknown
BrevetoxinsKarenia brevis, K. brevi-sulcataDinophyceaeLadder-frame polyetherNa+-channel activator
BrevetoxinsChatonella marina, C. antiqua, C. cf. verruculosaRaphidophyceaeLadder-frame polyetherNa+-channel activator
YessotoxinsProtoceratium reticulatum, Lingulodinium polyedrumDinophyceaeLadder-frame polyetherAffects cyclic AMP, cytotoxic
Okadaic acid and dinophysistoxinsDinophysis spp., Prorocentrum spp.DinophyceaeLinear polyetherProtein phosphatase inhibitor
PectenotoxinDinophysis fortii, D. acutaDinophyceaeMacrocyclic polyetherUnknown, hepatotoxic
AzaspriracidsProtoperidinium crassipesDinophyceaeLinear polyetherUnknown, neurotoxic
GymnodimineKarenia selliformisDinophyceaeMacrolideUnknown, potentially neurotoxic
PrymnesinsPrymnesium parvumPrymnesiophyceaeLinear polyetherUnknown, potential Ca2+-channel effector
SpirolideAlexandrium ostenfeldiiDinophyceaeMacrocyclic polyetherMuscarinic receptor or cholinesterase inhibitor
Ostreocin Ostreopsis siamensisDinophyceaeLinear polyetherNa+/K+ ATPase disruptor
Amphidinolide, CaribenolideAmphidinium spp.DinophyceaeMacrocyclic polyetherCytotoxic
GoniodominAlexandrium spp.DinophyceaeMacrocyclic polyether
ProrocentrolideProrocentrium limaDinophyceaeMacrocyclic polyether
ScytophycinsScytonema spp.CyanobacteriaLinear polyetherCytotoxic
TolytoxinTolypothrix conglutinata var. colorataCyanobacteriaLinear polyetherMicrofilament-depolymerizing agent
DebromoaplysiatoxinLyngbya majusculaCyanobacteriaLinear polyetherProtein kinase C activator
Amphidinols, AmphiketideAmphidinium spp.DinophyceaeOpen-chain polyketidesAntifungal
Majusculamides, CuracinsLyngbya majusculaCyanobacteriaOpen-chain polyketideMicrotubulin assembly inhibitor
BacillariolidesPseudo-nitzschia multiseriesBacillariophyceaeEicosanoidPhospholipase A2 inhibitor
LyngbyatoxinsLyngbya majusculaCyanobacteriaPrenylated amino acid derivativeProtein kinase C activator
Polyunsaturated aldehydesBacillariophyceaePolyunsaturated aldehydesAnti-mitotic, apoptosis
EuglenophycinEuglena sanguineaEuglenoideaPolyketide
KarlotoxinKarlodinium veneficumDinophyceaePolyketide / Polyether
KarmitoxinKarlodinium armigerDinophyceaePolyketide / Polyether