Kirkus Reviews praised The Spirit House, calling it "a feat" and "a treat". The Boston Globe's Stephanie Loer wrote that the book had a "terrific twist" and that "fans will not be disappointed". Jon Scieszka praised the book as an "eerie novel of suspense". The School Library Journal stated that while the "premise is clever and the characterization of Bia is convincing", the book "as a whole is sketchy and underdeveloped, more like a detailed outline than a fully realized novel" and "the thematic confrontation of Western logic and Eastern superstition seems heavy-handed".