| Year | Winner | Summary | APSU vs. TSU | APSU vs. TTU | APSU vs. UTM | TSU vs. TTU | TSU vs. UTM | TTU vs. UTM |
| 2007 | Tennessee State† | TSU 2–1, APSU 2–1, TTU 1–2, UTM 1–2 | TSU 33–32OT | APSU 30–27 | APSU 17–14 | TSU 45–28 | UTM 43–38 | TTU 13–10 |
| 2008 | Tennessee State | TSU 3–0, UTM 2–1, APSU 1–2, TTU 0–3 | No. 21 TSU 37–34 | APSU 31–28 | UTM 31–17 | TSU 41–14 | TSU 30–27OT | UTM 35–7 |
| 2009 | Tennessee Tech | TTU 3–0, UTM 2–1, APSU 1–2, TSU 0–3 | APSU 24–21 | TTU 31–23 | UTM 48–38 | TTU 20–13 | UTM 28–7 | TTU 35–28 |
| 2010 | UT Martin | UTM 3–0, TTU 2–1, APSU 1–2, TSU 0–3 | APSU 26–23 | TTU 34–21 | UTM 28–12 | TTU 21–10 | UTM 37–0 | UTM 27–24 |
| 2011 | Tennessee State† | TSU 2–1, TTU 2–1, UTM 1–2, APSU 1–2 | APSU 37–34 | No. 23 TTU 49–7 | UTM 61–23 | TSU 42–40 | TSU 35–30 | TTU 34–31 |
| 2012 | Tennessee State† | TSU 2–1, UTM 2–1, APSU 1–2, TTU 1–2 | TSU 34–14 | APSU 38–31 | UTM 31–6 | No. 21 TSU 22–21 | UTM 35–26 | TTU 45–44OT |
| 2013 | Tennessee State | TSU 3–0, UTM 2–1, TTU 1–2, APSU 0–3 | TSU 31–6 | TTU 34–0 | UTM 38–14 | TSU 41–21 | No. 24 TSU 29–15 | UTM 28–17 |
| 2014 | UT Martin | UTM 3–0, TSU 2–1, TTU 1–2, APSU 0–3 | TSU 31–27 | TTU 41–15 | UTM 37–7 | No. 20 TSU 10–7 | UTM 21–16 | UTM 17–10 |
| 2015 | UT Martin | UTM 3–0, TTU 2–1, TSU 1–2, APSU 0–3 | TSU 20–6 | TTU 42–24 | UTM 44–14 | TTU 30–24 | UTM 28–14 | UTM 31–17 |
| 2016 | UT Martin† | UTM 2–1, TTU 2–1, TSU 2–1, APSU 0–3 | TSU 41–40 | TTU 41–7 | UTM 45–31 | TTU 44–16 | TSU 34–30 | UTM 44–23 |
| 2017 | Austin Peay | APSU 3–0, UTM 2–1, TTU 1–2, TSU 0–3 | APSU 21–17 | APSU 35–28 | APSU 7–0 | TTU 30–26 | No. 24 UTM 31–16 | UTM 24–0 |
| 2018 | Austin Peay† | APSU 2–1, TSU 2–1, UTM 2–1, TTU 0–3 | APSU 49–34 | APSU 41–10 | UTM 37–7 | TSU 41–14 | TSU 31–28OT | UTM 38–13 |
| 2019 | Austin Peay† | APSU 2–1, UTM 2–1, TSU 2–1, TTU 0–3 | TSU 26–24 | APSU 58–21 | APSU 38–24 | TSU 37–27 | UTM 28–17 | UTM 55–14 |
| 2020 | Tennessee Tech† | TTU 2–1, UTM 2–1, APSU 1–2, TSU 1–2 | APSU 27–20 | TTU 27–21 | UTM 37–34 | TTU 24–10 | TSU 26–24 | UTM 40–7 |
| 2021 | UT Martin | UTM 3–0, APSU 2–1, TSU 1–2, TTU 0–3 | APSU 36–7 | APSU 48–20 | No. 13 UTM 17–16 | TSU 20–13OT | No. 15 UTM 41–20 | No. 13 UTM 42–3 |