| Season | Episode | Host | Notes |
| 43 | April 14, 2018 | John Mulaney | Davidson's character asks for lobster in Big Nick's diner. The ensemble, including Kenan Thompson and Kate McKinnon as singing lobsters, perform versions of songs from Les Misérables. This sketch was originally written for Zach Galifianakis' episode in Season 35, but never made it to the air, nor was it cut for time. |
| 44 | March 2, 2019 | John Mulaney | Davidson's character asks to use the bathroom in Big Nick's bodega. Mulaney plays the bodega's owner. The ensemble, including Kenan Thompson as a cat version of Willy Wonka; Melissa Villaseñor and Cecily Strong as cockroaches; Kate McKinnon as a Virgin Mary prayer candle; Mikey Day, Aidy Bryant, and Kyle Mooney as Sour Patch Kids dressed like Oompa Loompas; and Alex Moffat as a guy watching TV, perform versions of songs from Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory, Cats, and Rent. Beck Bennett voices a toilet inspired by Audrey II from Little Shop of Horrors. |
| 45 | February 29, 2020 | John Mulaney | Davidson's character asks to buy sushi at Big Nick's store at LaGuardia Airport. The ensemble, including Kenan Thompson as a bird version of the Phantom of the Opera; Cecily Strong as a sushi chef; Alex Moffat as a rat; Chloe Fineman as an air-hostess; Kate McKinnon as "Auntie Orphan Annie," Beck Bennett as a baby; Jake Gyllenhaal as "Guy Who Travels in Pajamas"; Mikey Day as a gate agent; Bowen Yang as "profiled Asian"; and David Byrne as a baggage handler, perform versions of songs from The Phantom of the Opera, West Side Story, Annie, Wicked, Little Shop of Horrors, and Talking Heads' "Road to Nowhere". |
| 46 | October 31, 2020 | John Mulaney | Davidson's character asks to buy a pair of I ❤ NY underpants from Big Nick's Souvenirs shop during the COVID-19 pandemic and the 2020 United States presidential election. The ensemble, including Kenan Thompson, Bowen Yang, Melissa Villaseñor, Lauren Holt, and Alex Moffat as Times Square costumed characters of a Minion, Batman, Minnie Mouse, Elsa, and Elmo; Kate McKinnon as Shrimp Louie; Beck Bennett as the "Diddler on the Roof"; Maya Rudolph as the Statue of Liberty; Chloe Fineman as a "woman from Westchester"; and Mikey Day as a homeless person, perform versions of songs from Guys and Dolls, A Chorus Line, A Little Night Music, Fiddler on the Roof, Follies, Sweet Charity, and Les Misérables. |
| 47 | February 26, 2022 | John Mulaney | Dismukes's character asks to buy a churro from a random woman in an F train subway station. The ensemble, including Kenan Thompson as a mole person; Sarah Sherman, James Austin Johnson, and Aristotle Athari as B&H Photo employees dressed like characters from Fiddler on the Roof; Cecily Strong as a woman on the tracks; Ben Marshall as a "finance bro"; Mikey Day as a guy with a knife; Punkie Johnson as the train operator; Alex Moffat as a public masturbator; Kyle Mooney as Evan Hansen, Kate McKinnon as a "Puddle of Unidentifiable Origin"; LCD Soundsystem as the Guardian Angels; and Aidy Bryant as "Jesus Christ" in a New York Islanders beer helmet, perform versions of songs from South Pacific, Fiddler on the Roof, Little Shop of Horrors, The Music Man, Singin' in the Rain, Dreamgirls, Les Misérables, and Jesus Christ Superstar. |
| 50 | November 2, 2024 | John Mulaney | Davidson's character asks to buy milk from a Duane Reade inside the Port Authority Bus Terminal. The ensemble, including Kenan Thompson and Ego Nwodim as possums; Sarah Sherman as an elderly lady; James Austin Johnson and Michael Longfellow as bums in taking part in Bumfights; Mikey Day as a soldier; Marcello Hernández as a shampoo bottle; Bowen Yang as the bus driver who is an escaped felon; Chloe Fineman as someone in a Timothée Chalamet lookalike contest; Devon Walker as Mayor Eric Adams; Andy Samberg as "the dead bear that RFK Jr. dumped in Central Park"; Jane Wickline as a "carton of milk that's come to life"; and Emil Wakim as "Jewish Christopher Columbus", perform versions of songs from The Lion King, The Sound of Music, Les Misérables, Cabaret, Aladdin, Hamilton, and Grease. |
| 50 | February 16, 2025 | 50th Anniversary Special | In 1975, David Spade's character announces he's moving to New York City, while Davidson's character asks to buy a hot dog laced with heroin from Big Nick's hot dog cart. The ensemble, including Adam Driver as a hot dog; Maya Rudolph as a needle of heroin, Emil Wakim as a taxi driver; Alex Moffat as a subway rider; Paul Shaffer and G. E. Smith as guitarists; Nathan Lane and Chloe Fineman as Wall Street brokers ingesting cocaine and vodka; Jason Sudeikis, Will Forte, and Kristen Wiig as costumed characters; Kate McKinnon as former Mayor Rudy Giuliani; Lin-Manuel Miranda as Alexander Hamilton; Beck Bennett and Kyle Mooney as Founding Fathers; Sarah Sherman as former Mayor Michael Bloomberg; Devon Walker as former Mayor Eric Adams, Scarlett Johansson and Paul Rudd as skid row residents; James Austin Johnson as a bottle of whiskey; Kenan Thompson as the singing lobster; Rudolph as the Statue of Liberty; Cecily Strong as the sushi chef; Nick Jonas as Marius Pontmercy; Taran Killam as Pizza Rat, and Ana Gasteyer as a pigeon, perform versions of songs from Fame, The Lion King, Les Misérables, Hamilton, and Little Shop of Horrors. Kevin Costner, Billy Crystal, Jenna Ortega, and Ben Stiller cameo as audience members. |