| Year | Actor
Movie | Nominees |
| 1995 | John Travolta and Uma Thurman
—Pulp Fiction | Jim Carrey and Cameron Diaz - The Mask
Christopher Daniel Barnes, Christine Taylor, Paul Sutera, Jennifer Elise Cox, Jesse Lee and Olivia Hack - The Brady Bunch Movie
Arnold Schwarzenegger and Tia Carrere - True Lies |
| 1998 | Mike Myers and Londoners
—Austin Powers: International Man of Mystery | Robert Carlyle, Mark Addy, William Snape, Tom Wilkinson, Steve Huison, Paul Barber and Hugo Speer - The Full Monty
Cameron Diaz and Ewan McGregor - A Life Less Ordinary
Mark Wahlberg - Boogie Nights
Lisa Kudrow, Mira Sorvino and Alan Cumming - Romy and Michele's High School Reunion |
| 2001 | Cameron Diaz
—Charlie's Angels | Kirsten Dunst, Lindsay Sloane, Clare Kramer, Nicole Bilderback, Tsianina Joelson, Rini Bell, Bianca Kajlich, Nathan West and Huntley Ritter - Bring It On
Jamie Bell and Julie Walters - Billy Elliot
Julia Stiles and Sean Patrick Thomas - Save the Last Dance |
| 2004 | Seann William Scott
—American Wedding | Drew Barrymore, Cameron Diaz and Lucy Liu - Charlie's Angels: Full Throttle
Steve Martin - Bringing Down the House
Omarion, Marques Houston and the Lil' Saint's Dance Crew - You Got Served
Jennifer Aniston and Ben Stiller - Along Came Polly |