| Rank | Title | Type | Performances | Opening date | Closing date | Awards | Additional information |
| 1 | The Phantom of the Opera | M | 13,981 | | |
| Broadway's longest-running show and musical First ever Broadway production with total performances to achieve each additional 1,000 performance increment from 8,000+ through 13,000+ |
| 2 | Chicago | M | 11,505 | | | 6 Tony Awards in 1997, including Best Revival of a Musical 6 Drama Desk Awards in 1997, including Outstanding Revival of a Musical [Grammy Award for Tony Award for Best Musical|Best Musical Theater Album|Grammy Award for Best Musical Show Album] in 1998 | Currently running at the Ambassador Theatre Broadway's longest running current show and musical Broadway's longest running revival Original production in 1975 Longest running show to have premiered on Broadway Broadway's longest running American show |
| 3 | The Lion King | M | 11,128 | | | 6 Tony Awards in 1998, including Best Musical 8 Drama Desk Awards in 1998 Grammy Award for Best Musical Show Album in 1999 | Currently running at the Minskoff Theatre Longest running Disney Theatrical Productions show Highest-grossing Broadway show in history Longest-running Broadway show directed by a woman |
| 4 | Wicked | M | 8,667 | | | 3 Tony Awards in 2004 7 Drama Desk Awards in 2004, including Outstanding Musical Grammy Award for Best Musical Show Album in 2005 | Currently running at the Gershwin Theatre |
| 5 | Cats | M | 7,485 | | | 7 Tony Awards in 1983, including Best Musical 3 Drama Desk Awards in 1983 Grammy Award for Best Cast Show Album in 1984 | First ever Broadway production with 7,000+ performances Revival in 2016 |
| 6 | Les Misérables | M | 6,680 | | | 8 Tony Awards in 1987, including Best Musical 5 Drama Desk Awards in 1987, including Outstanding Musical Grammy Award for Best Musical Cast Show Album in 1988 and 1991 | Revivals in 2006 and 2014 |
| 7 | A Chorus Line | M | 6,137 | | | 9 Tony Awards in 1976, including Best Musical 5 Drama Desk Awards in 1976, including Outstanding Musical A Special Tony Award in 1984 for becoming Broadway's longest-running musical Pulitzer Prize for Drama in 1976 | First ever Broadway production with 4,000, 5,000 and 6,000+ performances Revival in 2006 |
| 8 | Oh! Calcutta! | R | 5,959 | | | | Original production in 1969 First revival to match its original for 1000+ performances Broadway's longest-running revue |
| 9 | Mamma Mia! | M | 5,758 | | | | Longest running "jukebox musical" on Broadway Revival in 2025 |
| 10 | The Book of Mormon | M | 5,517 | | | 9 Tony Awards in 2011, including Best Musical 5 Drama Desk Awards in 2011, including Outstanding Musical Grammy Award for Best Musical Theater Album in 2012 | Currently running at the Eugene O'Neill Theatre |
| 11 | Beauty and the Beast | M | 5,462 | | | A Tony Award in 1994 | |
| 12 | Rent | M | 5,123 | | | 4 Tony Awards in 1996, including Best Musical 6 Drama Desk Awards in 1996, including Outstanding Musical Pulitzer Prize for Drama in 1996 | |
| 13 | Jersey Boys | M | 4,642 | | | 4 Tony Awards in 2006, including Best Musical 2 Drama Desk Awards in 2006 Grammy Award for Best Theatre Show Album in 2006 | |
| 14 | Aladdin | M | 4,292 | | | A Tony Award in 2014 A Drama Desk Award in 2014 | Currently running at the New Amsterdam Theatre |
| 15 | Miss Saigon | M | 4,092 | | | 3 Tony Awards in 1991 4 Drama Desk Awards in 1991 | Revival in 2017 |
| 16 | Hamilton | M | 3,733 | | | 11 Tony Awards in 2016, including Best Musical Pulitzer Prize for Drama in 2016 Grammy Award for Best Musical Theater Album in 2016 | Currently running at the Richard Rodgers Theatre Most Tony Award nominations for a production |
| 17 | 42nd Street | M | 3,486 | | | 2 Tony Awards in 1981, including Best Musical 2 Drama Desk Awards in 1981 | Revival in 2001 |
| 18 | Grease | M | 3,388 | | | 2 Drama Desk Awards in 1972 | Revivals in 1994 and 2007 |
| 19 | Fiddler on the Roof | M | 3,242 | | | 9 Tony Awards in 1965, including Best Musical A Special Tony Award in 1972 for becoming Broadway's longest-running musical | Revivals in 1976, 1981, 1990, 2004, and 2015 |
| 20 | Life with Father | P | 3,224 | | | | Broadway's longest-running straight play |
| 21 | Tobacco Road | P | 3,182 | | | | First ever Broadway production with 3,000+ performances Revivals in 1942, 1943, and 1950 |
| 22 | Hello, Dolly! | M | 2,844 | | | 10 Tony Awards in 1964, including Best Musical A Drama Desk Award in 1970 | Revivals in 1975, 1978, 1995, and 2017 |
| 23 | My Fair Lady | M | 2,717 | | | 6 Tony Awards in 1957, including Best Musical | Revivals in 1976, 1981, 1993, and 2018 |
| 24 | Hairspray | M | 2,642 | | | 8 Tony Awards in 2003, including Best Musical 10 Drama Desk Awards in 2003, including Outstanding Musical Grammy Award for Best Musical Show Album in 2003 | |
| 25 | Mary Poppins | M | 2,619 | | | A Tony Award in 2007 2 Drama Desk Awards in 2007 | |
| 26 | Avenue Q | M | 2,534 | | | 3 Tony Awards in 2004, including Best Musical | Original production moved Off-Broadway to New World Stages and ran for an additional 4,035 performances, closing May 26, 2019. |
| 27 | Kinky Boots | M | 2,505 | | | 6 Tony Awards in 2013, including Best Musical A Drama Desk Award in 2013 Grammy Award for Best Musical Theater Album in 2014 | |
| 28 | Harry Potter and the Cursed Child | P | 2,502 | | | 6 Tony Awards in 2018, including Best Play 5 Drama Desk Awards in 2018 | Currently running at the Lyric Theatre |
| 28 | The Producers | M | 2,502 | | | 12 Tony Awards in 2001, including Best Musical 11 Drama Desk Awards in 2001, including Outstanding Musical Grammy Award for Best Musical Show Album in 2002 | Currently holds the record of Broadway production with the most Tony Award wins, winning 12. |
| 30 | Beautiful: The Carole King Musical | M | 2,416 | | | 2 Tony Awards in 2014 3 Drama Desk Awards in 2014 Grammy Award for Best Musical Theater Album in 2015 | |
| 31 | Annie | M | 2,377 | | | 7 Tony Awards in 1977, including Best Musical 7 Drama Desk Awards in 1977, including Outstanding Musical Grammy Award for Best Cast Show Album in 1978 | Revivals in 1997 and 2012 |
| 31 | Cabaret | M | 2,377 | | | 4 Tony Awards in 1998, including Best Revival of a Musical 3 Drama Desk Awards in 1998, including Outstanding Revival of a Musical | Original production in 1966 and revivals in 1987, 2014, and 2024 |
| 33 | Man of La Mancha | M | 2,328 | | | 5 Tony Awards in 1966, including Best Musical | Revivals in 1972, 1977, 1992, and 2002 |
| 33 | Rock of Ages | M | 2,328 | | | | |
| 35 | Abie's Irish Rose | P | 2,327 | | | | First ever Broadway production with 2,000+ performances Revivals in 1937 and 1954 |
| 36 | Oklahoma! | M | 2,212 | | | A Special Tony Award in 1993 for the show's 50th anniversary | Revivals in 1951, 1953, 1979, 2002, and 2019 |
| 37 | Hadestown | M | 2,204 | | | 8 Tony Awards in 2019, including Best Musical 4 Drama Desk Awards in 2019 Grammy Award for Best Musical Theater Album in 2020 | Currently running at the Walter Kerr Theatre |
| 38 | Moulin Rouge! | M | 2,057 | | | 10 Tony Awards in 2020, including Best Musical 5 Drama Desk Awards in 2020 | Currently running at the Al Hirschfeld Theatre |
| 39 | Smokey Joe's Cafe | R | 2,036 | | | | Broadway's longest running original music revue. The longest running musical revue, Oh! Calcutta!, was a revival. |
| 40 | Pippin | M | 1,944 | | | 5 Tony Awards in 1973 5 Drama Desk Awards in 1973 | Revival in 2013 |
| 41 | South Pacific | M | 1,925 | | | 10 Tony Awards in 1950, including Best Musical Pulitzer Prize for Drama in 1950 | Revivals in 1955 and 2008 Held the record of Broadway production with the most Tony Award wins for 51 years with 10 wins, until it was surpassed by The Producers, which won 12. |
| 42 | The Magic Show | M | 1,920 | | | | |
| 43 | Aida | M | 1,852 | | | 4 Tony Awards in 2000 A Drama Desk Award in 2000 Grammy Award for Best Musical Show Album in 2001 | |
| 44 | Gemini | P | 1,819 | | | | |
| 45 | Six | M | 1,794 | | | 2 Tony Awards in 2022 4 Drama Desk Awards in 2022 | Currently running at the Lena Horne Theatre |
| 46 | Deathtrap | P | 1,793 | | | | |
| 47 | Harvey | P | 1,775 | | | | Revival in 1970 and 2012 |
| 48 | Dancin' | D | 1,774 | | | 2 Tony Awards in 1978 2 Drama Desk Awards in 1978 | Revival in 2023 Broadway's longest-running dance musical |
| 49 | La Cage aux Folles | M | 1,761 | | | 6 Tony Awards in 1984, including Best Musical 3 Drama Desk Awards in 1984 | Revivals in 2004 and 2010 |
| 50 | Hair | M | 1,750 | | | A Drama Desk Award in 1968 Grammy Award for Best Score from an Original Cast Show Album in 1969 | Revivals in 1977, 2004, 2009, and 2011 |
| 51 | Dear Evan Hansen | M | 1,672 | | | 6 Tony Awards in 2017, including Best Musical Grammy Award for Best Musical Theater Album in 2018 | |
| 51 | The Wiz | M | 1,672 | | | 7 Tony Awards in 1975, including Best Musical 5 Drama Desk Awards in 1975, including Outstanding Musical Grammy Award for Best Cast Show Album in 1976 | Revivals in 1984 and 2024 |
| 53 | MJ the Musical | M | 1,669 | | | 4 Tony Awards in 2022 2 Drama Desk Awards in 2022 | Currently running at the Neil Simon Theatre |
| 53 | Come from Away | M | 1,669 | | | A Tony Award in 2017 3 Drama Desk Awards in 2017, including Outstanding Musical | |
| 55 | Born Yesterday | P | 1,642 | | | | Revivals in 1989 and 2011 |
| 56 | Crazy for You | M | 1,622 | | | 3 Tony Awards in 1992, including Best Musical 2 Drama Desk Awards in 1992, including Outstanding Musical | |
| 57 | Ain't Misbehavin' | R | 1,604 | | | 3 Tony Awards in 1978, including Best Musical 3 Drama Desk Awards in 1978, including Outstanding Musical Grammy Award for Best Cast Show Album in 1979 | Revival in 1988 |
| 58 | The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas | M | 1,584 | | | 2 Tony Awards in 1979 3 Drama Desk Awards in 1978 | Revivals in 1982 and 2006 |
| 59 | Spamalot | M | 1,575 | | | 3 Tony Awards in 2005, including Best Musical 3 Drama Desk Awards in 2005, including Outstanding Musical Grammy Award for Best Musical Show Album in 2006 | Revival in 2023 |
| 60 | Mary, Mary | P | 1,572 | | | | |
| 61 | Evita | M | 1,567 | | | 7 Tony Awards in 1980, including Best Musical 6 Drama Desk Awards in 1980, including Outstanding Musical Grammy Award for Best Cast Show Album in 1981 | Revival in 2012 |
| 62 | The Voice of the Turtle | P | 1,557 | | | | |
| 63 | Matilda the Musical | M | 1,554 | | | 4 Tony Awards in 2013 5 Drama Desk Awards in 2013, including Outstanding Musical A Tony Honors for Excellence in Theatre in 2013 for the four original leading actresses | |
| 64 | Waitress | M | 1,544 | | | A Drama Desk Award in 2016 | Revival in 2021 |
| 65 | Jekyll & Hyde | M | 1,543 | | | 2 Drama Desk Awards in 1997 | Revival in 2013 |
| 66 | Barefoot in the Park | P | 1,530 | | | A Tony Award in 1964 | Revival in 2006 |
| 67 | 42nd Street | M | 1,524 | | | 2 Tony Awards in 2001, including Best Revival of a Musical A Drama Desk Award in 2001, Outstanding Revival of a Musical | Original production in 1980 |
| 68 | Dreamgirls | M | 1,521 | | | 6 Tony Awards in 1982 4 Drama Desk Awards in 1982 Grammy Award for Best Cast Show Album in 1983 | Revivals in 1987 and 2001 |
| 69 | Mame | M | 1,508 | | | 3 Tony Awards in 1966 Grammy Award for Best Score from an Original Cast Show Album in 1967 | Revival in 1983 |
| 70 | Grease | M | 1,505 | | | | Original production in 1972 and revival in 2007 |
| 71 | Same Time, Next Year | P | 1,453 | | | A Tony Award in 1975 2 Drama Desk Awards in 1975, including Outstanding Play | |
| 72 | Arsenic and Old Lace | P | 1,444 | | | | Revival in 1986 |
| 73 | The Sound of Music | M | 1,443 | | | 5 Tony Awards in 1960, including Best Musical Grammy Award for Best Show Album (Original Cast) in 1961 | Revival in 1998 |
| 74 | Me and My Girl | M | 1,420 | | | 3 Tony Awards in 1987 5 Drama Desk Awards in 1987 | |
| 75 | How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying | M | 1,417 | | | 7 Tony Awards in 1962, including Best Musical Pulitzer Prize for Drama in 1962 Grammy Award for Best Original Cast Show Album in 1962 | Revivals in 1995 and 2011 |
| 76 | Hellzapoppin | R | 1,404 | | | | |
| 77 | The Music Man | M | 1,375 | | | 6 Tony Awards in 1958, including Best Musical Grammy Award for Best Original Cast Album (Broadway or TV) in 1959 | Revivals in 1980, 2000, and 2022 |
| 78 | Funny Girl | M | 1,348 | | | Grammy Award for Best Score from an Original Cast Show Album in 1965 | Revivals in 2002 and 2022 |
| 79 | & Juliet | M | 1,340 | | | | Currently running at the Stephen Sondheim Theatre |
| 80 | Mummenschanz | S | 1,326 | | | | Broadway's longest-running special |
| 81 | Oh! Calcutta! | R | 1,314 | | | | Original production Revival in 1976 |
| 82 | Billy Elliot the Musical | M | 1,312 | | | 10 Tony Awards in 2009, including Best Musical 10 Drama Desk Awards in 2009, including Outstanding Musical | |
| 83 | School of Rock | M | 1,309 | | | | |
| 84 | Movin' Out | D | 1,303 | | | 2 Tony Awards in 2003 A Drama Desk Award in 2003 | |
| 85 | Brighton Beach Memoirs | P | 1,299 | | | A Tony Award in 1983 | Revival in 2009 |
| 86 | Angel Street | P | 1,295 | | | | Revivals in 1948 and 1975 |
| 87 | Lightnin' | P | 1,291 | | | | First ever Broadway production with 1,000+ performances Revival in 1938 |
| 88 | Promises, Promises | M | 1,281 | | | 2 Tony Awards in 1969 2 Drama Desk Awards in 1969 Grammy Award for Best Score from an Original Cast Show Album in 1970 | Revival in 2010 |
| 89 | The King and I | M | 1,246 | | | 5 Tony Awards in 1952, including Best Musical | Revivals in 1977, 1985, 1996, and 2015 |
| 90 | Cactus Flower | P | 1,234 | | | | |
| 91 | Torch Song Trilogy | P | 1,230 | | | 2 Tony Awards in 1983, including Best Play 2 Drama Desk Awards in 1983, including Outstanding Play | Revival in 2018 |
| 92 | Sleuth | P | 1,222 | | | A Tony Award in 1971, Best Play | |
| 93 | 1776 | M | 1,217 | | | 3 Tony Awards in 1969, including Best Musical 2 Drama Desk Awards in 1969 | Revivals in 1997 and 2022 |
| 94 | Equus | P | 1,209 | | | 2 Tony Awards in 1975, including Best Play 4 Drama Desk Awards in 1975, including Outstanding Play | Revival in 2008 |
| 95 | Sugar Babies | R | 1,208 | | | | |
| 96 | Guys and Dolls | M | 1,200 | | | 5 Tony Awards in 1951, including Best Musical | Revivals in 1955, 1965, 1976, 1992, and 2009 |
| 97 | In the Heights | M | 1,184 | | | 4 Tony Awards in 2008, including Best Musical Grammy Award for Best Musical Show Album in 2009 | |
| 98 | Amadeus | P | 1,181 | | | 5 Tony Awards in 1981, including Best Play 3 Drama Desk Awards in 1981, including Outstanding Play | Revival in 1999 |
| 99 | Once | M | 1,168 | | | 8 Tony Awards in 2012, including Best Musical 4 Drama Desk Awards in 2012, including Outstanding Musical Grammy Award for Best Musical Theater Album in 2013 | |
| 100 | Cabaret | M | 1,165 | | | 8 Tony Awards in 1967, including Best Musical Grammy Award for Best Score from an Original Cast Show Album in 1968 | Revivals in 1987, 1998, 2014, and 2024 |
| 100 | Memphis | M | 1,165 | | | 4 Tony Awards in 2010, including Best Musical 4 Drama Desk Awards in 2010, including Outstanding Musical | |
| 102 | Mister Roberts | P | 1,157 | | | 5 Tony Awards in 1948, including Best Play | |
| 103 | Annie Get Your Gun | M | 1,147 | | | | Revivals in 1966 and 1999 Oldest 1000+ original to be joined by 1000+ revival |
| 104 | Guys and Dolls | M | 1,143 | | | 4 Tony Awards in 1992, including Best Revival of a Musical 7 Drama Desk Awards in 1992, including Outstanding Revival of a Musical Grammy Award for Best Musical Show Album in 1993 | Original production in 1950 and revivals in 1955, 1965, 1976, and 2009 |
| 105 | The Seven Year Itch | P | 1,141 | | | A Tony Award in 1953 | |
| 106 | The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee | M | 1,136 | | | 2 Tony Awards in 2005 3 Drama Desk Awards in 2005 | |
| 107 | Bring in 'da Noise, Bring in 'da Funk | D | 1,135 | | | 4 Tony Awards in 1996 2 Drama Desk Awards in 1996 | |
| 108 | Butterflies Are Free | P | 1,128 | | | A Tony Award in 1970 | |
| 109 | Pins and Needles | R | 1,108 | | | | |
| 110 | Plaza Suite | P | 1,097 | | | A Tony Award in 1968 | Revival in 2022 |
| 111 | Fosse | D | 1,093 | | | 3 Tony Awards in 1999, including Best Musical A Drama Desk Award in 1999 | |
| 112 | They're Playing Our Song | M | 1,082 | | | | |
| 113 | Kiss Me, Kate | M | 1,077 | | | 5 Tony Awards in 1949, including Best Musical | Revivals in 1952, 1999, and 2019 First show to win the Tony Award for Best Musical, among other Tony awards |
| 114 | Spider-Man: Turn Off the Dark | M | 1,066 | | | | Most expensive production in Broadway history Longest preview period in Broadway history |
| 115 | Don't Bother Me, I Can't Cope | R | 1,065 | | | 2 Drama Desk Awards in 1972 Grammy Award for Best Score from an Original Cast Show Album in 1973 | |
| 116 | The Pajama Game | M | 1,063 | | | 3 Tony Awards in 1955, including Best Musical | Revivals in 1973 and 2006 |
| 117 | Shenandoah | M | 1,050 | | | 2 Tony Awards in 1975 2 Drama Desk Awards in 1975 | Revival in 1989 |
| 118 | Annie Get Your Gun | M | 1,045 | | | 2 Tony Awards in 1999, including Best Revival of a Musical A Drama Desk Award in 1999 A Special Drama Desk Award in 2001 for Reba McEntire Grammy Award for Best Musical Show Album in 2000 | Original production in 1946 and revival in 1966 |
| 119 | The Teahouse of the August Moon | P | 1,027 | | | 3 Tony Awards in 1954, including Best Play Pulitzer Prize for Drama in 1954 | |
| 120 | Les Misérables | M | 1,024 | | | | Original production in 1987 and revival in 2006 |
| 121 | Damn Yankees | M | 1,019 | | | 7 Tony Awards in 1956, including Best Musical | Revival in 1994 |
| 122 | Grand Hotel | M | 1,017 | | | 5 Tony Awards in 1990 5 Drama Desk Awards in 1990 | |
| 123 | Contact | D | 1,010 | | | 4 Tony Awards in 2000, including Best Musical 4 Drama Desk Awards in 2000, including Outstanding Musical | |
| 124 | Never Too Late | P | 1,007 | | | | |
| 125 | Beatlemania | M | 1,006 | | | | |
| 126 | Big River | M | 1,005 | | | 7 Tony Awards in 1985, including Best Musical 7 Drama Desk Awards in 1985 | Revival in 2003 |
| 127 | Newsies | M | 1,004 | | | 2 Tony Awards in 2012 2 Drama Desk Awards in 2012 | |
| Took lead | Title | Type | Opening date | Closing date | Performances | Comments/Notes |
| 2006-01-09January 9, 2006 | The Phantom of the Opera | M | 1988-01-26January 26, 1988 | 2023-04-16April 16, 2023 | 13,981 |
|
| 1997-06-19June 19, 1997 | Cats | M | 1982-10-07October 7, 1982 | 2000-09-09September 10, 2000 | 7,485 | 7 Tony Awards in 1983, including Best Musical 3 Drama Desk Awards in 1983 Grammy Award for Best Cast Show Album in 1984 Revival in 2016 |
| 1983-09-29September 29, 1983 | A Chorus Line | M | 1975-07-25July 25, 1975 | 1990-04-28April 28, 1990 | 6,137 | 9 Tony Awards in 1976, including Best Musical 5 Drama Desk Awards in 1976, including Outstanding Musical A Special Tony Award in 1984 for becoming Broadway's longest-running musical Pulitzer Prize for Drama in 1976 Revival in 2006 |
| 1979-12-08December 8, 1979 | Grease | M | 1972-02-14February 14, 1972 | 1980-04-13April 13, 1980 | 3,388 | 2 Drama Desk Awards in 1972 Revivals in 1994 and 2007 |
| 1972-06-17June 17, 1972 | Fiddler on the Roof | M | 1964-09-22September 22, 1964 | 1972-07-02July 2, 1972 | 3,242 | Became longest running musical in July 1971, at 2,845 performances passing 2,844 mark of Hello Dolly!. 9 Tony Awards in 1965, including Best Musical A Special Tony Award in 1972 for becoming Broadway's longest-running musical Revivals in 1976, 1981, 1990,, 2004, and 2015 |
| 1947-06-14June 14, 1947 | Life with Father | P | 1939-11-08November 8, 1939 | 1947-07-12July 12, 1947 | 3,224 | Broadway's longest-running straight play. Started at Empire Theatre, moved to the Bijou Theatre in 1945, and finished up its run in 1947 at the Alvin Theatre. |
| 1939-06-01June 1939 | Tobacco Road | P | 1933-12-04December 4, 1933 | 1941-05-31May 31, 1941 | 3,182 | Revivals in 1942, 1943, and 1950 |
| 1925-05-23May 23, 1925 | Abie's Irish Rose | P | 1923-05-23May 23, 1923 | 1927-10-1October 1, 1927 | 2,327 | Revivals in 1937 and 1954 |
| 1920-03-17March 17, 1920 | Lightnin' | P | 1918-08-26August 26, 1918 | 1921-08-27August 27, 1921 | 1,291 | Revival in 1938 |
| 1893-06-22June 22, 1893 | A Trip to Chinatown | M | 1891-11-09November 9, 1891 | 1893-08-07August 7, 1893 | 657 | |
| 1885-12-01December 1885 | Adonis | M | 1884-09-04September 4, 1884 | 1886-04-17April 17, 1886 | 603 | |
| 1881-05-01May 1881 | Hazel Kirke | P | 1880-02-04February 4, 1880 | 1881-05-31May 31, 1881 | 486 | 250th performance programme claimed play had exceeded number of consecutive performances of any "similar play" in the country on its 238th performance, which is no doubt a reference to Pique which ran for 237 performances. |
| 1885-12-01March 1868 | Humpty Dumpty | M | 1868-03-10March 10, 1868 | 1869-05-15May 15, 1869 | 483 | Revival in 1871-1872 |
| 1867-08-05August 5, 1867 | The Black Crook | M | 1866-09-12September 12, 1866 | 1868-01-04January 4, 1868 | 474 | First Broadway show to run for over one year. In terms of a "musical", The Seven Sisters, was probably the longest running show closest to a "musical" prior to this. |
| 1853-10-011853 | Uncle Tom's Cabin | P | 1853-08-23August 8, 1853 | 1854-05-13May 13, 1854 | 325 | Has generally been classified as a play, though some arguments have been made that it was a musical. Played at the National Theatre. |
| 1850-01-011850 | The Drunkard | P | 1850-01-011850 | 1850-10-07October 7, 1850? | 100 | As of October 7, 1850, it hit 100 consecutive performances in New York, the first play to do so. At Barnum's American Museum. It debuted in 1844 outside New York at the Boston Museum. |
| 1844-09-24September 24, 1844 | Putnam, the Iron Son of '76 | P | 1844-08-05August 5, 1844 | 1844-11-02November 2, 1844 | 78 | At the Bowery Theatre. If Mazeppa ran 43 nights in 1833 and was previous record, Putnam became most performed on its 44th performance on September 24, 1844. |
| 1833-08-091833 | Mazeppa, Or, The Wild Horse of Ukraine | P | 1833-06-22July 22, 1833 | 1833-09-09September 9, 1833 | 43 | At the Bowery Theatre with George Gale as Mazeppa. |
| 1831-01-281831 | The Elephant of Siam and the Fire Fiend by Samuel Beazley | P | 1831-01-10January 10, 1831 | 1831? | 18 | At the Bowery Theatre, the first season under Thomas S. Hamblin, who embraced melodramas which might support longer runs. The Elephant of Siam featured the elephant Mademoiselle D'Jeck, who of course needed to be used while available. The Water Witch, an adaption of a James Fenimore Cooper novel by Charles W. Taylor, which debuted on March 10, 1831, at the Bowery, also played for 18 performances. |