| School | Nickname | City | State/
province/
territory | Enrollment
| Conference |
| Abraham Baldwin Agricultural College | Golden Stallions | Tifton | Georgia | 3,768 | Southern States Athletic Conference |
| Alice Lloyd College | Eagles | Pippa Passes | Kentucky | 553 | Continental Athletic Conference |
| Aquinas College | Saints | Grand Rapids | Michigan | 1,295 | Wolverine–Hoosier Athletic Conference |
| Arizona Christian University | Firestorm | Phoenix | Arizona | 1,233 | Great Southwest Athletic Conference |
| Arkansas Baptist College | Buffaloes | Little Rock | Arkansas | 373 | Continental Athletic Conference |
| Ave Maria University | Gyrenes | Ave Maria | Florida | 1,335 | Sun Conference |
| Avila University | Eagles | Kansas City | Missouri | 1,733 | Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Baker University | Wildcats | Baldwin City | Kansas | 1,945 | Heart of America Athletic Conference |
| Bellevue University | Bruins | Bellevue | Nebraska | 14,476 | Frontier Conference |
| Benedictine College | Ravens | Atchison | Kansas | 2,465 | Heart of America Athletic Conference |
| Benedictine University at Mesa | Redhawks | Mesa | Arizona | 2,989 | Great Southwest Athletic Conference |
| Bethany College | Swedes | Lindsborg | Kansas | 637 | Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Threshers | North Newton | Kansas | 502 | Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Bethel University (IN) | Pilots | Mishawaka | Indiana | 1,222 | Crossroads League |
| Bethel University (TN) | Wildcats | McKenzie | Tennessee | 2,974 | Mid-South Conference |
| Bismarck State College | Mystics | Bismarck | North Dakota | 4,065 | Frontier Conference |
| Blue Mountain Christian University | Toppers | Blue Mountain | Mississippi | 971 | Southern States Athletic Conference |
| Bluefield University | Rams | Bluefield | Virginia | 989 | Appalachian Athletic Conference |
| Brenau University | Golden Tigers | Gainesville | Georgia | 2,420 | Appalachian Athletic Conference |
| Brescia University | Bearcats | Owensboro | Kentucky | 638 | River States Conference |
| Brewton–Parker Christian University | Barons | Mount Vernon | Georgia | 1,123 | Southern States Athletic Conference |
| Briar Cliff University | Chargers | Sioux City | Iowa | 940 | Great Plains Athletic Conference |
| * | Thunderbirds | Vancouver | British Columbia | 60,863 | Cascade Collegiate Conference |
| Bryan College | Lions | Dayton | Tennessee | 1,548 | Appalachian Athletic Conference |
| Bushnell University | Beacons | Eugene | Oregon | 758 | Cascade Collegiate Conference |
| Cal Poly Maritime Academy | Keelhaulers | Vallejo | California | 805 | California Pacific Conference |
| Calumet College of St. Joseph | Crimson Wave | Whiting | Indiana | 674 | Chicagoland Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Campbellsville University | Tigers | Campbellsville | Kentucky | 12,451 | Mid-South Conference |
| Carolina University | Bruins | Winston-Salem | North Carolina | 893 | Continental Athletic Conference |
| Carroll College | Fighting Saints | Helena | Montana | 1,103 | Frontier Conference |
| Central Baptist College | Mustangs | Conway | Arkansas | 550 | American Midwest Conference |
| Central Christian College of Kansas | Tigers | McPherson | Kansas | 455 | Sooner Athletic Conference |
| Central Methodist University | Eagles | Fayette | Missouri | 1,017 | Heart of America Athletic Conference |
| Clarke University | Crusaders | Dubuque | Iowa | 1,025 | Heart of America Athletic Conference |
| Cleary University | Cougars | Howell | Michigan | 1,040 | Wolverine–Hoosier Athletic Conference |
| Mariners | Brunswick | Georgia | 3,189 | Sun Conference |
| Cougars | Columbia | Missouri | 6,046 | American Midwest Conference |
| Koalas | Columbia | South Carolina | 1,572 | Appalachian Athletic Conference |
| Rams | Columbia | South Carolina | 2,631 | Appalachian Athletic Conference |
| Concordia University–Nebraska | Bulldogs | Seward | Nebraska | 3,423 | Great Plains Athletic Conference |
| Corban University | Warriors | Salem | Oregon | 866 | Cascade Collegiate Conference |
| Cornerstone University | Golden Eagles | Grand Rapids | Michigan | 1,735 | Wolverine–Hoosier Athletic Conference |
| Cottey College | Comets | Nevada | Missouri | 266 | American Midwest Conference |
| Crowley's Ridge College | Pioneers | Paragould | Arkansas | 225 | American Midwest Conference |
| Culver–Stockton College | Wildcats | Canton | Missouri | 1,069 | Heart of America Athletic Conference |
| Cumberland University | Phoenix | Lebanon | Tennessee | 3,072 | Mid-South Conference |
| Patriots | Williamsburg | Kentucky | 20,327 | Mid-South Conference |
| Dakota State University | Trojans | Madison | South Dakota | 3,508 | Frontier Conference |
| Dakota Wesleyan University | Tigers | Mitchell | South Dakota | 886 | Great Plains Athletic Conference |
| Dalton State College | Roadrunners | Dalton | Georgia | 4,902 | Southern States Athletic Conference |
| Defiance College | Yellow Jackets and Lady Jackets | Defiance | Ohio | 511 | Wolverine–Hoosier Athletic Conference |
| Dickinson State University | Blue Hawks | Dickinson | North Dakota | 1,453 | Frontier Conference |
| Dillard University | Bleu Devils & Lady Bleu Devils | New Orleans | Louisiana | 1,122 | HBCU Athletic Conference |
| Doane College | Tigers | Crete | Nebraska | 1,948 | Great Plains Athletic Conference |
| Dordt University | Defenders | Sioux Center | Iowa | 1,929 | Great Plains Athletic Conference |
| Eastern Oregon University | Mountaineers | La Grande | Oregon | 2,798 | Cascade Collegiate Conference |
| Embry–Riddle Aeronautical University, Prescott | Eagles | Prescott | Arizona | 3,286 | Great Southwest Athletic Conference |
| Evangel University | Valor | Springfield | Missouri | 2,157 | Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Geoducks | Olympia | Washington | 2,320 | Cascade Collegiate Conference |
| Faulkner University | Eagles | Montgomery | Alabama | 2,933 | Southern States Athletic Conference |
| Fisher College | Falcons | Boston | Massachusetts | 1,501 | Continental Athletic Conference |
| Fisk University | Bulldogs | Nashville | Tennessee | 1,005 | HBCU Athletic Conference |
| Florida College | Falcons | Temple Terrace | Florida | 657 | Continental Athletic Conference |
| Florida Memorial University | Lions | Miami Gardens | Florida | 1,365 | Sun Conference |
| Florida National University | Conquistadors | Miami | Florida | 2,638 | Continental Athletic Conference |
| Freed–Hardeman University | Lions | Henderson | Tennessee | 2,294 | Mid-South Conference |
| Friends University | Falcons | Wichita | Kansas | 1,927 | Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Georgetown College | Tigers | Georgetown | Kentucky | 1,463 | Mid-South Conference |
| Georgia Gwinnett College | Grizzlies | Lawrenceville | Georgia | 11,907 | Continental Athletic Conference |
| Goshen College | Maple Leafs | Goshen | Indiana | 824 | Crossroads League |
| Governors State University | Jaguars | University Park | Illinois | 4,337 | Chicagoland Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Grace College & Seminary | Lancers | Winona Lake | Indiana | 2,271 | Crossroads League |
| Graceland University | Yellowjackets | Lamoni | Iowa | 1,195 | Heart of America Athletic Conference |
| Grand View University | Vikings | Des Moines | Iowa | 1,796 | Heart of America Athletic Conference |
| Hannibal–LaGrange University | Trojans | Hannibal | Missouri | 441 | American Midwest Conference |
| Harris–Stowe State University | Hornets | | Missouri | 1,098 | American Midwest Conference |
| Haskell Indian Nations University | Fighting Indians | Lawrence | Kansas | 878 | Continental Athletic Conference |
| Hastings College | Broncos | Hastings | Nebraska | 1,011 | Great Plains Athletic Conference |
| Eutectics | | Missouri | 631 | American Midwest Conference |
| Hesston College | Larks | Hesston | Kansas | 308 | Continental Athletic Conference |
| Holy Cross College | Saints | Notre Dame | Indiana | 547 | Chicagoland Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Hope International University | Royals | Fullerton | California | 1,140 | Great Southwest Athletic Conference |
| Huntington University | Foresters | Huntington | Indiana | 1,504 | Crossroads League |
| Huston–Tillotson University | Rams | Austin | Texas | 1,029 | HBCU Athletic Conference |
| Coyotes | Caldwell | Idaho | 1,076 | Cascade Collegiate Conference |
| Indiana Institute of Technology | Warriors | Fort Wayne | Indiana | 2,862 | Wolverine–Hoosier Athletic Conference |
| | Crimson Pride | Columbus | Indiana | 932 | River States Conference |
| | Red Wolves | Richmond | Indiana | 2,985 | River States Conference |
| | Cougars | Kokomo | Indiana | 2,892 | River States Conference |
| | Redhawks | Gary | Indiana | 3,045 | Chicagoland Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| | Titans | South Bend | Indiana | 4,446 | Chicagoland Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| | Grenadiers | New Albany | Indiana | 3,752 | River States Conference |
| Indiana Wesleyan University | Wildcats | Marion | Indiana | 2,207 | Crossroads League |
| Jarvis Christian University | Bulldogs | Hawkins | Texas | 800 | Red River Athletic Conference |
| John Brown University | Golden Eagles | Siloam Springs | Arkansas | 2,341 | Sooner Athletic Conference |
| Johnson University | Royals | Kimberlin Heights | Tennessee | 950 | Appalachian Athletic Conference |
| Judson University | Eagles | Elgin | Illinois | 1,058 | Chicagoland Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Kansas Wesleyan University | Coyotes | Salina | Kansas | 951 | Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Keiser University | Seahawks | West Palm Beach | Florida | 20,102 | Sun Conference |
| Kentucky Christian University | Knights | Grayson | Kentucky | 541 | River States Conference |
| La Sierra University | Golden Eagles | Riverside | California | 1,611 | Great Southwest Athletic Conference |
| Langston University | Lions | Langston | Oklahoma | 1,910 | Sooner Athletic Conference |
Lawrence Technological University
| Blue Devils | Southfield | Michigan | 3,260 | Wolverine–Hoosier Athletic Conference |
| Lewis–Clark State College | Warriors | Lewiston | Idaho | 3,706 | Cascade Collegiate Conference |
| Life University | Eagles | Marietta | Georgia | 2,711 | Southern States Athletic Conference |
| Life Pacific University | Warriors | San Dimas | California | 504 | Great Southwest Athletic Conference |
| Lindsey Wilson University | Blue Raiders | Columbia | Kentucky | 4,055 | Mid-South Conference |
| Louisiana Christian University | Wildcats | Pineville | Louisiana | 950 | Red River Athletic Conference |
| Louisiana State University at Alexandria | Generals | Alexandria | Louisiana | 5,330 | Red River Athletic Conference |
| Louisiana State University in Shreveport | Pilots & Lady Pilots | Shreveport | Louisiana | 9,736 | Red River Athletic Conference |
| Lourdes University | Gray Wolves | Sylvania | Ohio | 1,014 | Wolverine–Hoosier Athletic Conference |
| Loyola University New Orleans | Wolf Pack | New Orleans | Louisiana | 4,351 | Southern States Athletic Conference |
| Madonna University | Crusaders | Livonia | Michigan | 2,054 | Wolverine–Hoosier Athletic Conference |
| Marian University | Knights | Indianapolis | Indiana | 3,586 | Crossroads League |
| Mustangs | Santa Clarita | California | 2,799 | Great Southwest Athletic Conference |
| Mayville State University | Comets | Mayville | North Dakota | 1,025 | Frontier Conference |
| McPherson College | Bulldogs | McPherson | Kansas | 788 | Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Wolverines | Dearborn | Michigan | 8,035 | Wolverine–Hoosier Athletic Conference |
| Evangels | Oklahoma City | Oklahoma | 2,183 | Sooner Athletic Conference |
| MidAmerica Nazarene University | Pioneers | Olathe | Kansas | 1,539 | Heart of America Athletic Conference |
| Midland University | Warriors | Fremont | Nebraska | 1,557 | Great Plains Athletic Conference |
| Midway University | Eagles | Midway | Kentucky | 1,945 | River States Conference |
| Milligan University | Buffaloes | Elizabethton | Tennessee | 1,200 | Appalachian Athletic Conference |
| Mission University | Patriots | Springfield | Missouri | 377 | American Midwest Conference |
| Missouri Baptist University | Spartans | | Missouri | 5,641 | Heart of America Athletic Conference |
| Missouri Valley College | Vikings | Marshall | Missouri | 1,619 | Heart of America Athletic Conference |
| Rams | Prichard | Alabama | 1,911 | Southern States Athletic Conference |
| Montana State University–Northern | Lights and Skylights | Havre | Montana | 1,021 | Frontier Conference |
Montana Technological University
| Orediggers | Butte | Montana | 1,622 | Frontier Conference |
| Bulldogs | Dillon | Montana | 1,458 | Frontier Conference |
| Montreat College | Cavaliers | Montreat | North Carolina | 932 | Appalachian Athletic Conference |
| Morningside University | Mustangs | Sioux City | Iowa | 2,158 | Great Plains Athletic Conference |
| Morris College | Hornets | Sumter | South Carolina | 421 | Continental Athletic Conference |
| Mount Marty University | Lancers | Yankton | South Dakota | 1,314 | Great Plains Athletic Conference |
| Mount Mary University | Blue Angels | Milwaukee | Wisconsin | 1,224 | Chicagoland Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Mount Mercy University | Mustangs | Cedar Rapids | Iowa | 1,451 | Heart of America Athletic Conference |
| Mount Vernon Nazarene University | Cougars | Mount Vernon | Ohio | 1,845 | Crossroads League |
| Nelson University | Lions | Waxahachie | Texas | 1,725 | Sooner Athletic Conference |
| New College of Florida | Mighty Banyans | Sarasota | Florida | 732 | Sun Conference |
| North American University | Stallions | Stafford | Texas | 923 | Red River Athletic Conference |
| Trailblazers | Dallas | Texas | 3,797 | Red River Athletic Conference |
| Northern New Mexico College | Eagles | Española | New Mexico | 1,310 | California Pacific Conference |
| Eagles | Kirkland | Washington | 999 | Cascade Collegiate Conference |
| Northwestern College | Red Raiders | Orange City | Iowa | 1,665 | Great Plains Athletic Conference |
| | Racers | Lima | Ohio | 2,606 | Wolverine–Hoosier Athletic Conference |
| Oakland City University | Mighty Oaks | Oakland City | Indiana | 650 | River States Conference |
| Oakwood University | Ambassadors & Lady Ambassadors | Huntsville | Alabama | 1,319 | HBCU Athletic Conference |
| Oklahoma City University | Stars | Oklahoma City | Oklahoma | 2,763 | Sooner Athletic Conference |
| Oklahoma Panhandle State University | Aggies | Goodwell | Oklahoma | 1,071 | Sooner Athletic Conference |
| Oklahoma Wesleyan University | Eagles | Bartlesville | Oklahoma | 947 | Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Olivet Nazarene University | Tigers | Bourbonnais | Illinois | 3,275 | Chicagoland Collegiate Athletic Conference |
Oregon Institute of Technology
| Owls | Klamath Falls | Oregon | 5,103 | Cascade Collegiate Conference |
| Ottawa University | Braves | Ottawa | Kansas | 1,055 | Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Ottawa University Arizona | Spirit | Surprise | Arizona | 836 | Great Southwest Athletic Conference |
| Our Lady of the Lake University | Saints | San Antonio | Texas | 2,096 | Red River Athletic Conference |
| Bobcats | Point Lookout | Missouri | 1,427 | Sooner Athletic Conference |
| Pacific Union College | Pioneers | Angwin | California | 938 | California Pacific Conference |
| Park University | Pirates | Parkville | Missouri | 6,634 | Heart of America Athletic Conference |
| Park University Gilbert | Buccaneers | Gilbert | Arizona | 6,634 | Great Southwest Athletic Conference |
| Paul Quinn College | Tigers | Dallas | Texas | 602 | HBCU Athletic Conference |
| Peru State College | Bobcats | Peru | Nebraska | 1,638 | Heart of America Athletic Conference |
| Philander Smith University | Panthers | Little Rock | Arkansas | 866 | HBCU Athletic Conference |
| Bears | Pikeville | Kentucky | 2,610 | Appalachian Athletic Conference |
| Skyhawks | West Point | Georgia | 2,827 | Southern States Athletic Conference |
| Argonauts | Great Falls | Montana | 677 | Frontier Conference |
| Reinhardt University | Eagles | Waleska | Georgia | 1,170 | Appalachian Athletic Conference |
| RedStorm | Rio Grande | Ohio | 2,168 | River States Conference |
| Rochester Christian University | Warriors | Rochester | Michigan | 1,170 | Wolverine–Hoosier Athletic Conference |
| Rocky Mountain College | Battlin' Bears | Billings | Montana | 991 | Frontier Conference |
| Rust College | Bearcats | Holly Springs | Mississippi | 429 | HBCU Athletic Conference |
| Fighting Bees & Queen Bees | Davenport | Iowa | 2,703 | Chicagoland Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Fighting Saints | Joliet | Illinois | 3,185 | Chicagoland Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Cougars | Fort Wayne | Indiana | 1,852 | Crossroads League |
| Spires | Leavenworth | Kansas | 1,414 | Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Flames | Omaha | Nebraska | 733 | Great Plains Athletic Conference |
| Saint Mary-of-the-Woods College | Pomeroys | Saint Mary's | Indiana | 1,227 | River States Conference |
| Bobcats | Miami Gardens | Florida | 6,455 | Sun Conference |
| Saint Xavier University | Cougars | Chicago | Illinois | 3,457 | Chicagoland Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Savannah College of Art and Design* | Bees | Savannah | Georgia | 17,575 | Sun Conference |
| Savannah College of Art and Design–Atlanta* | Bees | Atlanta | Georgia | 17,575 | Appalachian Athletic Conference |
| Drovers | Chickasha | Oklahoma | 914 | Sooner Athletic Conference |
| Shawnee State University | Bears | Portsmouth | Ohio | 3,206 | River States Conference |
| Siena Heights University | Saints | Adrian | Michigan | 1,832 | Wolverine–Hoosier Athletic Conference |
| Simpson University | Red Hawks | Redding | California | 907 | California Pacific Conference |
| Soka University of America* | Lions | Aliso Viejo | California | 476 | Great Southwest Athletic Conference |
| Southeastern University | Fire | Lakeland | Florida | 10,400 | Sun Conference |
| | Knights and Lady Knights | New Orleans | Louisiana | 2,059 | HBCU Athletic Conference |
| Southern Oregon University | Raiders | Ashland | Oregon | 5,371 | Cascade Collegiate Conference |
| Mustangs | Hobbs | New Mexico | 1,034 | Red River Athletic Conference |
| Southwestern College | Moundbuilders | Winfield | Kansas | 1,139 | Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Southwestern Christian University | Eagles | Bethany | Oklahoma | 364 | Sooner Athletic Conference |
| Spartanburg Methodist College | Pioneers | Saxon | South Carolina | 1,029 | Appalachian Athletic Conference |
| Spring Arbor University | Cougars | Spring Arbor | Michigan | 2,390 | Crossroads League |
| Stanton University | Elks | Anaheim | California | 404 | California Pacific Conference |
| Stephens College | Stars | Columbia | Missouri | 532 | American Midwest Conference |
| Sterling College | Warriors | Sterling | Kansas | 707 | Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Stillman College | Tigers | Tuscaloosa | Alabama | 779 | HBCU Athletic Conference |
| Tabor College | Bluejays | Hillsboro | Kansas | 664 | Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Talladega College | Tornadoes | Talladega | Alabama | 837 | HBCU Athletic Conference |
| Taylor University | Trojans | Upland | Indiana | 2,398 | Crossroads League |
| | FireHawks | Pulaski | Tennessee | 978 | Southern States Athletic Conference |
| Tennessee Wesleyan University | Bulldogs | Athens | Tennessee | 1,074 | Appalachian Athletic Conference |
| Texas A&M University–San Antonio | Jaguars | San Antonio | Texas | 7,584 | Red River Athletic Conference |
| Texas A&M University–Texarkana | Eagles | Texarkana | Texas | 2,109 | Red River Athletic Conference |
| Texas A&M University–Victoria* | Jaguars | Victoria | Texas | 3,784 | Red River Athletic Conference |
| Texas College | Steers | Tyler | Texas | 644 | Red River Athletic Conference |
| Texas Wesleyan University | Rams | Fort Worth | Texas | 2,595 | Sooner Athletic Conference |
| Thomas University | Night Hawks | Thomasville | Georgia | 1,583 | Southern States Athletic Conference |
| Tougaloo College | Bulldogs | Tougaloo | Mississippi | 725 | HBCU Athletic Conference |
| Trinity Christian College | Trolls | Palos Heights | Illinois | 883 | Chicagoland Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Trinity Western University* | Spartans | Langley | British Columbia | 6,000 | Cascade Collegiate Conference |
| Truett McConnell University | Bears | Cleveland | Georgia | 2,714 | Appalachian Athletic Conference |
| Union Commonwealth University | Bulldogs | Barbourville | Kentucky | 1,129 | Appalachian Athletic Conference |
| Valley City State University | Vikings | Valley City | North Dakota | 1,754 | Frontier Conference |
| * | Vikes | Victoria | British Columbia | 22,020 | Continental Athletic Conference |
| Buccaneers | Saint Thomas | US Virgin Islands | 1,739 | HBCU Athletic Conference |
| Viterbo University | V-Hawks | La Crosse | Wisconsin | 2,301 | Chicagoland Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Voorhees University | Tigers | Denmark | South Carolina | 515 | HBCU Athletic Conference |
| Waldorf University | Warriors | Forest City | Iowa | 2,657 | Great Plains Athletic Conference |
| Walla Walla University | Wolves | College Place | Washington | 1,397 | Cascade Collegiate Conference |
| Royals | Lake Wales | Florida | 891 | Sun Conference |
| Warner Pacific University | Knights | Portland | Oregon | 350 | Cascade Collegiate Conference |
| Washington Adventist University | Shock | Takoma Park | Maryland | 695 | Continental Athletic Conference |
| Wayland Baptist University | Pioneers & Flying Queens | Plainview | Texas | 2,861 | Sooner Athletic Conference |
| Webber International University | Warriors | Babson Park | Florida | 930 | Sun Conference |
| West Virginia University Institute of Technology | Golden Bears | Beckley | West Virginia | 1,448 | River States Conference |
| Westcliff University | Warriors | Irvine | California | 6,532 | California Pacific Conference |
| Wilberforce University | Bulldogs | Wilberforce | Ohio | 617 | HBCU Athletic Conference |
| Wiley University | Wildcats | Marshall | Texas | 636 | HBCU Athletic Conference |
| William Carey University | Crusaders | Hattiesburg | Mississippi | 5,448 | Southern States Athletic Conference |
| William Penn University | Statesmen | Oskaloosa | Iowa | 1,536 | Heart of America Athletic Conference |
| William Woods University | Owls | Fulton | Missouri | 1,729 | Heart of America Athletic Conference |
| Williams Baptist University | Eagles | Walnut Ridge | Arkansas | 514 | American Midwest Conference |
| Xavier University of Louisiana | Gold Rush & Gold Nuggets | New Orleans | Louisiana | 3,181 | Red River Athletic Conference
|
| York University | Panthers | York | Nebraska | 585 | Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference |