Despite her hyperacusis and announcement that she will no longer be touring with the band, she has remained in Superchunk since 1989. Their latest album is Wild Loneliness, released in February 2022.
In 1989, Ballance alongside her bandmate MacMcCaughan, founded Merge Records for releases from Superchunk and similar artists. Ballance has also contributed to the bookOur Noise: The Story of Merge Records with Mac McCaughan and John Cook.