The Herrick Cobblestone is generally Greek Revivalin style and resembles a common design for cobblestone houses. It measures approximately with a two-way pitched roof. Walls are thick and consist of a backing wall of large stones with a face of smaller cobbles. Eleven quoins decorate the exterior corners. The quoins are large blocks of Platteville limestone. The house is on a foundation of Galena Dolomite. Chimneys are found at the end of the two gables, on the east and west. There are thirteen windows, each six-over-six. Lintels are wooden and are found on all except on three rear windows. The doorways has four sidelights on either side and a five-pane transom overhead. The front porch was added later and is Victorian in style. A small shed-like addition was built on the rear.