Four Days in September
Four Days in September is a 1997 Brazilian thriller film directed by Bruno Barreto and produced by his parents Lucy and Luiz Carlos Barreto. It is a dramatized version of the 1969 kidnapping of [the United States Ambassador to Brazil], Charles Burke Elbrick, by members of Revolutionary Movement 8th October and Ação Libertadora Nacional.
It was nominated as Best Foreign Language Film at the 70th Academy Awards.
Background
The film is "loosely based" on the 1979 memoir O Que É Isso, Companheiro?, written by politician Fernando Gabeira. In 1969, as a member of Revolutionary Movement 8th October, a student guerrilla group, he participated in the abduction of the United States ambassador to Brazil, negotiating to gain release of leftist political prisoners. MR-8 was protesting the recent takeover of Brazil by a military government and seeking the release of political prisoners. But, the military further increased its repression of dissent, MR-8 and ALN members were tortured by the police, and democracy was not re-established in Brazil until 1985.Gabeira later became a journalist and politician, elected as congressman from the Green Party.
Plot
The film is a fictionalized version of the dramatic events of the 1969 kidnapping of the [United States Ambassador to Brazil|abduction] of the American ambassador Charles Burke Elbrick. Elbrick was kidnapped in Rio de Janeiro by the Revolutionary Movement 8th October with the help of the Ação Libertadora Nacional. Gabeira as a student joins the radical movement after Brazil's military overthrew its government in a 1964 coup. In 1969, he and his comrades decide to kidnap the American ambassador to protest the Brazilians' coup; the film busies itself with the group's conspiring and execution of the crime. Paulo is portrayed as "the most intelligent and uncertain of the kidnappers."The film explores Paulo's love affair with Andréia, the guerrilla leader. It suggests a kind of friendship developing between Paulo and Elbrick. The ambassador is portrayed as a decent man who shares some of his kidnappers' frustrations regarding the Brazilian military dictatorship, and one who fulfills his duty to his own government.
Cast
The main characters include:- Paulo / Fernando Gabeira - member of the MR-8 guerrilla group and one of the kidnappers.
- Andréia / Maria - the beautiful and tough MR-8 guerrilla-group leader who falls in love with Paulo/Fernando.
- Charles Burke Elbrick - the American ambassador, who forms a bond with Paulo/Fernando.
- Jonas / Virgílio Gomes da Silva - member of ALN guerrilla group
- Marcão / Franklin Martins - second in command to the MR-8 guerrilla group and one of the kidnappers.
- Renée / Vera Sílvia Magalhães - member of the MR-8 guerrilla group and one of the kidnappers.
- Toledo / Joaquim Câmara Ferreira - member of ALN guerrilla group. He's a Spanish expatriate in Brazil that fought the dictatorship of Francoist Spain
- Henrique - former Navy enlistee and member of the National Intelligence Service of Brazil
- Brandão - member of the National Intelligence Service of Brazil
- Júlio / Cid Benjamin - member of the MR-8 guerrilla group and one of the kidnappers.
- César / Oswaldo - member of the MR-8 guerrilla group, arrested prior to the kidnapping of the Ambassador.
- Dona Margarida / Elba Souto-Maior
- Lília - wife of Henrique
- Mowinkel
- Jorge Cherques
Reception
Critical response
The film had mixed reviews, in part because of its fictionalizing Brazilian history, and its uneasy portrayal of terrorist activities by student radicals. Four Days in September has an approval rating of 59% on review aggregator website Rotten Tomatoes, based on 17 reviews, and an average rating of 6.5/10.Stephen Holden of The New York Times wrote, "Four Days in September is an uneasy hybrid of political thriller and high-minded meditation on terrorism, its psychology and its consequences." He noted that the film suggests the kidnapping was followed by worse political events, with increased repression, and torture of MR-8 members. He describes Cardoso as the most complex character.
Roger Ebert gave it two stars, saying the film was marked by a "quiet sadness" and the "film examines the way that naive idealists took on more than they could handle." He suggests that the film tries to humanize both sides but seems muddled. Ebert writes, "The point of view is that of a middle-age man who no longer quite understands why, as a youth, he was so sure of things that now seem so puzzling."