List of NCAA Division I men's soccer First-Team All-America teams

The Division I First-Team All-Americans are the best eleven Division I U.S. college soccer players as selected by United Soccer Coaches.

1970–1983

From 1970 to 1983 the NCSAA only named defenders and forwards in addition to one goalkeeper.
* – repeat selection

Year	Goalkeeper	Defenders	Forwards
1970	Bill Nuttall	Buzz Demling Alan Harte Nick Iwanik Gerardo Pagnani Aladin Rodrigues	Al Henderson Richard Parkinson Randy Smith Stan Startzell Al Trost
1971	Cal Kern	Alan Harte* Gerardo Pagnani* John Schneider Andy Smiles William Smyth	Keith Aqui Al Henderson* Richard Parkinson* Mike Seerey John Moore
1972	Bob Rigby	Chris Bahr Gordon Cholmondeley Alan Harte* Gerardo Pagnani* Hans Wango	Ian Bain Eugene Durham Tom Kazembe Chris Papagianis Andy Rymarczuk
1973	Frank Tusinski	David D'Errico Kip Jordan Kevin Missey Farrukh Quraishi Ferdinand Treusacher	Henry Abadi Chris Bahr* Steve Baumann Dale Russell Tom Kazembe*
1974	Peter Mannos	Jesse Cox Bruce Hudson John Nusum Farrukh Quraishi* Mickey Rooney	Chris Bahr* Frantz Innocent Tom Kazembe* Dale Russell* Fred Pereira
1975	Peter Mannos*	Sam Bick Nimrod Dreyfus Greg Makowski John Nusum* Dale Rothe	Carlos Merchan George Nanchoff Steve Ralbovsky Dale Russell* Elson Seale
1976	Dragan Radovich	Carl Christensen George Gorleku Paul Hunter Greg Makowski* Glenn Myernick	Andy Atuegbu Ty Keough George Nanchoff* Louis Nanchoff Fred Pereira*
1977	Dragan Radovich*	Greg Makowski* John Nusum* Adrian Brooks Herve Guilliod Billy Gazonas	Angelo DiBernardo Emilio John Paul Milone John Maciel Rich Reice
1978	Dragan Radovich*	George Gorleku* Adrian Brooks* Greg Ryan Ty Keough* Barry Nix	Raymond Ford George Lesyw Peter Notaro Jim Stamatis Ole Mikkelsen
1979	Randy Phillips	Saeid Baghvardani Mike Freitag Barry Nix* Gerry Reardon John Young	Armando Betancourt Steve Charles Clyde O'Garro Ray Taylor
1980	Randy Phillips*	Saeid Baghvardani* Tim Gagan Erhardt Kapp Joe Morrone (Jr.) Kevin Murphy	Trevor Adair Chico Borja Damien Kelly Kemal Khilian Robert Meschbach
1981	Skip Gilbert	Dan Canter Richard Chinapoo Tom Groark Tom McDonald Barry Nix*	Armando Betancourt* Pedro DeBrito John Hayes Damien Kelly* Agyeman Prempeh
1982	Skip Gilbert*	Lou Karbiener Erik Nelson Adubarie Otorubio* Joe Ulrich	Matthew English Tom Killeen Kevin Maher Steve McLean Neil Ridgway Roy Wegerle

1983–present

Beginning with the 1983 season, the NSCAA began naming midfielders in addition to forwards and defenders.
* – repeat selection
Scholar Player of the Year in bold

Year	Goalkeeper	Defenders	Midfielders	Forwards
1983	Jamie Swanner	Keith Flynn David Masur Simon Spelling Cheche Vidal	Michael Brady Aidan McClusky Neil Ridgway*	Steve McLean* Roy Wegerle* Tom Kain
1984	Jeff Duback	Albert Adabe Adubarie Otorubio* Shaun Pendleton	Tony Bono Dale Ervine Aidan McCluskey*	John Gaffney Tom Kain* Michael King Sam Okpodu
1985	Tim Borer	Paul Caligiuri Shaun Pendleton* Michael Reynolds	John Kerr Jr. Mark Mettrick Bruce Murray	Michael Brady* Eric Eichmann Tom Kain* Sam Sumo
1986	Jeff Duback*	Paul Caligiuri* Benjamin Okaroh Steve Trittschuh	Mark Francis Gary Furlong John Harkes	John Catliff Guy Furfaro George Gelnovatch John Kerr Jr.*
1987	Bob Willen	Seamus Purcell Paul Rutenis David Smyth	John Harkes* Mark Mettrick* Tab Ramos	Doug Allison Bruce Murray* Ken Snow Peter Vermes
1988	Tony Meola	Jeff Agoos Marcelo Balboa Kevin Grimes	Henry Gutierrez Pat O'Kelly Mark Santel	Scott Benedetti Brian Benedict Ken Snow* Joey Valenti
1989	Tony Meola*	Kevin Grimes* Cam Rast Kevin Wylie	David Banks Tim Martin Pat O'Kelly*	Clark Brisson Peter Isaacs Robert Paterson Ken Snow
1990	Kasey Keller	Jeff Agoos* Scott Cannon Tom Loeber	Dario Brose Chad Deering Mark Santel*	Steve Rammel Ken Snow Billy Thompson David Weir
1991	Brad Friedel	Alexi Lalas Mike Lapper Cam Rast*	Peter DiMaggio Graham Merryweather Claudio Reyna	Gerell Elliott Henry Gutierrez* Manny Lagos Dante Washington
1992	Brad Friedel*	Joe Addo Scott Schweitzer Hector Zamora	Joe-Max Moore Claudio Reyna* Joey Thieman	Ben Crawley Robert Martella Alan Prampin Robert Ukrop
1993	Tim Deck	Shane Batelle Pedro Lopes Jorge Salcedo	Brian Kamler Jason Kreis Claudio Reyna*	Keith DeFini Jimmy Glenn Brian McBride Ståle Søbye
1994	David Kramer	Brandon Pollard Eddie Pope	Jason Kreis* Brian Maisonneuve Matt McKeon Todd Yeagley	Brent Bennett Mac Cozier Darren Eales Ståle Søbye*
1995	Chris Snitko	Scott Lamphear Ian McIntyre Brandon Pollard*	Ben Hickey Jesse Marsch Clint Mathis	Mike Fisher Matt McKeon* Toni Siikala Andy Williams
1996	Jon Busch	Tahj Jakins Pete Santora John Stratton	Mike Fisher* Steve Klein Mike Mekelburg	Tony Kuhn Ignace Moleka Johnny Torres Andy Williams*
1997	Matt Jordan	Leo Cullen Kevin Daly Pete Santora*	Daniel Hernández Alen Kozić Ben Olsen	Wade Barrett Sigurdur Eyjolfsson Dema Kovalenko Johnny Torres*
1998	Adin Brown	Matt Chulis Jamie Clark Kevin Kalish	Lazo Alavanja Jay Heaps Wojtek Krakowiak Maurizio Rocha	Chris Albright Seth George Dema Kovalenko* Richard Mulrooney
1999	Adin Brown	Nick Garcia Eric Denton David Wright	Carl Bussey Daniel Alvarez Jeff DiMaria Sasha Victorine	John Barry Nusum Mohammed Fahim Ricardo Villar Aleksey Korol
2000	Chris Hamblin	Chris Gbandi Cory Gibbs Ryan Suarez	Carl Bussey Mark Lisi Jorge Martínez Ryan Nelsen	Chris Carrieri Ali Curtis John Barry Nusum*
2001	Byron Foss	Chris Gbandi Danny Jackson Lee Morrison	Luchi Gonzalez Kyle Martino Diego Walsh	Nicholas McCreath Pat Noonan John Barry Nusum* Dipsy Selolwane
2002	Doug Warren	Todd Dunivant John Swann Chris Wingert	Ricardo Clark Sumed Ibrahim Andres Murriagui Diego Walsh*	Alecko Eskandarian Pat Noonan* Tim Pierce Mike Tranchilla
2003	Will Hesmer	Leonard Griffin Trevor McEachron Chris Wingert*	Scott Buete Sumed Ibrahim* C.J. Klaas	Adom Crew Ned Grabavoy Vedad Ibišević Joseph Ngwenya
2004	Christopher Sawyer	Ugo Ihemelu Drew Moor Gonzalo Segares	Michael Enfield C.J. Klaas* Sacha Kljestan Danny O'Rourke	Justin Moose Randi Patterson Ryan Pore Jeff Rowland
2005	Chris Dunsheath	Greg Dalby Tyson Wahl Marvell Wynne	Mehdi Ballouchy Scott Jones Yohann Mauger Brian Plotkin	Jason Garey Ross McKenzie Jeff Rowland* Willie Sims
2006	Nick Noble	Andrew Boyens Julius James Jay Needham John O'Reilly	Greg Dalby* Maurice Edu Ryan Maduro	Omar Cummings Charlie Davies Edson Elcock Joseph Lapira
2007	Stefan Frei	Eric Brunner Julius James* Pat Phelan	Reuben Ayarna Alejandro Bedoya Andrew Jacobson Peter Lowry	Xavier Balc Joseph Lapira* Patrick Nyarko O'Brian White
2008	Jovan Bubonja	Calum Angus Matt Besler Omar Gonzalez Tennant McVea	Corben Bone Sam Cronin Andrei Gotsmanov Baggio Hušidić	Andre Akpan Mike Grella Marcus Tracy Steve Zakuani
2009	Jeff Attinella	Bobby Warshaw	Kyle Nakazawa Corben Bone* Tony Tchani	Teal Bunbury
2010	Zac MacMath	Kofi Sarkodie A. J. Soares Andrew Wenger	Michael Farfan Matt Kassel Ryan Kinne* Ben Sippola	Will Bruin Tony Cascio Darlington Nagbe Colin Rolfe*
2011	Brian Holt	Chris Estridge Matt Hedges Charles Rodriguez	Miguel Ibarra Enzo Martinez Luis Silva	Ashton Bennett Ethan Finlay Billy Schuler Andrew Wenger*
2012	Andre Blake	Chad Barson Andrew Farrell Andrew Ribeiro	Scott Caldwell Jose Gomez Dillon Powers	Ashton Bennett* Ryan Finley Daniel Haber Patrick Mullins
2013	Andre Blake*	Steve Birnbaum A. J. Cochran Taylor Peay	Laurie Bell Aodhan Quinn Leo Stolz	Pete Caringi III Sagi Lev-Ari Patrick Mullins* Harrison Shipp
2014	Alex Bono	Joseph Greenspan Brandon Vincent Joshua Yaro	Jay Chapman Patrick Hodan Leo Stolz* Tanner Thompson	Andy Craven Fabian Herbers Robert Kristo Jordan Morris
2015	Callum Irving	Jonathan Campbell Kyle Fisher Brandon Vincent*	Mauro Cichero Jack Harrison Timo Pitter	Brandon Allen Nick DePuy Fabian Herbers* Jordan Morris* David Olsen
2016	Alec Ferrell	Alex Crognale Reagan Dunk Tomas Hilliard-Arce Miles Robinson	Ian Harkes Jacori Hayes Tanner Thompson*	Wuilito Fernandes Julian Gressel Albert Ruiz Gordon Wild
2017	Eric Dick	Tomas Hilliard-Arce* Tim Kübel Grant Lillard João Moutinho	Tucker Bone Mauro Cichero Cameron Lindley	Jon Bakero Brandon Bye Foster Langsdorf Santiago Patiño
2018	Trey Muse	Tanner Beason Alex Comsia Andrew Gutman Callum Montgomery	Giuseppe Barone Tucker Bone* Bruno Lapa	Omir Fernandez Cal Jennings Andre Shinyashiki J. J. Williams
2019	Colin Shutler	Josh Bauer Tanner Beason* Eddie Munjoma Dylan Nealis	Joe Bell Blake Bodily Bruno Lapa*	Matthew Bentley Cal Jennings* Anders Engebretsen Robbie Robinson
2020	Giannis Nikopolidis	Bridger Hansen Kyle Hiebert Tom Judge	Vitor Dias Dante Polvara Dylan Teves	Gloire Amanda Victor Bezerra Zach Ryan Valentin Noël
2021	Jan Hoffelner	Kyle Hiebert* Ryan Sailor Adam Savill	Benjamin Bender Yannick Bright Sofiane Djeffal Sean Zawadzki	Simon Becher Dylan Teves* Thorleifur Úlfarsson
2022	Casper Mols	Luis Grassow Noah Gulden Keegan Hughes	Knut Ahlander Alex Nagy JC Ngando Peter Stroud*	Eythor Bjorgolfsson Levonte Johnson Shak Mohammed Ilijah Paul
2023	Bryan Dowd	Kevin Bonilla Morris Duggan Garrison Tubbs Mads Westergren	Yannick Bright Eliot Goldthorp Jono Nyandjo	Matthew Bell Charlie Sharp Tyrese Spicer Ousmane Sylla
2024	Wessel Speel	Kyle Cusimano Siggi Magnusson Casper Svendby	Michael Adedokun Sam Bassett* Joran Gerbet	Jesus Barea Emil Jaaskelainen Sergio Ors Navarro Lineker Rodrigues dos Santos