Die for My Bitch was met with generally positive reviews from music critics. Scott Glaysher of HipHopDX praised Baby Keem's vocal performance and beatselection, which he felt were an improvement over his previous work. Writing for AllMusic, Fred Thomas also praised Baby Keem's performance, calling it a "enjoyable, low-stakes listen." XXL ranked Die for My Bitch one of the 50 best hip-hop projects of 2019.