Comparison of movie cameras


This article summarized the comparison of movie cameras.

35 mm

The 35 mm film gauge has long been the most common gauge in professional usage, and thus enjoys the greatest number of cameras currently available for professional usage. The modern era of 35 mm cameras dates to 1972, when Arri's Arriflex 35BL and Panavision's original Panaflex models emerged as the first self-blimped, lightweight cameras. Another distinguishing characteristic of modern cameras is the adoption of stronger lens mount seatings secured with a breech lock – namely the Arri PL and PV mount, both of which were designs descended from the BNCR mount of Mitchell cameras.

General

Camera model – specific camera body models and variants, usually officially authorizedCamera line – either the body family or system family Manufacturer – company of originIntroduced – first year of known usageWeight – usually just the body, but may include accessories as mentionedMOS/sync – Sync-sound cameras are able to both maintain a constant speed and run quietly enough not to be heard by the sound recordist. MOS cameras do not meet either one or both of these requirements, and are usually used either for applications where camera noise is not a concern, or non-standard camera speeds are required. A camera is also deemed MOS if it cannot hold a constant speed, regardless of its noise levels.Noise level – measured noise made by the camera, dB, with film and at a given distance from the film plane, usually one meter. MOS cameras do not have a measured noise level since they are not intended to be used with recorded sound and thus are much louder.
Camera modelCamera lineManufacturerIntroducedWeightMOS/syncNoise level
Eyemo 71KEyemoBell and Howell1925MOSN/A
Arriflex 35-2CArriflex 35 IIArri1964, with empty magazineMOSN/A
Arriflex 35BL-1Arriflex 35BLArri1972, with empty magazineSync26 dB
Panaflex-XPanaflexPanavision1974Sync<24 dB
Arriflex 35BL-2Arriflex 35BLArri1975, with empty magazineSync26 dB
Panaflex Gold IIPanaflexPanavision1976, with short eyepieceSync<24 dB
Arriflex 35BL-3Arriflex 35BLArri1980, with empty magazineSync22 dB
Arriflex 35-3CArriflex 35 IIIArri1982;, with empty magazineMOSN/A
Moviecam SuperAmericaMoviecam SuperAmericaMoviecam1984Sync20 dB
Arriflex 35BL-4Arriflex 35BLArri1986, with empty magazineSync22 dB
Panaflex PlatinumPanaflexPanavision1986Sync<22 dB
Panaflex Panastar IIPanaflex PanastarPanavision1987MOSN/A
Arriflex 35BL-4sArriflex 35BLArri1988, with empty magazineSync20 dB
Arriflex 535Arriflex 535Arri1990, body only;, with finder;, with finder and empty magazineSync19 dB
Moviecam CompactMoviecam CompactMoviecam1990Sync<20 dB
Arriflex 535BArriflex 535Arri1992, with empty magazineSync19 dB
Arriflex 435Arriflex 435Arri1995, without magazineMOSN/A
Arriflex 435ESArriflex 435Arri1995, without magazineMOSN/A
Moviecam SLMoviecam SLMoviecam1995Sync25 dB
Aaton 35-IIIAaton 35Aaton1997, with full magazine and onboard batterySync30 dB, 26 dB
Panaflex MillenniumPanaflex MillenniumPanavision1997Sync<19 dB
Panaflex Millennium XLPanaflex MillenniumPanavision1999Sync<23 dB
Arricam LTArricamArri2000, body only;, with finderSync<24 dB
Arricam STArricamArri2000, body only;, with finderSync<20 dB
Arriflex 435 AdvancedArriflex 435Arri2001, without magazineMOSN/A
Aaton 35-3PAaton 35Aaton2002, with full magazine and onboard batterySync30 dB, 24 dB
Arriflex 235Arriflex 235Arri2004, with viewfinderMOSN/A
Arriflex 435 XtremeArriflex 435Arri2004, without magazineMOSN/A
Panaflex Millennium XL2Panaflex MillenniumPanavision2004
Aaton PenelopeAaton PenelopeAaton2008, with full magazine and onboard batterySync23 dB, 22 dB

Lens and gate aperture

Lens mount – the type of mount required for using the camera. Certain lenses may not be able to be used with particular cameras if the mounts are incompatible. The lens mount must be shifted to be centered to accommodate the Super 16 format from standard 16.Aperture size – the size of the aperture of the gate.Aperture plate – is the gate removable for inspection and what accessories may it have?Lens interface – electronic information system located in the lens mount to communicate lens data to the camera and accessories.Ground glass – interchangeable ground glasses allow for the viewfinder to display whichever aspect ratio is being framed for.Frameline glow – can the camera make the framelines glow for easier viewing in low-light conditions?
Camera modelLens mountSuper 35?Aperture sizeAperture plateLens interfaceGround glassFrameline glow?
Eyemo 71KEyemo mount, many conversionsNo, but conversions existFull framefixednoneinterchangeableNo
Arriflex 35-2CArri standard and Arri bayonetNo, but conversions existAcademy ratiofixednoneinterchangeableNo
Arriflex 35BL-1Arri bayonetNoAcademy ratio, custom sizes existremovablenoneinterchangeableNo
Panaflex-XPV mount;YesFull frameremovable; interchangeable format masksnoneinterchangeableYes
Arriflex 35BL-2Arri bayonetNoAcademy ratio, custom sizes existremovablenoneinterchangeableNo
Panaflex Gold IIPV mountYesFull frameremovable; interchangeable format masksnoneinterchangeableYes
Arriflex 35BL-3Arri PL or BNCR mountNoAcademy ratio, custom sizes existremovablenone, but Lens Data Archive can be usedinterchangeableNo
Arriflex 35-3CArri PLNoAcademy ratioremovablenone, but Lens Data Archive can be usedinterchangeableNo
Moviecam SuperAmericaArri PL and BNCR mountYesfull range availableremovablenone, but Lens Data Archive can be usedinterchangeableYes
Arriflex 35BL-4Arri PLYesAcademy ratio, custom sizes existremovablenone, but Lens Data Archive can be usedinterchangeableYes
Panaflex PlatinumPV mountYesFull frameremovable; interchangeable format masksnoneinterchangeableYes
Panaflex Panastar IIPV mountYesFull frameremovable; interchangeable format masksnoneinterchangeableYes
Arriflex 35BL-4sArri PLYesAcademy ratio, custom sizes existremovablenone, but Lens Data Archive can be usedinterchangeableYes
Arriflex 535Arri PLYesfull range availableremovable; interchangeable format masks and filter holdersnone, but Lens Data Archive can be usedinterchangeableYes
Moviecam CompactArri PL and BNCR mountYesfull range availableremovablenone, but Lens Data Archive can be usedinterchangeableYes
Arriflex 535BArri PLYesfull range availableremovable; interchangeable format masks and filter holdersnone, but Lens Data Archive can be usedinterchangeableYes
Arriflex 435Arri PL, PV mountYesfull range availableremovable; interchangeable format masks and filter holdersnone, but Lens Data Archive can be usedinterchangeableYes
Arriflex 435ESArri PL, PV mountYesfull range availableremovable; interchangeable format masks and filter holdersnone, but Lens Data Archive can be usedinterchangeableYes
Moviecam SLArri PLYesfull range availableremovablenone, but Lens Data Archive can be usedinterchangeableYes
Aaton 35-IIIArri PL, PV mount, or NikonYesfull framefixednone, but Lens Data Archive can be usedinterchangeableYes
Panaflex MillenniumPV mountYesfull frameremovable; interchangeable format masksnoneinterchangeableYes
Panaflex Millennium XLPV mountYesfull frameremovable; interchangeable format masksnoneinterchangeableYes
Arricam LTArri PLYesfull frameremovable; interchangeable format masks and filter holdersLens Data System contacts; integrated Lens Data Box interchangeableYes
Arricam STArri PLYesfull frameremovable; interchangeable format masks and filter holdersLens Data System contacts; integrated Lens Data Box interchangeableYes
Arriflex 435 AdvancedArri PL, PV mountYesfull frameremovable; interchangeable format masks and filter holdersLens Data System contacts; usable with FEM-2 unitinterchangeableYes
Aaton 35-3PArri PL, PV mount, or NikonYesfull framefixednone, but Lens Data Archive can be usedinterchangeableYes
Arriflex 235Arri PLYesfull frameremovablenone, but Lens Data Archive can be usedinterchangeableYes
Arriflex 435 XtremeArri PL, PV mountYesfull range availableremovable; interchangeable format masks and filter holdersLens Data System contacts and integrated electronicsinterchangeableYes

Shutter

Reflex – is the shutter a reflex mirror design?Designrotary disc shutters have two common designs – a "half-moon" disc of 180° or "butterfly" of two e.g. 90° segments opposite each other which spin at half-speed.Location – where the shutter is centeredAdjustment – how the shutter angle can be adjusted. Most manual designs can only be adjusted when the camera is not running, often with the lens removed. All electronic shutters allow adjustment at all times, including when the camera is running.Angles – shutter angles available and in what increments or stops, if not continuous.
Camera modelReflex?DesignLocationAdjustmentAngles
Eyemo 71KNo, but many conversionsHalf-moonBeside gatefixed160°; many conversions for different angles
Arriflex 35-2CYesButterflyUnderneath gatefixed180°, although the V/B variant is adjustable from 0° to 165°
Arriflex 35BL-1YesButterflyUnderneath gatefixed180°
Panaflex-XYesButterflyBeside gatemanually while running or in standbybetween 50° and 200°, continuously adjustable
Arriflex 35BL-2YesButterflyUnderneath gatefixed180°
Panaflex Gold IIYesButterflyBeside gatemanually while running or in standbybetween 50° and 200°, continuously adjustable
Arriflex 35BL-3YesHalf-moonUnderneath gatemanualstops at 144°, 172.8°, and 180°
Arriflex 35-3CYesButterflyUnderneath gatemanual0° to 165° with stops every 15°
Moviecam SuperAmericaYesHalf-moonUnderneath gatemanualstops at 45°, 90°, 120°, 144°, 172.8°, and 180°.
Arriflex 35BL-4YesHalf-moonUnderneath gatemanualstops at 144°, 172.8°, and 180°
Panaflex PlatinumYesButterflyBeside gateelectronic or manually while running or in standbybetween 50° and 200°, in 0.1° stops
Panaflex Panastar IIYesButterflyBeside gateelectronic or manually while running or in standbybetween 45° and 180°, in 0.1° stops
Arriflex 35BL-4sYesHalf-moonUnderneath gatemanualstops at 144°, 172.8°, and 180°
Arriflex 535YesHalf-moonUnderneath gateelectronicbetween 11° and 180°, in 0.01° stops
Moviecam CompactYesHalf-moonUnderneath gatemanualstops at 45°, 90°, 120°, 144°, 172.8°, and 180°. 22.5° available on newer models.
Arriflex 535BYesHalf-moonUnderneath gatemanualstops every 15° between 15° and 180°, also stops at 144° and 172.8°
Arriflex 435YesHalf-moonUnderneath gatemanualstops every 15° between 30° and 135°, also stops at 11.2°, 22.5°, 144°, 172.8°, and 180°
Arriflex 435ESYesHalf-moonUnderneath gateelectronicbetween 11.2° and 180°, in 0.1° stops
Moviecam SLYesHalf-moonUnderneath gatemanualstops at 22.5°, 45°, 90°, 120°, 144°, 172.8°, and 180°.
Aaton 35-IIIYesHalf-moonUnderneath gatemanualstops at 144°, 150°, 172.8°, and 180°
Panaflex MillenniumYesButterflyBeside gateelectronic or manually while running or in standbybetween 11.2° and 180°, in 0.1° stops
Panaflex Millennium XLYesButterflyBeside gateelectronic or manually while running or in standbybetween 11.2° and 180°, in 0.1° stops
Arricam LTYesHalf-moonUnderneath gateelectronicbetween 0° and 180°, in 0.1° stops
Arricam STYesHalf-moonUnderneath gateelectronicbetween 0° and 180°, in 0.1° stops
Arriflex 435 AdvancedYesHalf-moonUnderneath gateelectronicbetween 11.2° and 180°, in 0.1° stops
Aaton 35-3PYesHalf-moonUnderneath gatemanualstops at 144°, 150°, 172.8°, and 180°
Arriflex 235YesHalf-moonUnderneath gatemanualstops every 15° between 45° and 150°, also stops at 144°, 172.8°, and 180°
Arriflex 435 XtremeYesHalf-moonUnderneath gateelectronicbetween 11.2° and 180°, in 0.1° stops

Movement

Movement type – design of the movement mechanismPulldown claws – number of claws which engage the film perforations to transport the film while the shutter is closed. Some claws may have more than one pin in order to engage multiple perfs at a time.Registration pins – number of pins which engage the film perforations during exposure in order to ensure consistent image stability from frame to frame.Frame rate – range of speeds in frame/s and smallest increments of change allowed. Accessories noted where required for certain speeds.Frame rate – range of speeds in frame/s and smallest increments of change allowed. Accessories noted where required for certain speeds.Motor – type of motor, voltage, crystal-controlled speeds Pulldownnegative pulldown options availablePitch control? – does the camera allow for adjustment of the pulldown claw to optimize camera noise and avoid perforation damage?
Camera modelMovement typePulldown clawsRegistration pinsFrame rate Frame rate MotorPulldownPitch control?
Eyemo 71Kclockwork mechanism104–50 frame/sNospring-wound, several motors available4 perfNo
Arriflex 35-2Ccam-driven10depends on motor; speeds ranging from 5–80 frame/s availableNoseveral available, including 32V DC handgrip, 16V DC governor, 24-28V DC and 16V DC variables.4 perfNo
Arriflex 35BL-1cam-driven425–100 frame/sNo12V DC, Xtal at 24, 25, and 30 frame/s4 perfNo
Panaflex-XMitchell-design, cam driven224–34 frame/sNo24V DC brushed, Xtal at 24, 25, and 29.97 frame/s4 and 3 perfYes
Arriflex 35BL-2cam-driven225–50 frame/sNo12V DC, Xtal at 24, 25, and 30 frame/s4 perfNo
Panaflex Gold IIMitchell-design, cam driven224–34 frame/sNo24V DC brushed, Xtal at 24, 25, and 29.97 frame/s4 and 3 perfYes
Arriflex 35BL-3cam-driven225–50 frame/sNo12V DC, Xtal at 24, 25, and 30 frame/s4 perfNo
Arriflex 35-3Ccam-driven1 14–100 frame/s; some models can reach 130 frame/s4–100 frame/s; some models can reach 130 frame/s12/24V DC, Xtal at 24, 25, and 30 frame/s4 and 3 perfNo
Moviecam SuperAmericacompensating link movement2212–32 frame/s in 1 frame/s increments; 1–50 frame/s in 0.001 frame/s increments with speedbox12–32 frame/s in 0.001 frame/s increments with speedbox24V DC microprocessor-controlled, Xtal at all speeds4 perfYes
Arriflex 35BL-4cam-driven225–40 frame/sNo12V DC, Xtal at 24, 25, and 30 frame/s4 perfNo
Panaflex PlatinumMitchell-design, cam driven224–36 frame/s in 0.1 frame/s increments4–36 frame/s in 0.1 frame/s increments24V DC brushed, Xtal at all speeds4 and 3 perfYes
Panaflex Panastar IIMitchell-design, cam driven424–120 frame/s in 1 frame/s increments4–120 frame/s in 1 frame/s increments24V DC brushed, Xtal at all speeds4 and 3 perfYes
Arriflex 35BL-4sseven-link movement225–40 frame/sNo12V DC, Xtal at 24, 25, and 30 frame/s4 and 3 perfYes
Arriflex 535seven-link movement223–50 frame/s in 0.001 frame/s increments; 1 frame/s if phase button held3–50 frame/s in 0.001 frame/s increments24V DC microprocessor-controlled, Xtal at 1, 24, 25, 29.97, and 30 frame/s forwards4 and 3 perfYes
Moviecam Compactcompensating link movement2212–32 frame/s in 1 frame/s increments; 2–50 frame/s in 0.001 frame/s increments with speedbox12–32 frame/s in 0.001 frame/s increments with speedbox24V DC microprocessor-controlled, Xtal at all speeds4 perf; 3 perf available for Mk 2Yes
Arriflex 535Bseven-link movement223–60 frame/s in 0.001 frame/s increments; 1 frame/s if phase button held3–60 frame/s in 0.001 frame/s increments24V DC microprocessor-controlled, Xtal at all speeds4 and 3 perfYes
Arriflex 435five-link movement2 21–150 frame/s in 0.001 frame/s increments up to 100 frame/s and 0.01 frame/s increments after1–150 frame/s in 0.001 frame/s increments up to 100 frame/s and 0.01 frame/s increments afterDC quartz-controlled, Xtal at all speeds4 and 3 perfYes
Arriflex 435ESfive-link movement2 21–150 frame/s in 0.001 frame/s increments up to 100 frame/s and 0.01 frame/s increments after1–150 frame/s in 0.001 frame/s increments up to 100 frame/s and 0.01 frame/s increments afterDC quartz-controlled, Xtal at all speeds4 and 3 perfYes
Moviecam SLcompensating link movement2212–40 frame/s in 1 frame/s increments; 2–40 frame/s in 0.001 frame/s increments with speedbox12–32 frame/s in 0.001 frame/s increments with speedbox 24V DC microprocessor-controlled, Xtal at all speeds4 perfYes
Aaton 35-IIImagnetic drive wheels between body and magco-planarNo3-32 frame/s in 0.001 frame/s incrementsNotri-phase brushless, Xtal at all speeds4 and 3 perfYes
Panaflex MillenniumMitchell-design, cam driven223–50 frame/s in 0.001 frame/s increments3–50 frame/s in 0.001 frame/s incrementsdual brushless for shutter and movement, single variable for shutter angle, Xtal all speeds4 and 3 perfYes
Panaflex Millennium XLMitchell-design, cam driven223–40 frame/s in 0.001 frame/s incrementsNodual brushless for shutter and movement, single variable for shutter angle, Xtal all speeds4 and 3 perfYes
Arricam LTfive-link movement221–48 frame/s in 0.001 frame/s increments; speeds with decimal places must be set with accessories1–32 frame/s in 0.001 frame/s increments; speeds with decimal places must be set with accessoriesdual brushless for shutter and movement, Xtal all speeds4, 3, and 2 perfYes
Arricam STfive-link movement221–60 frame/s in 0.001 frame/s increments; speeds with decimal places must be set with accessories1–32 frame/s in 0.001 frame/s increments; speeds with decimal places must be set with accessoriesdual brushless for shutter and movement, Xtal all speeds4, 3, and 2 perfYes
Arriflex 435 Advancedfive-link movement2 20.1–150 frame/s in 0.001 frame/s increments up to 100 frame/s and 0.01 frame/s increments after0.1–150 frame/s in 0.001 frame/s increments up to 100 frame/s and 0.01 frame/s increments afterDC quartz-controlled, Xtal at all speeds4 and 3 perfYes
Aaton 35-3Pmagnetic drive wheels between body and magco-planarNo2-40 frame/s in 0.001 frame/s incrementsNotriphase brushless, Xtal at all speeds4 and 3 perfYes
Arriflex 235five-link movement1 11–75 frame/s in 0.001 frame/s increments25 frame/s DC quartz-controlled, Xtal at all speeds4, 3, and 2 perfNo
Arriflex 435 Xtremefive-link movement2 20.1–150 frame/s in 0.001 frame/s increments up to 100 frame/s and 0.01 frame/s increments after0.1–150 frame/s in 0.001 frame/s increments up to 100 frame/s and 0.01 frame/s increments afterDC quartz-controlled, Xtal at all speeds4 and 3 perfYes

16 mm

16 mm film occupies a rather curious position within filmmaking – with a wide range encompassing virtually every field – amateur home movies, student films, experimental films, television work, commercials, music videos, corporate films, industrial research, medical applications, and lower budget features. Its robust image quality in relation to its size allows for a much more versatile, accessible, and affordable usage in many fields where neither 35 mm nor Super 8 would be well-suited. Despite current challenges from the burgeoning digital video market, the consistent improvement of cameras, lenses, and film stocks have enabled the Super 16 format to flourish recently, with many labs reporting increased usage. The modern era of 16 mm cameras is concurrent with that of 35 mm for both the same reasons as 35 mm as well as an additional change: the creation of the Super 16 format by Rune Ericsson in 1971. The format expanded the usable film negative horizontally, which required a larger film gate and necessitated either specialized conversion of machined parts or purchase of new cameras designed with Super 16 gates. Since the format took more than a decade to slowly standardize, the competition from both high and low end video cameras has decimated the demand for 16 mm cameras for most non-professional usage. Therefore, there are relatively few Super 16 cameras, although most are considered professional-grade.

General

Camera modelCamera lineManufacturerIntroducedWeightMOS/syncLens mount
7LTR Aaton LTRAaton1974SyncAaton universal
54LTRAaton LTRAaton1982SyncAaton universal
Arriflex 16HSR2 Arriflex 16SRArri1982, with empty magazineSyncArri bayonet
Arriflex 16SR2 Arriflex 16SRArri1982, with empty magazineSyncArri bayonet
Panaflex 16 Panaflex 16PanavisionJune 27, 1984, with eyepieceSyncPV mount
XTRAaton XTRAaton1984SyncAaton universal
Arriflex 16HSR3Arriflex 16SRArri1992SyncArri PL
Arriflex 16SR3Arriflex 16SRArri1992SyncArri PL
X0plusAaton XTRAaton1992SyncAaton universal
XTRplusAaton XTRAaton1992SyncAaton universal
XTRprodAaton XTRAaton1994, with onboard battery and full magazineSyncArri PL, Aaton universal, or PV mount
A-MinimaA-MinimaAaton2000, with onboard battery and full magazineSyncArri PL and Nikon
Arriflex 416Arriflex 416Arri2006, with full magazineSyncArri PL
Arriflex 416 PlusArriflex 416Arri2006, with full magazineSyncArri PL
XteraAaton XTRAaton2006SyncArri PL, Aaton universal, or PV mount