The newspaper was founded in 1995 by Amos Lynch. Lynch was editor in chief of the Columbus edition of the Call and Post for 33 years prior to founding the Post. He had also played a founding role in the Ohio Sentinel in 1949. He was inducted into the Ohio Civil RightsHall of Fame in 2011. While editor of the Call & Post, Lynch was credited with bringing down longtimemayor M. E. Sensenbrenner, with the publication of photos depicting victims of police brutalitythe day before the 1971 election. In 2015, more than a decade after Lynch's retirement and a few months after his death, the Posttransitioned to a digital-only product, delivered by email. Alan W. Sorter purchased the paper at some point and launched an online digital newsplatform in 2018.