Brian Schaefer

Brian Schaefer is an American soccer player who plays as a defender for FC Cincinnati 2 in MLS Next Pro.

Early life

Schaefer played youth soccer with the Jacksonville Armada. Schaefer attended Fletcher High School and won the Gateway Conference championship in 2020 and was named the Player of the Year.

In 2020, Schaefer began attending the University of South Florida, where he played for the [South Florida Bulls men's soccer|men's soccer team]. On March 6, 2021, he scored the winning goal in a 2–1 victory over the Tulsa Golden Hurricane, for his first career collegiate goal, subsequently being named to the American Athletic Conference Weekly Honor Roll. At the end of his freshman season, he was named to the AAC All-Freshman Team. In 2022, he was named to the All-ACC Second Team and an Academic All-District selection.

In 2021, he played with the Jacksonville Armada U-23 in the National Premier Soccer League.
In 2022, Schaefer played with Tampa Bay United in USL League Two. In 2023, he played with St. Petersburg FC in USL League Two.
At the 2024 MLS SuperDraft, Schaefer was selected in the first round by FC Cincinnati. After participating in training camp with the first team, he signed a professional contract with the second team, FC Cincinnati 2 of MLS Next Pro, in February. He made his debut on March 17 against Chicago Fire FC II. He scored his first goal on June 15 against Carolina Core FC.
Schaefer scored his first goal of the 2025 [MLS Next Pro season] on April 20, 2025, in a 3–1 home victory over the New York [Red Bulls II].
Schaefer joined USL Championship team Indy Eleven on loan on September 3, 2025. He made his first appearance for the club on the same day, in a 0–2 away league victory over Hartford Athletic, replacing midfielder James Murphy in the 61st minute. He scored his first goal for the club on September 27, 2025, in a 2–1 home victory over FC Tulsa. Schaefer's loan expired at the end of the 2025 [Indy Eleven season|2025 season], returning to FC Cincinnati 2.