Baldwin High School was first built and occupied in 1888. In 1923, a new school building was constructed on the same site. A gymnasium and auditorium were added in 1942. Despite construction being halted by World War II, the community rallied to finish it. A new building was built once again in 1956 with the old building being repurposed. The school's current building was first occupied in 1995. In 2015, the high school building built in 1923 along with the gymnasium and auditorium added in 1942 were added to the National Historic Places list.