2015 Outer Critics Circle Awards


The 2015 Outer Critics Circle Awards winners were announced on May 11, 2015, recognizing excellence in Broadway and Off-Broadway productions during the 2014–15 season. Nominations were announced on April 20, 2015, with Something Rotten! receiving the most nominations with 12. On the Twentieth Century followed with nine nominations, and the An American in Paris received eight nominations. Among plays, Wolf Hall led the field with seven nominations.
The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time led the productions with the most awards, winning five including Outstanding New Broadway Play. An American in Paris won four awards, followed by Hamilton and The King and I with three wins each.

Awards and nominations

Award nominations were announced by Brian D'Arcy James and Jennifer Simard on April 20, 2015, with the winners announced on May 11, 2015, with the winners ceremony on May 21, 2016 at Sardi's, featuring Michael Cerveris, Nick Cordero, Raúl Esparza, Katie Finneran, Montego Glover, William Ivey Long and Jefferson Mays as presenters.
Following The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time winning Outstanding New Broadway Play and An American in Paris won Outstanding New Broadway Musical. For Off-Broadway, Between Riverside and Crazy won Outstanding New Off-Broadway Play and Hamilton won Outstanding New Off-Broadway Musical. For the revival categories, You Can't Take It With You won Outstanding Revival of a Play and The King and I won Outstanding Revival of a Musical. Ayad Akhtar took home the John Gassner Playwrights Award for The Invisible Hand. Despite leading the nominations, Something Rotten! did not take home any awards.
CategoryWinner and nominees
Outstanding New Broadway Play* The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-TimeThe AudienceWolf Hall
Outstanding New Broadway Musical* An American in ParisIt Shoulda Been YouThe Last ShipSomething Rotten!The Visit
Outstanding New Off-Broadway Play* Between Riverside and CrazyThe City of ConversationThe NetherRasheeda SpeakingThe Village Bike
Outstanding New Off-Broadway Musical* HamiltonA Christmas MemoryDisenchantedThe Fortress of SolitudeLonesome Traveler
Outstanding Revival of a Play* You Can't Take It With YouFashions for MenSkylightThe Heidi ChroniclesThe Elephant Man
Outstanding Revival of a Musical* The King and ISide ShowInto the WoodsOn the TownOn the Twentieth Century
John Gassner Award* Ayad Akhtar – The Invisible Hand
Outstanding Book of a Musical (Broadway or Off-Broadway)* Lin-Manuel MirandaHamilton
  • Brian HargroveIt Shoulda Been You
  • Karey Kirkpatrick & John O'FarrellSomething Rotten!
  • Terrence McNallyThe Visit
  • John Logan & Brian YorkeyThe Last Ship
  • Outstanding New Score (Broadway or Off-Broadway)* Lin-Manuel MirandaHamilton
  • John Kander & Fred EbbThe Visit
  • Wayne Kirkpatrick & Karey KirkpatrickSomething Rotten!
  • Barbara Anselmi & Brian HargroveIt Shoulda Been You
  • StingThe Last Ship
  • Outstanding Director of Play* Marianne Elliott The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time
  • Jeremy HerrinWolf Hall
  • Scott EllisYou Can't Take It With You
  • Stephen DaldryThe Audience
  • Scott EllisThe Elephant Man
  • Outstanding Director of a Musical* Christopher Wheeldon An American in Paris
  • Thomas KailHamilton
  • Casey NicholawSomething Rotten!
  • David Hyde PierceIt Shoulda Been You
  • Scott EllisOn the Twentieth Century
  • Outstanding Choreography* Christopher Wheeldon An American in Paris
  • Joshua BergasseOn the Town
  • Andy BlankenbuehlerHamilton
  • Warren CarlyleOn the Twentieth Century
  • Casey NicholawSomething Rotten!
  • Outstanding Actor in a Play* Alex Sharp The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time as Christopher Boone
  • Reed BirneyI'm Gonna Pray For You So Hard as David
  • Bradley CooperThe Elephant Man as John Merrick
  • Stephen McKinley HendersonBetween Riverside and Crazy as Pops
  • Ben MilesWolf Hall as Thomas Cromwell
  • Outstanding Actress in a Play* Helen Mirren The Audience as Queen Elizabeth II
  • Jan MaxwellThe City of Conversation as Hester Ferris
  • Elisabeth MossThe Heidi Chronicles as Heidi Holland
  • Tonya PinkinsRasheeda Speaking as Jaclyn
  • Greta GerwigThe Village Bike as Becky
  • Outstanding Featured Actor in a Play* Richard McCabe The Audience as Harold Wilson
  • Paul JessonWolf Hall as Cardinal Archbishop Thomas Wolsey / William Warham, Archbishop of Canterbury/ Sir John Seymour / Sir William Kingston
  • Alessandro NivolaThe Elephant Man as Frederick Treves
  • Nathaniel ParkerWolf Hall as King Henry VIII
  • Bryce PinkhamThe Heidi Chronicles as Peter Patrone
  • Outstanding Featured Actress in a Play* Annaleigh Ashford You Can't Take It With You as Essie Carmichael
  • Lydia LeonardWolf Hall as Anne Boleyn
  • Patricia ClarksonThe Elephant Man as Mrs. Kendal
  • Francesca FaridanyThe Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time as Siobhan
  • Julie HalstonYou Can't Take It With You as Gay Wellington
  • Outstanding Actor in a Musical* Robert Fairchild An American in Paris as Jerry Mulligan
  • Peter GallagherOn the Twentieth Century as Oscar Jaffee
  • Christian BorleSomething Rotten! as William Shakespeare
  • Tony YazbeckOn the Town as Gabey
  • Brian d'Arcy JamesSomething Rotten! as Nick Bottom
  • Outstanding Actress in a Musical* Kristin Chenoweth On the Twentieth Century as Lily Garland / Mildred Plotka
  • Chita RiveraThe Visit as Claire Zachanassian
  • Leanne CopeAn American in Paris as Lise Dassin
  • Tyne DalyIt Shoulda Been You as Judy Steinberg
  • Kelli O'HaraThe King and I as Anna Leonowens
  • Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical* Andy Karl On the Twentieth Century as Bruce Granit
  • Paul Alexander NolanDoctor Zhivago as Pasha Antipov
  • John CarianiSomething Rotten! as Nigel Bottom
  • Josh GrisettiIt Shoulda Been You as Marty Kaufman
  • Max von EssenAn American in Paris as Henri Baurel
  • Outstanding Featured Actress in a Musical* Ruthie Ann Miles The King and I as Lady Thiang
  • Mary Louise WilsonOn the Twentieth Century as Letitia Peabody Primrose
  • Megan FairchildOn the Town as Ivy Smith
  • Victoria ClarkGigi as Mamita Alvarez
  • Heidi BlickenstaffSomething Rotten! as Bea
  • Outstanding Solo Performance* Jim Dale Just Jim Dale
  • Joe Assadourian – The Bullpen
  • Benjamin ScheuerThe Lion
  • Cush JumboJosephine and I
  • Tom DuganWiesenthal
  • Outstanding Scenic Design* Bunny Christie The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time
  • David RockwellOn the Twentieth Century
  • Bob CrowleyAn American in Paris
  • Michael H. Yeargan – The King and I
  • Scott PaskSomething Rotten!
  • Outstanding Costume Design* Catherine Zuber The King and I
  • Gregg BarnesSomething Rotten!
  • Bob CrowleyThe Audience
  • William Ivey LongOn the Twentieth Century
  • Christopher OramWolf Hall
  • Outstanding Lighting Design* Paule Constable The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time'
  • Japhy Weideman – The Visit
  • Jeff Croiter – Something Rotten!
  • Rick FisherThe Audience
  • Natasha KatzAn American in Paris