Rick Swan reviewed Wizard's Challenge II for Dragon magazine #215. He called Wizard's Challenge II "a breezy, undemanding AD&Dgame adventure for a Dungeon Master and a single PC". He notes that because the adventure is playable in a single session, "it's good practice for novices and a pleasant diversion for veterans". Swan felt that the One-On-One series, which also includes "the equally appealing" Fighter's Challenge and Cleric's Challenge "seems like a natural to me; I'm surprised other publishers haven't jumped on the bandwagon."