William Marshal, 1st Earl of Pembroke


William Marshal, 1st Earl of Pembroke, also called William the Marshal, was an Anglo-Norman soldier and statesman during High Medieval England who served five English kings—Henry II and his son and co-ruler Young Henry, Richard I, John, and Henry III—as a royal adviser and agent and as a warrior of outstanding prowess.
Knighted in 1166, William spent his younger years as a successful competitor in military tournaments; 13th century chronicler Stephen Langton eulogises him as the "best knight that ever lived." In 1189, he became earl of Pembroke through his marriage to Isabel de Clare, whose parents were Aoife MacMurrough and Richard de Clare, 2nd Earl of Pembroke. The title of earl was not officially granted until 1199 and is considered to be the second creation of the Pembroke earldom. In 1216 upon the death of King John, William was appointed protector for John's nine-year-old Henry III and Provisions of Oxford#Background. Just before his death, William fulfilled a promise he said he made in his youth while on crusade by taking vows as a Knight Templar, and was buried in the Temple Church in London.
Before William, his father's family held a hereditary title of Earl Marshal#Lords [Marshal of England, 1135–1386|Marshal to the King], which by his father's time had become recognised as a chief or master marshalcy, involving management over other marshals and functionaries. William became known as "the Marshal", although by his time much of the function was delegated to more specialised representatives. Because he was an earl, and also known as the marshal, the term "earl marshal" was commonly used, and this later became an established hereditary title in the English peerage.

Early life

William's father, John Marshal, supported King Stephen when Stephen took the throne in 1135, but in about 1139 John changed sides to support the rival claimant Empress Matilda in her war of succession against Stephen, which led to the collapse of England into a 15-year civil war known as "the Anarchy". When Stephen besieged Newbury Castle in 1152, according to William's biographer, he used the young William as a hostage to ensure that John kept his promise to surrender the castle. John, however, used the time allotted to reinforce the castle and to alert Matilda's forces. When Stephen ordered John to surrender, threatening that William would be hanged, John replied that he should go ahead, saying, "I still have the hammer and the anvil with which to forge still more and better sons!"
Subsequently, a pretence was made to launch William from a pierrière towards the castle, but Stephen could not bring himself to harm young William. William remained a crown hostage for many months and was released following the peace resulting from the terms agreed at Winchester on 6 November 1153, by which the civil war was ended.

Knight

As a younger son of a minor nobleman, William had no lands or fortune to inherit and had to make his own way in life. Around age 12, when his father's career was faltering, he was sent to the Château de Tancarville in Normandy to be brought up in the household of William de Tancarville, a great magnate and cousin of William's mother. Here he began his training as a knight. This would have included biblical stories, Latin prayers, and exposure to French romance literature to confer precepts of chivalry upon the future knight. In Tancarville's household he is also likely to have learned practical lessons in the politics of courtly life. According to his 13th-century biography, L'Histoire de Guillaume le Marechal, Marshal had enemies at Tancarville's court who plotted against him—presumably men threatened by his close relationship with the magnate.
In 1166, William was knighted on campaign in Upper Normandy, which was invaded from Flanders. His first experience in battle received mixed reviews. According to L'Histoire, everyone who witnessed William in combat agreed that he had acquitted himself well. However, as medieval historian David Crouch remarks, "War in the twelfth century was not fought wholly for honour. Profit was there to be made..." In this regard William was not so successful, as he was unable to translate his combat victories into profit from either ransom or seized booty. L'Histoire relates that the earl of Essex, expecting the customary tribute from his valorous knight after the battle, jokingly remarked: "Oh? But Marshal, what are you saying? You had forty or sixty of them—yet you refuse me so small a thing!"
In 1167, William was sponsored by William de Tancarville in his first tournament, where he found his true calling and began to develop skills that later made him a tournament champion.
In 1168 William served in the household of his mother's brother, Patrick, Earl of Salisbury. Later that year Patrick was escorting Queen Eleanor on a journey near the boundary of her province of Aquitaine and Marshal was part of the escort. They were ambushed by Guy de Lusignan who was trying to capture Eleanor. Although Eleanor escaped unharmed, Patrick was killed; William was wounded in the thigh and was taken prisoner and conveyed to a Lusignan castle to be held for ransom. Someone at the castle took pity on William because it is told that he received a loaf of bread in which were concealed several lengths of clean linen bandages with which to dress his wounds. This act of kindness by an unknown person perhaps saved William's life as infection of the wound could have killed him. After a period of time, he was ransomed by Eleanor, who was apparently impressed by tales of his bravery. He remained a member of Eleanor's household for the next two years, taking part in tournaments and increasing his reputation as a chivalrous knight.

Service to Young King Henry

In 1170 Henry II appointed William as tutor-in-arms to his son, Henry the Young King. During the Revolt of 1173–1174 led by the Young King, little is known of William's specific activities besides his loyalty to Young Henry. After the failed rebellion, Young Henry and his retinue, including William, travelled with Henry II for 18 months before receiving permission to travel to Europe to participate in knightly tournaments. William followed the Young King, and from 1176 to 1182 both men gained prestige from winning tournaments. Tournaments were dangerous, often deadly, staged battles in which money and valuable prizes were to be won by capturing and ransoming opponents, their horses and armour. William became a legendary tournament champion: on his deathbed, he recalled besting 500 knights during his tournament career.
In late 1182 William was accused of having an affair with Young Henry's wife, Margaret of France. Historian Thomas Asbridge states that while the affair very strongly appears to have been fabricated by William's political enemies within the Young King's service, it cannot be proven either way. David Crouch suggests that the charge against William was actually one of lèse-majesté, brought on by William's own arrogance and greed, with the charge of adultery only introduced in Life of William Marshal as a distraction from the real charges, of which he was most probably guilty. Regardless of the truth of the accusations, by early 1183 William had been removed from the Young King's service.
Young Henry declared war against his brother Richard in January 1183, with Henry II siding with Richard. By May, William had been cleared of all charges against the Young King and returned to his service. However, the Young King became sick and died on 11 June 1183. On his deathbed, the Young King asked William to fulfil the vow the Young King had made in 1182 to take up the cross and undertake a crusade to the Holy Land, and after receiving Henry II's blessing William left for Jerusalem in late 1183. Nothing is known of his activities during the two years he was gone, except that he fulfilled Young Henry's vow and secretly committed to joining the Knights Templar on his deathbed. Historians disagree about why his time on crusade received no coverage in the otherwise-detailed History of William Marshal. Georges Duby believes it was at William's own discretion, perhaps relating to his having joined the Templars. Thomas Asbridge examined the complex circumstances in the Latin East at the time of William's journey, and concludes that even if he had taken part in military engagements, like the relief of Kerak in 1184 or King Guy of Lusignan's attack on the Bedouin in Sinai the same year, these battles might not have been worth recounting. Nicholas Paul has suggested that stories surrounding William's crusade by the time of the composition of the History of William Marshal may, on the contrary, have been considered too outlandish by the author.

Royal favour

After his return from the Holy Land in late 1185 or early 1186, William rejoined the court of King Henry II and served as a loyal captain through the many difficulties of Henry's final years. The returns of royal favour were almost immediate. The king gave William the large royal estate of Cartmel in Cumbria and the keeping of Heloise, the heiress of the northern barony of Lancaster. It may be that the king expected him to take the opportunity to marry her and become a northern baron, but William seems to have had grander ambitions for his marriage.
In 1188, faced with an attempt by Philip II to seize the disputed region of Berry, Henry summoned William to his side. The letter by which he did this survives and makes some sarcastic comments about William's complaints that he had not been properly rewarded to date for his service to the king. Henry therefore promised him the marriage and lands of Dionisia, lady of Châteauroux in Berry. In the resulting campaign, the king fell out with his heir Richard, count of Poitou, who consequently allied with Philip II against his father.
In 1189 while covering the flight of Henry from Le Mans to Chinon, William unhorsed Richard in a skirmish. William could have killed the prince but killed his horse instead, to make that point clear. He is said to have been the only man ever to unhorse Richard. Nonetheless, after Henry's death William was welcomed at court by Richard, apparently recognising that William's loyalty and military accomplishments were too useful to ignore, especially for a king who was intending to go on crusade.
During Henry's last days he had promised William the hand and estates of Isabel de Clare but had not completed the arrangements. King Richard, however, confirmed the offer and so in August 1189, William and Isabel married. William acquired large estates and claims in England, Wales, Normandy and Ireland. Some estates, however, were excluded from the deal. Marshal did not obtain Pembroke and the title of earl, which his father-in-law had enjoyed, until 1199, as it had been taken into the king's hand in 1154. However, the marriage transformed the landless knight from a minor family into one of the richest men in the kingdom, a sign of his power and prestige at court. They had five sons and five daughters, and have numerous descendants. William made many improvements to his wife's lands, including extensive additions to Pembroke Castle and Chepstow Castle. Even though the marriage was a reward for his political and military services, and despite a significant age difference, the couple appear to have developed a real love and affection for each other. It is also notable that there is no evidence that Marshal ever took a mistress, which was commonplace for nobles and often widely discussed and reported.
William was included in the council of regency which Richard appointed on his departure for the Third Crusade in 1190. He took the side of John, the king's brother, when the latter expelled Justiciar William Longchamp from the kingdom, but he soon discovered that the interests of John were different from those of Richard. Hence in 1193 he joined with the loyalists in making war upon him. In the spring of 1194 during the course of the hostilities in England and before Richard's return, William's elder brother John Marshal was killed while defending Marlborough for John. Richard allowed William to succeed his brother in the hereditary marshalship and his paternal honour of Hamstead Marshall. William served Richard in his wars in Normandy against Philip II. On Richard's deathbed, he designated William as custodian of Rouen and of the royal treasure during the interregnum.

King John and Magna Carta

William supported John when he became king in 1199, arguing against those who maintained the claims of Arthur of Brittany, the teenage son of John's elder brother Geoffrey. William was heavily engaged with the defence of Normandy against the growing pressure of the Capetian armies between 1200 and 1203. He sailed with John when he abandoned the duchy in December 1203. William and John had a falling out in the aftermath of the loss of Normandy when he was sent with the earl of Leicester as ambassadors to negotiate a truce with King Philip in 1204. William took the opportunity to negotiate the continued possession of his Norman lands.
Before commencing negotiations with Philip, William had been generously permitted to do homage to Philip by King John so he might keep his possessions in Normandy. However, once official negotiations began, Philip demanded that such homage be paid exclusively to him, which John had not consented to. When William paid homage to Philip, John took offence and there was a major row at court which led to cool relations between the two men. This became outright hostility in 1207 when John began to move against several major Irish magnates, including William. Though he left for Leinster in 1207, William was recalled and humiliated at court in the autumn of 1208, while John's justiciar in Ireland Meilyr fitz Henry invaded his lands, burning the town of New Ross.
Meilyr's defeat by Countess Isabel led to her husband's return to Leinster. He was once again in conflict with King John in his war with the Braose and Lacy families in 1210, but managed to survive. He stayed in Ireland until 1213, during which time he had Carlow Castle erected and restructured his honour of Leinster. Taken back into favour in 1212, he was summoned in 1213 to return to the English court. Despite their differences, William remained loyal throughout the hostilities between John and his barons which culminated on 15 June 1215 at Runnymede with the sealing of Magna Carta. William was one of the few English earls to remain loyal to the king through the First Barons' War. It was William whom John trusted on his deathbed to make sure John's nine-year-old son Henry would get the throne. William took responsibility for the king's funeral and burial at Worcester Cathedral.

Regent for Henry III

On 11 November 1216 at Gloucester, upon the death of King John, William was named by the king's council to serve as protector of Henry and regent of the kingdom. In spite of his advanced age he prosecuted the war against Prince Louis and the rebel barons with remarkable energy. In the battle of Lincoln he charged and fought at the head of the army, leading them to victory. He was preparing to besiege Louis in London when the war was terminated by the naval victory of Hubert de Burgh in the Strait of Dover.
William was criticised for the generosity of the terms he accorded to Louis in September 1217, but his expedient settlement was dictated by sound statesmanship and a desire to remove the French from England as quickly as possible. Self-restraint and compromise were the keynotes of William's policy, hoping to secure peace and stability for Henry. Both before and after the peace of 1217 he reissued Magna Carta, in which he is a signatory as one of the witnessing barons.

Death and legacy

William, who had enjoyed robust health throughout his life, was "plagued by illness and pain" in early 1219. By March he realised that he was dying, so he summoned his eldest son William and his household knights and left the Tower of London for his estate at Caversham where he called a meeting of the barons, Henry, the Papal Legate Pandulf Verraccio, Justiciar Hubert de Burgh, and Peter des Roches. William rejected the bishop's claim to the regency and entrusted the regency to the care of the papal legate; he apparently did not trust the bishop or any of the other magnates that he had gathered to this meeting. Fulfilling the vow he had made while on crusade, he was invested into the order of the Knights Templar on his deathbed. He died peacefully on 14 May 1219 at Caversham, surrounded by his friends and family. He was buried in the Temple Church in London, where his tomb can still be seen.
A statue of Marshal on horseback was unveiled in front of Pembroke Castle in 2022. It was created by Harriet Addyman, and followed a campaign by Pembroke and Monkton Local History Society.

Descendants

  1. William Marshal, 2nd Earl of Pembroke, married Alice de Béthune, daughter of Baldwin of Bethune; 23 April 1224 Eleanor Plantagenet, daughter of King John of England. They had no children.
  2. Richard Marshal, 3rd Earl of Pembroke, married Gervaise de Dinan. He died in captivity. They had no children.
  3. Maud Marshal, married Hugh Bigod, 3rd Earl of Norfolk, they had four children; William de Warenne, 5th Earl of Surrey, they had two children.
  4. Gilbert Marshal, 4th Earl of Pembroke, married Marjorie of Scotland, youngest daughter of King William I of Scotland; by an unknown mistress he had one illegitimate daughter:
  5. #Isabel Marshal, betrothed to Rhys ap Maelgwn Fychan
  6. Walter Marshal, 5th Earl of Pembroke, married Margaret de Quincy, Countess of Lincoln, granddaughter of Hugh de Kevelioc, 3rd Earl of Chester. No children.
  7. Isabel Marshal, married Gilbert de Clare, 4th Earl of Hertford, whose daughter Isabella of [Gloucester and Hertford|Isabel de Clare] married Robert Bruce, 5th Lord of Annandale, the grandfather of Robert the Bruce; Richard Plantagenet, Earl of Cornwall
  8. Sibyl Marshal, married William de Ferrers, 5th Earl of Derby; they had seven daughters.
  9. # Agnes de Ferrers, married William de Vesci.
  10. # Isabel de Ferrers
  11. # Maud de Ferrers, married Simon de Kyme, William de Vivonia (de Forz), and Amaury IX of Rochechouart.
  12. # Sibyl de Ferrers, married Sir Franco de Bohun.
  13. # Joan de Ferrers
  14. # Agatha de Ferrers, married Hugh de Mortimer, of Chelmarsh.
  15. # Eleanor de Ferrers, married William de Vaux of Tharston and Wisset, Roger de Quincy, Earl of Winchester, and Roger de Leyburne of Elham.
  16. Eva Marshal, married William de Braose, Lord of Abergavenny
  17. # Isabella de Braose, married Prince Dafydd ap Llywelyn. She died childless.
  18. # Maud de Braose, in 1247, she married Roger Mortimer, 1st Baron Mortimer and they had descendants.
  19. # Eva de Braose, married Sir William de Cantelou and had descendants.
  20. # Eleanor de Braose. On an unknown date after August 1241, she married Sir Humphrey de Bohun and had descendants.
  21. Anselm Marshal, 6th Earl of Pembroke, married Maud de Bohun, daughter of Humphrey de Bohun, 2nd Earl of Hereford. They had no children.
  22. Joan Marshal, married Warin de Munchensi, Lord of Swanscombe
  23. #Joan de Munchensi married William of Valence, the fourth son of King John's widow, Isabella of Angoulême, and her second husband, Hugh X of Lusignan, Count of La Marche. Valence was half-brother to Henry III and Edward I's uncle.
During Ireland's civil wars, William took two manors that the Bishop of Ferns claimed but could not get back. Some years after William's death, that bishop is said to have laid a curse on the family that William's sons would have no children and that William's estates would be scattered. Each of William's sons did become earl of Pembroke and marshal of England, and each died without legitimate issue. William's vast holdings were then divided among the husbands of his five daughters. The title of "Marshal" went to the husband of the oldest daughter, Hugh Bigod, 3rd Earl of Norfolk, and later passed to the Mowbray dukes of Norfolk and then to the Howard dukes of Norfolk, becoming "Earl Marshal" along the way. The title of "Earl of Pembroke" passed to William of Valence, the husband of Joan Marshal's daughter, Joan de Munchensi; he became the first of the de Valence line of earls of Pembroke.
Through his daughter Isabel, William is an ancestor to both the Bruce and Stewart kings of Scots. Through his granddaughter Maud de Braose, William is an ancestor to the last Plantagenet kings, Edward IV through to Richard III, and all English monarchs from Henry VIII and afterward.