Vitakkasaṇṭhāna Sutta


The Vitakkasanthana Sutta is the 20th discourse in Majjhima Nikaya of Pāli Canon in Theravada Buddhism.
In the Theravadin Tipitaka, the ' is the twentieth discourse in the Majjhima Nikaya and is thus often designated by "MN 20"; in the Pali Text Society edition of the Canon, this text begins on the 118th page of the first volume of its three-volume Majjhima Nikaya, and is thus alternately represented as "M i 118'''".

Title and content

English translations have employed several different titles for the, including
The Removal of Distracting Thoughts,
The Discursively Thinking Mind, and
The Relaxation of Thoughts.
The describes five approaches for overcoming negative thoughts. Translators into English have used different terms to designate the purpose, nature, and components of these approaches. One translation begins by stating that
Other translators or commentators refer to five "things," "signs," or "strategies". The purpose of these five approaches is variously described as attaining "higher consciousness," "higher mind," "developing the mind", "heightened mind", or "freedom". To implement these approaches, one is enjoined to "reflect on", "give attention to", "attend to", or "employ" each approach.
In describing the first of the five approaches, the sutta uses the analogy of a carpenter's peg. In the language of one translation, when the mind has become filled with hatred or illusion by dwelling on a bad object, the aspirant should replace the bad thought with a good thought :
If thoughts still arise that are "negative" or "evil" and "unskilled", "unwholesome", or "demeritorious," the second recommended approach is as follows: The aspirant should "reflect on the consequences", "ponder on the disadvantages" "examine the danger", or "scrutinize the drawbacks" of such thoughts.
If negative thoughts still continue to arise, the third approach is "withdrawing attention" — that is, the aspirant should "not attend", "not give attention", "be without attention and reflection", "pay no mind and pay no attention", or even "forget" such thoughts.
If the third approach fails to eliminate negative thoughts, the fourth approach involves going "to the root" by "stilling the thought-formation", "removal of the source of those unskillful thoughts", "appeasing the whole intentional thought process", or engaging in "the relaxing of thought-fabrication". The sutta compares this to stages of removing the source of physical movement:
The fifth approach, to be pursued when the fourth and all previous approaches together fail to eliminate negative thoughts, is to clench the teeth and "subdue and beat down the mind by the mind", just as one man may do physical violence to another man.

Commentaries and translations

A commentary on the Vitakkasanthana Sutta was provided in Part III of Conquest of Mind by Eknath Easwaran.
Martine Batchelor characterized the Vitakkasanthana Sutta as a discourse "which seems to illustrate an early Buddhist cognitive behavioural strategy." She provided paragraph-length commentaries on each of the 5 methods listed in the sutta, and wrote that "In the Korean Zen tradition, the Vitakkasanthana Sutta is neither taught nor even mentioned. When I first heard a vipassana teacher explain this sutta, I was particularly struck because it was an exact description of what I had found myself doing after practising Zen meditation for 10 years."
Several English translations have been done of the, including:
  • "The Removal of Distracting Thoughts",
  • "The Removal of Distracting Thoughts"
  • "The Discursively Thinking Mind"
  • "The Relaxation of Thoughts"