In 2007, he attended the Redskins mini-camp and later signed as an undrafted free agent by the Atlanta Falcons. In 2008 Lindsey was signed by the Seattle Seahawks and was outstanding in the pre-season. He had nine perfect snaps including the game-winning field goalin overtime against the Bears in Week 2 and played two pre-season games. In 2010, Lindsey was signed by the UFL Hartford Colonials and participated in the team's early mini-camp. He was later released in favor of Jared Retkofsky, who had snapped the previous year for the franchise. Retkofsky had just been released by the Pittsburgh Steelers with whom he played nine games in the 2009 NFL season.
Awards
In 2006, he received the Coaches Contribution Award. That year, he was also the winner of the Tom Nickolich Memorial Award for outstanding achievement by a walk-on in the Mountaineer football program. In 2007, he received the Ira E. Rodgers Award presented to the player who has shown high leadership and academic qualities as well as football performance.