The band described the album as "doing something different with most bands", as far as band collaboration was concerned. The described themselves as minimally stressed while putting together the album.
Things Will Matter has received critical acclaim. According to Metacritic, the album has an average score of 81, based on five reviews. The consensus of critics was that the album contained epicthemes, and powerful instrumentation. David McLaughlin of Rock Sound gave the album four out of five stars commenting that Lonely the Brave "pulled another rabbit from the hat." In a positive review, the Kerrang! staff described the album "continues to make bold strides into the unknown." The staff also gave the album four stars out of five.