Awarding the EP three and a half stars from New ReleaseToday, Kaitlyn Gosnell states, "The Color EP fuses heartfelt and vulnerable lyrics with unforgettable musical soundscapes to create a wonderful worship experience that showcases CCM at its finest." Jonathan Andre, giving the EP four and a half stars at 365 Days of Inspiring Media, writes, "Heartfelt and emotional, comforting and enjoyable; this is a must-have for anyone who loves pop/worship music, and anyone who loves anything different and unique as compared to songs overplayed on the radio recently."