The orange, hygrophanous cap of Thaxterogaster causticus is about 1.5-4.5 centimeters in diameter. It starts out conical and usually becomes umbonate in age. The gills start out creamy or white-colored, before becoming brown as the mushroom getsolder. They are adnexed and often notched. The stipe is about 3.5-7 centimeters long and 3-6 centimeters wide. It is white and bruises yellow. The spore print is rusty brown. Both the cap and stipe of this mushroom are slimy. There are several similar species, including T. vibratilis, which is found in Europe.