Sutton began as a New York actor, but his role in Signs gained him attention, and led to further roles, including guest appearances in 24, Law & Order: SVU, Cold Case, JAG, Charmed, 10-8. He was scheduled to play an Andorian general in theStar Trek: Enterprise episode "Proving Ground" but was replaced by Granville Van Dusen. Sutton played a department store regional manager who took a big cash bribe on The Young and the Restless. Sutton says that role was the most fun he has ever had. He is noted for his distinctive speaking voice. He played a doctor in Clint Eastwood's Million Dollar Baby.