Tabyin Kadhib al-Muftari
Tabyin Kadhib al-Muftari fima Nusiba ila al-Imam Abi al-Hasan al-Ash'ari is a polemic book with a powerful message against the detractors of Abu al-Hasan al-Ash'ari, written by the Shafi'i hadith master Ibn 'Asakir, who vindicated him from deviant views and claims falsely attributed to him.
The book was actually written in response to Abu 'Ali al-Ahwazi who wrote a book compiling criticisms and disparagements upon al-Ash'ari. For this reason, Ibn 'Asakir authored the book, to defend the honour and integrity of al-Ash'ari, and to establish and affirm that al-Ash'ari was in agreement with Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal after his conversion from the Mu'tazilite theology to the orthodox Sunni doctrine.
The author gives a list of some seventy Ash'ari scholars divided into five classes, starting with the biographical layer of al-Ash'ari himself.
The book has been in print since 1928 and has been the subject of several studies.
Content
Tabyin Kadhib al-Muftari is a biography of Imam Al-Ash'ari, relaying his ancestry, his conversion from Mu'tazilism and his subsequent "middle position" creed, i.e. Orthodox Sunni Islam. In it, Ibn Asakir lays out Ash'ari's "middle position" in 13 points, highlighting two opposing and extreme views in each and discussing the middle position Ash'ari took. For example, he writes:1. "The Hashwiyya, who liken Allah to creation, said: Allah can be subject to modality and dimension like anything that can be seen. The Mu'tazila, the Jahmiyya, and the Najjariyya said: Allah cannot be seen under any circumstance whatsoever. Al-Ash'ari took the middle road and said: He can be seen without indwelling and without acquiring limits nor being subject to modality."
2. "Likewise, The Najjariyya held that the Creator is in every place without localisation or direction. And the Hashwiyya and Mujassima held that God is localised on the Throne, and that Throne is a place for him, and that He is sitting on it. But al-Ash'ari followed a middle course between them and held that God was when no place was, and then He created the Throne and the without His needing a place, and He was just the same after creating place as He had been before He created it."
3. "The Mu'tazila said: He has a "hand" but His "hand" is His power and favor, while His face is his existence. The Hashwiyya said: His hand is a limb, and His face has a form. Al-Ash'ari took the middle road and said: His hand is an attribute and his face is an attribute, just like His hearing and His sight.
4. "The Mu'tazila said: descent is the descent of any given sign of His, or that of His angels, while istiwā means mastery. The Mushabbiha and Hashwiyya said: Descent is the descent of His person through movement and displacement, and istiwā is His sitting on the Throne and indwelling on top of it. Al-Ash'ari took the middle road and said: Descent is one of His attributes and istiwā is one of His attributes and an action which He did pertaining to the Throne, called istiwā."
5. "The Muʿtazila said: 'the Speech of Allah Most High is created, invented, and brought into being.' The Hashwiyya, who attribute a body to Allah the Exalted, said: 'The alphabetical characters, the materials on which they are written, the colors in which they are written, and all that is between the two covers is beginningless and pre-existent. Al-Ashʿari took a middle road between them and said: The Qur'an is the beginningless speech of Allah Most High unchanged, uncreated, not of recent origin in time, nor brought into being. As for the alphabetical characters, the materials, the colors, the voices, the elements that are subject to limitations, and all that is subject to modality in the world: all this is created, originated, and produced."
Reception
Al-Dhahabi said: "Whoever seeks to develop deep knowledge about al-Ash'ari must read Kitab Tabyin Kadhib al-Muftari by Hafiz Abu al-Qasim Ibn Asakir"The book was also highly recommended and praised by the Shafi'i scholar Taj al-Din al-Subki.