| Year | Host | Award | Recipient | Presented by |
| 2003 | John Ritter | Future Classic | American Dreams | Paula Abdul |
| 2003 | John Ritter | Groundbreaking Role | Diahann Carroll as Julia | Halle Berry |
| 2003 | John Ritter | Innovator | All in the Family | Kathy Bates |
| 2003 | John Ritter | Legend | The [Dick Van Dyke Show] | Matthew Perry and Ted Danson |
| 2003 | John Ritter | Pop Culture | Star Trek | Mira Sorvino |
| 2003 | John Ritter | Superest Superhero | Lee Majors as The Six Million Dollar Man | Maureen McCormick and Davy Jones |
| 2004 | Brad Garrett | Future Classic | Arrested Development | Liza Minnelli |
| 2004 | Brad Garrett | Groundbreaking Show | The [Mary Tyler Moore Show] | Ben Stiller and Eric McCormack |
| 2004 | Brad Garrett | Legend | The Andy Griffith Show | Billy Bob Thornton |
| 2004 | Brad Garrett | Fan-tastic Phenomenon | Farrah Fawcett | Arsenio Hall and Ed McMahon |
| 2004 | Brad Garrett | Pop Culture | Gilligan's Island | Rudy Boesch, Tina Wesson, Jenna Morasca, and Rob Cesternino |
| 2004 | Brad Garrett | Visionary | Chico and the Man | George Lopez |
| 2004 | Brad Garrett | Superest Superhero | Lynda Carter as Wonder Woman | Chad Everett and Jane Seymour |
| 2004 | Brad Garrett | Favorite "Big, Bad Momma" | Vicki Lawrence as Thelma Harper | - |
| 2005 | Cedric the Entertainer | Future Classic | Desperate Housewives | Teri Hatcher |
| 2005 | Cedric the Entertainer | Icon | The [Bob Newhart Show] | Ray Romano |
| 2005 | Cedric the Entertainer | Legend | The [Carol Burnett Show] | Garry Shandling |
| 2005 | Cedric the Entertainer | Little Screen/Big Screen Star | Sally Field | Eva Longoria |
| 2005 | Cedric the Entertainer | Pioneer | Aaron Spelling | Peggy Lipton, Michael Cole, Jaclyn Smith, Gavin MacLeod, Bernie Kopell, Joan Collins, Jason Priestley, Luke Perry, Tori Spelling, Jennie Garth, Stephen Collins and Catherine Hicks |
| 2005 | Cedric the Entertainer | Pop Culture | Soul Train | Little Richard, Smokey Robinson, Ashanti, Mýa and Stevie Wonder |
| 2005 | Cedric the Entertainer | Favorite Airborne Character | Tim Daly, Steven Weber | |
| 2005 | Cedric the Entertainer | 100th Birthday | Charles Lane | Haley Joel Osment |
| 2006 | Megan Mullally | Future Classic | Grey's Anatomy | Jeremy Piven |
| 2006 | Megan Mullally | 40th Anniversary | Batman | William Shatner |
| 2006 | Megan Mullally | Impact | Good Times | Quentin Tarantino |
| 2006 | Megan Mullally | Legend | Cheers | Mary Tyler Moore |
| 2006 | Megan Mullally | Little Screen/Big Screen Star | Hilary Swank | Robert [Downey Jr.] |
| 2006 | Megan Mullally | Pop Culture | Dallas | John Schneider and Tom Wopat |
| 2006 | Megan Mullally | Pioneer | Sid Caesar | Billy Crystal |
| 2006 | Megan Mullally | TV's Greatest Music Moment | Diana Ross Concert in Central Park | Megan Mullally |
| 2007 | Kelly Ripa | The Medallion Award | Taxi | Sharon Stone |
| 2007 | Kelly Ripa | The Legacy of Laughter | Lucille Ball | Kirstie Alley and Carol Burnett |
| 2007 | Kelly Ripa | The Entertainers | Hee Haw | k.d. lang, The Judds and Willie Nelson |
| 2007 | Kelly Ripa | Future Classic | Heroes | Leonard Nimoy and Luke Wilson |
| 2007 | Kelly Ripa | 30th Anniversary | Roots | Forest Whitaker and Morgan Freeman |
| 2007 | Kelly Ripa | Pop Culture | The Brady Bunch | Valerie Bertinelli, Mackenzie Phillips and James Lipton |
| 2007 | Kelly Ripa | TV's Greatest Music Moment | Sonny & Cher Sonny & Cher on Late Night with David Letterman | n/a |
| 2008 | Vanessa L. Williams | Future Classic | The Office | Ed Asner and William Shatner |
| 2008 | Vanessa L. Williams | Icon | Lionel Richie | Samuel L. Jackson |
| 2008 | Vanessa L. Williams | Innovator | Roseanne | Teri Hatcher |
| 2008 | Vanessa L. Williams | Legend | Garry Marshall | Dick Van Dyke, Jack Klugman, Cindy Williams, Penny Marshall and Henry Winkler |
| 2008 | Vanessa L. Williams | The Lucille Ball Legacy of Laughter | Mike Myers | Justin Timberlake |
| 2008 | Vanessa L. Williams | Pioneer | Jonathan Winters | Robin Williams |
| 2008 | Vanessa L. Williams | Pop Culture | The Golden Girls | Steve Carell |
| 2009 | Neil Patrick Harris | 30th Anniversary | Knots Landing | Reba McEntire |
| 2009 | Neil Patrick Harris | Entertainer | Earth, Wind & Fire | Angela Bassett |
| 2009 | Neil Patrick Harris | Fan Favorite | Home Improvement | Jamie Lee Curtis |
| 2009 | Neil Patrick Harris | Future Classic | Two and a Half Men | Teri Hatcher |
| 2009 | Neil Patrick Harris | Hero | Magnum P.I. | Matthew McConaughey |
| 2009 | Neil Patrick Harris | Icon | ER | Neil Patrick Harris |
| 2009 | Neil Patrick Harris | Impact | M*A*S*H | Martin Sheen |
| 2009 | Neil Patrick Harris | Innovator | Married... with Children | Dr. Phil |
| 2009 | Neil Patrick Harris | The Lucille Ball Legacy of Laughter | Julia Louis-Dreyfus | Amy Poehler |
| 2009 | Neil Patrick Harris | Legend | Don Rickles | Jimmy Kimmel |
| 2009 | Neil Patrick Harris | Pop Culture | Sid and Marty Krofft | Will Ferrell |
| 2010 | Tim Allen | 30th Anniversary | Bosom Buddies | Jay Leno |
| 2010 | Tim Allen | Fan Favorite | The Love Boat | Jane Leeves, Wendie Malick and Betty White |
| 2010 | Tim Allen | Future Classic | Glee | Paula Abdul |
| 2010 | Tim Allen | Icon | Blondie | Jane Lynch |
| 2010 | Tim Allen | Impact | Everybody Loves Raymond | Bob Newhart |
| 2010 | Tim Allen | Legend | Mel Brooks and Carl Reiner | Billy Crystal |
| 2010 | Tim Allen | Pop Culture | Charlie's Angels | Pamela Anderson |
| 2011 | Jane Lynch | Fan Favorite | Family Ties | Ben Stiller |
| 2011 | Jane Lynch | Icon | Hall & Oates | Paul Reiser |
| 2011 | Jane Lynch | Impact | The Cosby Show | Stevie Wonder |
| 2011 | Jane Lynch | Legend | Regis Philbin | Barbara Walters |
| 2011 | Jane Lynch | Pop Culture | The [Facts of Life (TV series)|The Facts of Life] | Valerie Bertinelli, Jane Leeves and Wendie Malick |
| 2011 | Jane Lynch | 35th Anniversary | Welcome Back, Kotter | Jane Lynch |
| 2011 | Jane Lynch | Tribute to Classic TV Housewives | | The Real Housewives of New York City |
| 2012 | Kelly Ripa | Fan Favorite | Laverne & Shirley | Katie Couric |
| 2012 | Kelly Ripa | Groundbreaking | In Living Color | Whoopi Goldberg |
| 2012 | Kelly Ripa | Icon | Aretha Franklin | John Legend |
| 2012 | Kelly Ripa | Impact | Murphy Brown | Kelly Ripa |
| 2012 | Kelly Ripa | Innovator | One Day at a Time | Fran Drescher |
| 2012 | Kelly Ripa | Pop Culture | Pee-wee's Playhouse | Mike Myers |
| 2015 | Terry Crews | Fan Favorite | Parenthood | Minka Kelly and Martin Sheen |
| 2015 | Terry Crews | Groundbreaking | Ally McBeal | Lauren Graham |
| 2015 | Terry Crews | Impact | The Wonder Years | Paula Abdul |
| 2015 | Terry Crews | Legend | Betty White | Valerie Bertinelli, Jane Leeves and Wendie Malick |
| 2015 | Terry Crews | Pop Culture | Donny Osmond and Marie Osmond | Sutton Foster and Nico Tortorella |
| 2015 | Terry Crews | 15th Anniversary | Freaks and Geeks | Carl Reiner |