Scissor-billed koa finch fossils have been found on Maui and Kauai. Based on its disjunct distribution, the species might have occurred on all of the main islands, although more fossils are needed for confirmation.
The koa finchesseem to have been driven to extinction by habitat destruction, and not by climatic variation nor mosquito-vectored diseases. Koa finches were likely driven out of lowland habitat before or shortly after the time of western contact in 1778. The two species from Maui might have survived in an uplandrefugium until the late 19th century, paralleling the fate of the two species from the island of Hawaii. However, the only verified records of the Maui species are from fossils at a lower elevation.