The game received reviews ranging from negative to positive. JustAdventure thought the game was a "slight improvement" over The Elk Moon Murder, while noting " is not entirely easy to classify - somewhere between an interactive movie and an adventure game". In a 2001 retrospective, Programmer in Black wrote, "For an older game, the game play here holds up well." Just Adventure said "There is one thing that absolutely, positively isn't: unique". Allgame gave Sacred Ground 2.5 stars out of 5. Tekno Magazine noted the annoyance of switching between the game's two CDs when moving back and forth between different locations. PC Player felt the title was a missed opportunity to build on the world created in the predecessor. MacGamer thought the title was serviceable in the genre of interactive murder mysteries, but admitted it was not revolutionary in any way. Adrenaline Vault praised the immersive characters and the atmospheric music.