| Year | Cast
| Conductor,
Opera house and orchestra | Label |
| 1915–18 | Antonio Armentano Anticorona,
Fernando De Lucia,
Angela de Angelis,
Luis Muñoz,
Vida Ferluga | Salvatore Sassano
San Carlo orchestra and chorus, Naples | LP: Phonotype |
| 1916 | Cesare Formichi,
Giuseppe Taccani,
Ines Maria Ferraris,
Vincenzo Bettoni,
G Caiani | Lorenzo Molajoli
Teatro alla Scala orchestra and chorus | LP: Columbia Records
Cat: D 17732-17747 |
| 1917 | Giuseppe Danise,
Carlo Broccardi,
Ayres Borghi-Zerni,
Vincenzo Bettoni,
Nelda Garrone | Carlo Sabajno
Teatro alla Scala orchestra and chorus | LP: Bongiovanni
Cat: GB 1024 |
| 1927–28 | Luigi Piazza,
Tino Folgar,
Lina Pagliughi,
Salvatore Baccaloni,
Vera de Christoff | Carlo Sabajno
Teatro alla Scala orchestra and chorus | CD: Radiex
Cat: RXC1113-14 |
| 1927 | Riccardo Stracciari,
Dino Borgioli,
Mercedes Capsir,
Ernesto Dominici,
Anna Masetti-Bassi | Lorenzo Molajoli
Teatro alla Scala orchestra and chorus | LP: Columbia Records
Cat: GQX 10028-10042
CD: Aura Music
Cat: LRC 11099-2 |
| 1935 | Lawrence Tibbett,
Frederick Jagel /
Jan Kiepura,
Lily Pons,
Virgilio Lazzari,
Helen Olheim | Ettore Panizza
Metropolitan Opera orchestra and chorus | CD: Naxos Historical
Cat: 8.110020-1 |
| 1944 | Heinrich Schlusnus,
Helge Rosvaenge,
Erna Berger,
Josef Greindl,
Margarete Klose | Robert Heger,
Berlin State Opera orchestra and chorus
| LP: Heliodor
Cat: 2700 702
CD: Berlin Classics
Cat: 0033002 BC |
| 1945 | Jussi Björling,
Leonard Warren
Bidu Sayão,
Norman Cordon,
Martha Lipton | Cesare Sodero
Metropolitan Opera orchestra and chorus | CD: Naxos Historical
Cat: 8.110051-52 |
| 1950 | Leonard Warren,
Jan Peerce,
Erna Berger,
Italo Tajo,
Nan Merriman | Renato Cellini
RCA Victor Orchestra
Robert Shaw Chorale | LP: RCA Victrola
Cat: AVM2-0698
CD: RCA Red Seal
Cat: 88883729002 |
| 1950 | Josef Metternich,
Rudolf Schock,
Rita Streich,
Wilhelm Lang,
Margarete Klose | Ferenc Fricsay,
Deutsches Symphonie-Orchester Berlin,
RIAS Kammerchor | CD: Myto Records
Cat: 945111 |
| 1952 | Piero Campolonghi,
Giuseppe Di Stefano,
Maria Callas,
Alberto Herrera,
Gilberto Cerda | Umberto Mugnai,
Palacio de Bellas Artes orchestra and chorus | LP: Melodram
Cat: MEL 405
CD: Mondo Musica
Cat: MMO 91112 |
| 1954 | Giuseppe Taddei,
Ferruccio Tagliavini,
Lina Pagliughi,
Giulio Neri,
Irma Colasanti | Angelo Questa
RAI Orchestra Sinfonica and chorus | CD: Warner-Fonit
Cat: 8573 82647-2 |
| 1954 | Aldo Protti,
Mario Del Monaco,
Hilde Gueden,
Cesare Siepi,
Giulietta Simionato | Alberto Erede
Accademia di Santa Cecilia orchestra and chorus | CD: Decca
Cat: 440242 |
| 1955 | Tito Gobbi,
Giuseppe Di Stefano,
Maria Callas,
Nicola Zaccaria,
Adriana Lazzarini | Tullio Serafin,
Teatro alla Scala orchestra and chorus | CD: EMI Classics
Cat: 747469 |
| 1956 | Robert Merrill,
Jussi Björling,
Roberta Peters,
Giorgio Tozzi,
Anna Maria Rota | Jonel Perlea,
Teatro dell'Opera di Roma orchestra and chorus | LP: RCA Victrola
Cat: VIC-6041
CD: RCA Victor
Cat: 60172-2-RG |
| 1960 | Ettore Bastianini,
Alfredo Kraus,
Renata Scotto,
Ivo Vinco,
Fiorenza Cossotto | Gianandrea Gavazzeni,
Maggio Musicale Fiorentino orchestra and chorus | CD: >BMG Classics-Ricordi
Cat: 74321 68779 2 |
| 1961 | Cornell MacNeil,
Renato Cioni,
Joan Sutherland,
Cesare Siepi,
Stefania Malagu | Nino Sanzogno,
Accademia di Santa Cecilia orchestra and chorus | CD: Decca
Cat: 443 853-2 |
| 1961 | Cornell MacNeil,
Gianni Raimondi,
Leyla Gencer,
Jorge Algorta,
Carmen Burello | Argeo Quadri,
Buenos Aires Philharmonic and Chorus | CD: Myto Records
Cat: 3225 |
| 1963 | Robert Merrill,
Alfredo Kraus,
Anna Moffo,
Ezio Flagello,
Rosalind Elias | Georg Solti,
RCA Italiana Orchestra and chorus | LP: RCA Red Seal
Cat: LSC-7027
CD: RCA Red Seal
Cat: 88875073425 |
| 1963 | Nicolae Herlea,
Ion Buzea,
Magda Ianculescu,
Nicolae Rafael,
Dorothea Palade | Jean Bobescu,
Romanian Opera Bucharest orchestra and chorus | CD: VOXBOX
Cat: CDX5162 |
| 1964 | Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau,
Carlo Bergonzi,
Renata Scotto,
Ivo Vinco,
Fiorenza Cossotto | Rafael Kubelík,
Teatro alla Scala orchestra and chorus | CD: Deutsche Grammophon
Cat: 477 5608 |
| 1967 | Cornell MacNeil,
Nicolai Gedda,
Reri Grist,
Agostino Ferrin,
Anna di Stasio | Francesco Molinari-Pradelli,
Teatro dell'Opera di Roma orchestra and chorus | CD: EMI Classics
Cat: 3932822 |
| 1971 | Sherrill Milnes,
Luciano Pavarotti,
Joan Sutherland,
Martti Talvela,
Huguette Tourangeau | Richard Bonynge,
London Symphony Orchestra
Ambrosian Opera Chorus | CD: Decca
Cat: 414-269-2 |
| 1977 | Rolando Panerai,
Franco Bonisolli,
Margherita Rinaldi,
Bengt Rundgren,
Viorica Cortez | Francesco Molinari-Pradelli,
Staatskapelle Dresden
State Opera Dresden Chorus | CD: Arts Music
Cat: 43073;
DVD: Encore
Cat: 2022 |
| 1977 | Cornell MacNeil,
Plácido Domingo,
Ileana Cotrubaș,
Justino Díaz,
Isola Jones | James Levine,
Metropolitan Opera orchestra and chorus
| DVD: Deutsche Grammophon
Cat: 00440 073 0930;
Met Opera on Demand |
| 1978 | Sherrill Milnes,
Alfredo Kraus,
Beverly Sills,
Samuel Ramey,
Mignon Dunn | Julius Rudel,
Philharmonia Orchestra
Ambrosian Chorus | CD: EMI Classics
Cat: CMS 5 66037-2 |
| 1979 | Piero Cappuccilli,
Plácido Domingo,
Ileana Cotrubaș,
Nicolai Ghiaurov,
Elena Obraztsova | Carlo Maria Giulini,
Vienna Philharmonic
Vienna State Opera Chorus | CD: Deutsche Grammophon
Cat: 457 753-2 |
| 1981 | Louis Quilico,
Luciano Pavarotti,
Christiane Eda-Pierre,
Ara Berberian,
Isola Jones | James Levine,
Metropolitan Opera
| Streaming SD video
Met Opera on Demand |
| 1982 | Ingvar Wixell,
Luciano Pavarotti,
Edita Gruberová,
Ferruccio Furlanetto,
Victoria Vergara | Riccardo Chailly,
Vienna Philharmonic
Vienna State Opera Chorus
| DVD: Deutsche Grammophon
Cat: 00440 073 4166 7
DVD: Decca
Cat: 071401 |
| 1984 | Renato Bruson,
Neil Shicoff,
Edita Gruberová,
Robert Lloyd,
Brigitte Fassbaender | Giuseppe Sinopoli,
Accademia di Santa Cecilia orchestra and chorus | CD: Decca
Cat: 470 437-2 |
| 1985 | Bernd Weikl,
Giacomo Aragall,
Lucia Popp,
Jan-Hendrik Rootering,
Klara Takacs | Lamberto Gardelli,
Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra and chorus | CD: Eurodisc
Cat: 610 115
BMG-RCA
Cat: 74321 25286-2 |
| 1988 | Giorgio Zancanaro,
Vincenzo La Scola,
Daniela Dessì,
Paata Burchuladze,
Martha Senn | Riccardo Muti,
Teatro alla Scala orchestra and chorus | CD: EMI Classics
Cat: 7 49605-2 |
| 1989 | Leo Nucci,
Luciano Pavarotti,
June Anderson,
Nicolai Ghiaurov,
Shirley Verrett | Riccardo Chailly,
Teatro Comunale di Bologna orchestra and chorus | CD: Decca
Cat: 425 864-2 |
| 1993 | Vladimir Chernov,
Luciano Pavarotti,
Cheryl Studer,
Roberto Scandiuzzi,
Denyce Graves | James Levine,
Metropolitan Opera orchestra and chorus | CD: Deutsche Grammophon
Cat: 447 064-2 |
| 1994 | Renato Bruson,
Roberto Alagna,
Andrea Rost,
Silvestro Sammaritano,
Mariana Pentcheva | Riccardo Muti,
Teatro alla Scala orchestra and chorus | CD: Sony Classical
Cat: S2K 66314 |
| 1999 | John Rawnsley,
Arthur Davies,
Helen Field,
John Tomlinson,
Jean Rigby | Mark Elder,
English National Opera orchestra and chorus | CD: Chandos
Cat: CHAN 3030 |
| 2001 | Leo Nucci,
Aquiles Machado,
Inva Mula,
Mario Luperi,
Milena Josipovic | Marcello Viotti,
Arena di Verona orchestra and chorus
| DVD: Arthaus Musik
Cat: 107096 |
| 2002 | Paolo Gavanelli,
Marcelo Álvarez,
Christine Schäfer,
Eric Halfvarson,
Graciela Araya | Edward Downes,
Royal Opera House orchestra and chorus
| DVD: Opus Arte
Cat: OA0829D |
| 2004 | Carlos Álvarez,
Marcelo Álvarez,
Inva Mula,
Julian Konstantinov,
Nino Surguladze | Jesús López Cobos,
Liceu orchestra and chorus
| DVD: Arthaus Musik
Cat: 107147 |
| 2006 | Leo Nucci,
Piotr Beczała,
Elena Moșuc,
László Polgár,
Katharina Peetz | Nello Santi,
Zurich Opera orchestra and chorus
| DVD: Arthaus Musik
Cat: 108057 |
| 2008 | Leo Nucci,
Francesco Demuro,
Nino Machaidze,
Marco Spotti,
Stefanie Irányi | Massimo Zanetti,
Teatro Regio di Parma orchestra and chorus
| DVD: C Major
Cat: 723208 |
| 2013 | Željko Lučić,
Piotr Beczała,
Diana Damrau,
Stefan Kocán,
Oksana Volkova | Michele Mariotti,
Metropolitan Opera
| Streaming HD video
Met Opera on Demand |
| 2015 | George Petean,
Saimir Pirgu,
Aleksandra Kurzak,
Andrea Mastroni,
Judith Schmid | Fabio Luisi,
Orchestra and chorus of the Oper Zürich,
Tatjana Gürbaca, stage director | DVD: Accentus MusicCat:PHR0203 |
| 2017 | Dmitri Hvorostovsky,
Francesco Demuro,
Nadine Sierra,
Andrea Mastroni,
Oksana Volkova | Constantine Orbelian,
Kaunas Symphony Orchestra, Kaunas State Choir | DVD:Delos
Cat:DE3522 |
| 2019 | Vladimir Stoyanov,
Stephen Costello,
Mélissa Petit,
Miklós Sebestyén,
Katrin Wundsam | Enrique Mazzola,
Wiener Symphoniker,
| DVD:C Major
Cat: 751704 |
| 2022 | Quinn Kelsey,
Piotr Beczała,
Rosa Feola,
Andrea Mastroni,
Varduhi Abrahamyan | Daniele Rustioni,
Metropolitan Opera
| Streaming HD video
Met Opera on Demand |