NASA categories of evidence


NASA Categories of Evidence comprise a matrix or scale denoting the sources of evidence provided in the Human Research Program's various evidence reports, and thus potentially their probative value and efficacy. Authors in the Program were urged to label their evidence according to whether it was based on controlled experiments, observation, or expert opinion.
Broad "Experimental" Design TypeSilagy & Haines Levels of EvidenceNasa Categories of Evidence
ControlledIa - Meta-analysis of randomized trialsI - At least one randomized, controlled trial
ControlledIb - At least one randomized trialI - At least one randomized, controlled trial
ControlledIIa - At least one controlled study without randomizationII - At least one controlled study without randomization, including cohort, case-control, or subject operating as own control.
ControlledIIb - At least one other quasi-experimental studyII - At least one controlled study without randomization, including cohort, case-control, or subject operating as own control.
ObservationalIII - Non-experimental descriptive studies, e.g. comparative correlation or case studies.III - Non-experimental observations or comparative, correlation, and case or case-series studies.
OpinionIV - Expert committee reports or opinions or clinical experiences of respected authorities.IV - Expert committee reports or opinions of respected authorities based on clinical experiences, bench research, or "first principles".