Miss New Mexico's Outstanding Teen


For the state pageant affiliated with Miss Teen USA, see Miss New Mexico Teen USA
The Miss New Mexico's Teen competition is the pageant that selects the representative for the U.S. state of New Mexico in the Miss America's Teen pageant.
Tinaya St. ClassisBrown of Albuquerque was crowned Miss New Mexico's Teen on June 21, 2025, at the Flickinger Center for Performing Arts in Alamogordo, New Mexico. She competed for the title of Miss America's Teen 2026.

Results summary

The year in parentheses indicates year of Miss America's Outstanding Teen competition the award/placement was garnered.

Placements

Top 12: Natalie Benson

Awards

America's Choice: Natalie Benson Teens in Action Award Finalists: Natalie Benson

Winners

YearNameHometownAgeLocal TitleTalentPlacement at MAO TeenSpecial scholarships at MAO TeenNotes
2025Tinaya St. ClassisBrownAlbuquerque16Miss Bernalillo County's TeenVocal
2024Grace EvansHobbs18Miss Lea County's TeenLyrical Dance
2023Emily LehrAlamogordo18Miss Otero County's TeenJazz DancePreviously Miss New Mexico Teen USA 2021
2022Morgan BuhlerAlamogordoMiss Alamogordo's Outstanding TeenJazz Dance
2021Dallas CollinsAlamogordo18Miss Cloudcroft's Outstanding TeenVocal, "What About Us"
2019–20Brynn AyalaAlbuquerque15Miss Albuquerque's Outstanding TeenJazz Dance, "A Little Party Never Killed Nobody" by Fergie
2018Abrianna MoralesLas Cruces16Miss Las Cruces' Outstanding TeenVocal, "All That Matters"
2017Sienna MascarenasAlbuquerque16Miss Rio Grande's Outstanding TeenJazz Dance, "Breath of Life"Later Miss New Mexico 2021
Later Miss New Mexico Volunteer 2025
2016Madison BelcherTexico16Miss Portales' Outstanding TeenPiano, “Puttin’ on the Ritz”
2015Sasha ButcherAlbuquerque15Miss Las Vegas' Outstanding TeenVocal
2014Lindsey DayCarlsbad14Miss Enchanted Forest's Outstanding Teen
2013Jaden SmithRoswell14Miss Chavez County's Outstanding TeenTap Dance
2012Natalie BensonAlbuquerque15Miss Route 66's Outstanding TeenPianoTop 12America's Choice
Teens in Action Award Finalist
Later Distinguished Young Woman of New Mexico 2015
2011Nicolette YoungLas Cruces15Miss Las Cruces' Outstanding TeenLater Distinguished Young Woman of New Mexico 2014
2010Nadine SanchezLos Alamos16Piano, "Moonlight Sonata" by Ludwig van Beethoven
2009Ashley FresquezRio Rancho14BalletLater Miss New Mexico 2018
2008Alyssa Jean SifuentesSilver CityVocal/Guitar
2007Madison TabetAlbuquerque15DanceLater Miss New Mexico 2010
2006Ellen StriepekeSilver CityTap Dance
2005Sara Elizabeth RyanRoswell16Tap Dance