| Ed. | Year | Champion | Score | Runner-up | Venue | City | Tournament MVP |
| 1 | 1988 | Army | | La Salle | | | John Brence, Army |
| 2 | 1989 | Loyola Maryland | 3–0 | La Salle | | | Vince Moskunas, Loyola |
| 3 | 1990 | Loyola Maryland | 3–0 | La Salle | | | Doug Miller, Loyola |
| 4 | 1991 | Loyola Maryland | 2–0 | Fairfield | | | Tom Donahue, Loyola |
| 5 | 1992 | Loyola Maryland | 3–0 | Fairfield | | | Jim Garvey, Loyola |
| 6 | 1993 | Loyola Maryland | 1–0 | Fairfield | | | Anthony Novello, Fairfield |
| 7 | 1994 | Loyola Maryland | 4–0 | Manhattan | | | Doug Willey, Loyola |
| 8 | 1995 | Loyola Maryland | 6–1 | Iona | | | Mike Barger, Loyola |
| 9 | 1996 | Loyola Maryland | 2–0 | Fairfield | | | J. T. Dorsey, Loyola |
| 10 | 1997 | Rider | 2–0 | Loyola Maryland | | | Mark Bennett, Rider |
| 11 | 1998 | Rider | 1–0 | Fairfield | | | Craig Wicken, Rider |
| 12 | 1999 | Fairfield | 2–1 | Loyola Maryland | | | David Mancini, Fairfield |
| 13 | 2000 | Marist | 3–2 | Fairfield | | | Sean Murphy, Marist |
| 14 | 2001 | Loyola Maryland | 1–0 | Fairfield | | | Graham Marchant, Loyola |
| 15 | 2002 | Loyola Maryland | 2–1 | Marist | | | Steven Coleman, Loyola |
| 16 | 2003 | Saint Peter's | 2–1 | Loyola Maryland | | | Rinaldo Chambers, St. Peter's |
| 17 | 2004 | Marist | 2–0 | Rider | | | Keith Detelj, Marist |
| 18 | 2005 | Marist | 2–1 | Fairfield | | | Keith Detelj, Marist |
| 19 | 2006 | Fairfield | 1–0 | Saint Peter's | Lessing Field | Fairfield, CT | Alex Cunliffe, Fairfield |
| 20 | 2007 | Loyola Maryland | 1–0 | Saint Peter's | Wide World of Sports | Lake B. Vista, FL | Miloš Kočić, Loyola |
| 21 | 2008 | Fairfield | 1–0 | Loyola Maryland | Tenney Stadium | Poughkeepsie, NY | Christian Uy, Fairfield |
| 22 | 2009 | Loyola Maryland | 1–0 | Niagara | Lessing Field | Fairfield, CT | Tennant McVea, Loyola |
| 23 | 2010 | Saint Peter's | 2–1 | Iona | Geppi-Aikens Field | Baltimore, MD | Lebogang Pila, St. Peter's |
| 24 | 2011 | Fairfield | 3–1 | Manhattan | Sports Complex | Lake B. Vista, FL | Jack Burridge, Fairfield |
| 25 | 2012 | Niagara | 1–0 | Loyola Maryland | Leonidoff Field | Poughkeepsie, NY | Rene De Zorzi, Niagara |
| 26 | 2013 | Quinnipiac | 0–0 | Monmouth | Lessing Field | Fairfield, CT | Borja Angoitia, Quinnipiac |
| 27 | 2014 | Monmouth | 2–1 | Fairfield | Quinnipiac Field | Hamden, CT | Emmanuel Senyah, Monmouth |
| 28 | 2015 | Rider | 3–2 | Monmouth | Sports Complex | Lake B. Vista, FL | Elliot Otmani, Rider |
| 29 | 2016 | Rider | 3–1 | Quinnipiac | Quinnipiac Field | Hamden, CT | Ryan Baird, Rider |
| 30 | 2017 | Fairfield | 1–0 | Rider | Lessing Field | Fairfield, CT | Angus Hastings, Fairfield |
| 31 | 2018 | Rider | 1–0 | Quinnipiac | Quinnipiac Stadium | Hamden, CT | Elliott Otmani, Rider |
| 32 | 2019 | [2019 2019 Iona Gaels men's soccer team|Iona Gaels men's soccer team|Iona] | 3–2 | Saint Peter's | Jaroschak Field | Jersey City, NJ | Josh Plimpton, Iona |
| 33 | 2020 | Monmouth | 1–0 | Quinnipiac | Quinnipiac Stadium | Hamden, CT | Julian Gomez, Monmouth |
| 34 | 2021 | Marist | 2–2 | Rider | Tenney Stadium | Poughkeepsie, NY | Kyle Galloway, Marist |
| 35 | 2022 | Quinnipiac | 3–2 | Iona | Quinnipiac Stadium | Hamden, CT | Karl Netzell, Quinnipiac |
| 36 | 2023 | Rider | 2–1 | Iona | Mazzella Field | New Rochelle, NY | Momo Diop, Rider |
| 37 | 2024 | Iona | 1–0 | Rider | Mazzella Field | New Rochelle, NY | Sergio Gonzalez Fernandez, Iona |
| 38 | 2025 | Siena | 2–1 | Sacred Heart | Lessing Field | Fairfield, CT | |