List of judgements of the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council


This is a list of major cases decided by the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council. These include appeals from the following countries:

2001 onwards

2001-2008

Case nameCitationSubject
T Choithram International SA v PagaraniBritish Virgin Islands 2 All ER 492Vesting of "imperfect gifts"
Dextra Bank & Trust Company Limited v Bank of JamaicaJamaica 1 All ER 193, UKPC 50
Pratt Contractors Ltd v Transit New Zealand - New ZealandTendering law
Bernard v. Attorney General of Jamaica - Jamaica UKPC 47A vicarious liability case
Citco Banking Corporation NV v Pusser's Ltd - British Virgin Islands UKPC 13Validity of amendments to company's constitutional documents

2009

Case nameCitationSubject
Johannes Deuss v The Attorney General for Bermuda and The Commissioner of Police for Bermuda UKPC 38
GFN SA and Artag Meridian Limited v The Liquidators of Bancredit Cayman Limited UKPC 39
Peter Michel v The Queen UKPC 40
Francis Eiley and others v The Queen UKPC 41
Dave Burnett v The State of Trinidad & Tobago UKPC 42
Hearing on the Report of the Chief Justice of Gibraltar UKPC 43
Save Guana Cay Reef Association Limited v The Queen & Others UKPC 44
Pell Frischmann Engineering Limited v Bow Valley Iran Limited & Others UKPC 45
Texan Management Limited & Others v Pacific Electric Wire & Cable Company Limited UKPC 46
Kenneth McKinney Higgs, Senior v Leshel Maryas Investment Company Limited and Annamae Woodside UKPC 47
Lowell Lawrence v Financial Services Commission UKPC 48
The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago v Carmel Smith UKPC 49
Herman Ramdass v Marilyn Bahaw - Nanan UKPC 50
Nadine Rodriguez v Minister of Housing of the Government & Another UKPC 51
Nadine Rodriguez v Minister of Housing of the Government & Another UKPC 52
Josine Johnson and Yuclan Balwant v The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 52

2010

Case nameCitationSubject
Mossell Limited v The Office of Utilities Regulation, Cable and Wireless J A Limited and Centennial JA Limited UKPC 1
Cyril Archibold Capron v The Government of the Turks and Caicos Islands and the Crown UKPC 2
Theresa Henry & Marie Ann Mitchell v Calixtus Henry UKPC 3
Keith O'Connor v Paul Haufman Percival Piccott UKPC 4
Sherman McNicholls v Judicial and Legal Service Commission UKPC 5
Sherman McNicholls v Judicial and Legal Service Commission UKPC 6
The Prime Minister of Belize and The Attorney General of Belize v Alberto Vellos and Others UKPC 7
Patrick Thomas Tibbetts v The Attorney General of The Cayman Islands UKPC 8
Larry Winslow Marshall & Others v The Deputy Governor of Bermuda & Others UKPC 9
Mrs Fatma Bibi Mahmood Nahaboo and Others v N Parsooramen and Co and Others UKPC 10
Societe Royal Gardens et Compagnie and 138 others v The Mauritius Revenue Authority as represented by its Director General UKPC 11
Devendranath Hurnam v Kailashing Bholah and Soobashsing Bholah UKPC 12
Gangasing Aubeeluck v The State of Mauritius UKPC 13
Rosalind Ramroop v John Ishmael and Lall Heerasingh UKPC 14
Charmaine Bernard v Ramesh Seebalack UKPC 15
Marie Jean Nelson Mirbel & Others v The State of Mauritius & Others UKPC 16
Razcoomar Moodoosoodun v The State of Mauritius UKPC 17
Kirk Gordon v The Queen UKPC 18
Seeromani Maraj-Naraynsingh v The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago and The Director of Public Prosecutions UKPC 19
Andrew Ryan Ferrell v The Queen UKPC 20
Cosimo Borrelli As Liquidator of AKAI Holdings Limited and Others v Mr James Henry Ting and Others UKPC 21
Earlin White v The Queen UKPC 22
Romauld James v The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 23
Report of The Tribunal to The Governor of The Cayman Islands - Madam Justice Levers UKPC 24
Cable & Wireless Limited v Conrad Tonge et al, represented by The Antigua and Barbuda Workers' Union UKPC 25
Noel Campbell v The Queen UKPC 26
Leedon Limited v Mr Ghanshyam Hurry & Others UKPC 27
E Anthony Ross v Bank of Commerce Trust and Savings Association Limited UKPC 28
The Public Service Appeal Board v Omar Maraj UKPC 29
The Palms Resort Limited v P.P.C. Limited UKPC 30
The National Transport Authority v Mauritius Secondary Industry Limited UKPC 31
Francis Paponette and Others v The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 32
Culross Global Limited v Strategic Turnaround Master Partnership UKPC 33

2011

Case nameCitationSubject
Charles Villeneuve v Joel Gaillard UKPC 1, UKPC 6
Steven Kent Jervis KST Investments Limited v Victor John Skinner UKPC 2
Dennis Alma Robinson v The Queen UKPC 3
Bahamas Hotel Maintenance & Allied Workers Union v Bahamas Hotel Catering & Allied Workers Union ; West Bay Management Limited and The Attorney General of The Commonwealth of The Bahamas UKPC 4
Nigel Sookram v The Queen UKPC 5
Fellowes International Holdings Limited v Kyrgyz Mobil Tel Limited and Others, AK Investment CJSC v Kyrgyz Mobil Tel Limited and Others, Altimo Holdings and Investment Limited and Others v Kyrgyz Mobil Tel Limited and Others, CP-Credit Prive SA v Kyrgyz Mobil Tel Limited and Others UKPC 7
John Thompson & Janet Thompson v Goblin Hill Hotels Limited UKPC 8
Edwin M Hughes v La Baia Limited UKPC 9
Curtis Francis Warren and others v Her Majesty's Attorney General of the Bailiwick of Jersey UKPC 10
Peter Stewart v The Queen UKPC 11
Rohan Vidal and Kevin Thompson v The Queen UKPC 12
Spread Trustee Company Limited v Sarah Ann Hutcheson & Others UKPC 13
Nimrod Miguel v The Republic of Trinidad & Tobago UKPC 14
Tabeel Lewis v The State UKPC 15
Maxo Tido v The Queen UKPC 16
Tasarruf Mevduati Sigorta Fonu v Merrill Lynch Bank and Trust Company Limited and others UKPC 17
Rajendra Krishna v The State UKPC 18
The Emile Elias & Company Limited v The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 19
The Honourable Prime Minister, Mr Patrick Manning and others v Ganga Persad Kissoon, The Emile Elias & Company Limited v The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 20
Phillip Tillett v The Queen UKPC 21
Antonio Webster v The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 22
Rhett Allen Fuller v The Attorney General of Belize UKPC 23
Winston Gibson v Public Service Commission UKPC 24
Ranjan Rampersad v Commissioner of Police & Police Service Commission UKPC 25
Robert Ramsahai v Teaching Service Commission UKPC 26
Ashford Sankar & Ors v Public Service Commission, Hermia Tyson-Cuffie v Public Service Commission UKPC 27
Gopichand Ganga & Others v Commissioner of Police UKPC 28
Consolidated Contractors International Company SAL v Mr Munib Masri UKPC 29
The Legal Representative of Succession Paul de Maroussem v The Director-General, Mauritius Revenue Authority UKPC 30
Electra Daniel Administrator ad litem for the Estate of George Daniel v The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 31
Adamas Limited v Mrs Yong Ting Ping How Fok Cheung UKPC 32
Culross Global Limited v Strategic Turnaround Master Partnership UKPC 33
Ernest Lockhart v The Queen UKPC 34
The Belize Bank Limited v The Association of Concerned Belizeans and others UKPC 35
The Belize Bank Limited v The Attorney General of Belize and others UKPC 36
The Attorney General v Universal Projects Limited UKPC 37
The Attorney General v Keron Matthews UKPC 38
Omar Grieves and others v The Queen UKPC 39
Total Mauritius Limited v Mauritius Revenue Authority UKPC 40
Phillip McKenzie v The Queen UKPC 41
Total Mauritius Limited v Mauritius Revenue Authority UKPC 42
Saint Aubin Limitee v Alain Jean Francois Doger de Speville UKPC 43
Samuel Robie v The Queen UKPC 44
The Director of Public Prosecutions v A A Bholah UKPC 45
Dany Sylvie Marie Dhojaven Vencadsamy and 103 others v The Electoral Commissioner & Ors UKPC 46
Dennis Graham v Police Service Commission and the Attorney General of the Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 46
Sugar Investment Trust v Jyoti Jeetun UKPC 47
Joseph Lennox Holmes v Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons UKPC 48

2012

Case nameCitationSubject
David Gopaul on behalf of H V Holdings Limited v Vitra Imam Baksh on behalf of the Incorporated Trustees of the Presbyterian Church of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 1
Nigel Brown v The State UKPC 2
Ian Seepersad and Roodal Panchoo v The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 4
Dylan Simon v Manuel Paul Helmot UKPC 5
Deenish Benjamin and Deochan Ganga v The State UKPC 6
; Eloise Mulligan and Grace Wong v The Kingston & Saint Andrew Corporation UKPC 7
Sans Souci Limited v VRL Services Limited UKPC 8
Commissioner of Taxpayer Audit and Assessment v Cigarette Company of Jamaica Limited UKPC 9
The Superintendent of Her Majesty's Foxhill Prison & another v Viktor Kozeny UKPC 10
Terrell Neilly v The Queen UKPC 12
Margaret Toumany and another v Mardaynaiken Veerasamy UKPC 13
Lamusse Sek Sum & Co v Late Bai Rehmatbai Waqf UKPC 14
Marcus Jason Daniel v The State UKPC 15
Chandrawtee Ramsingh v The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 16
The Queen ex parte Mario Hoffmann v The Commissioner for the Turks and Caicos Islands Commission of Inquiry and The Governor of the Turks and Caicos Islands UKPC 17
Sakoor Patel and others v Anandsing Beenessreesing and Sicom Ltd UKPC 18
Dookee v The State of Mauritius and another UKPC 19
Li Chen Ling Kaw v Societe Piang Sang Pere et Fils and Mr Chong Fee Ng Wong UKPC 21
Dookee v The State of Mauritius and another UKPC 22
Rooplall Beerjeraz & others v Mrs Moonesh Amrita Dabee UKPC 23
Smegh Ltée v Dharmendra Persad UKPC 24
Donald Phipps v The Director of Public Prosecutions and the Attorney General of Jamaica UKPC 25
Kelly and others v Fraser UKPC 26
La Generale des Carrieres et des Mines v F G Hemisphere Associates LLC UKPC 27
Mark France and Rupert Vassell v The Queen UKPC 28
Harinath Ramoutar v Commissioner of Prisons and another UKPC 29
Richardson Anthony Arthur v The Attorney General of the Turks and Caicos Islands UKPC 30
The Presidential Insurance Company Limited v Resha St. Hill UKPC 32
The descendants of Utanga and Arerangi Tumu v The descendants of Iopu Tuma UKPC 33
June Margaret Baudinet v Ellen Tavioni and another UKPC 34
Ramone Drysdale v The Queen UKPC 35
Anneth Livingston v The Queen UKPC 36
Carlos Hamilton and Jason Lewis v The Queen UKPC 37, UKPC 31
Taitt v The State UKPC 38
Chief Justice of the Cayman Islands v The Governor UKPC 39
Anthony Armbrister and Cyril Armbrister v Marion E Lightbourn and others UKPC 40
Lesage v The Mauritius Commercial Bank Limited UKPC 41
Lancashire Insurance Company Limited v MS Frontier Reinsurance Ltd UKPC 42

2013

Case nameCitationSubject
Cukurova Finance International Ltd & another v Alfa Telecom Turkey Limited UKPC 2 and UKPC 20 - British Virgin IslandsNature of the remedy of appropriation introduced into English law under the EU
Oceania Heights Limited v Willard Clarke Enterprises Limited and Others UKPC 3
Ebbvale Limited v Andrew Lawrence Hosking UKPC 1
Hassen Eid En Rummun v The State of Mauritius UKPC 6
American Jewellery Company and others v Commercial Corporation Jamaica Limited and others UKPC 5
Director General, Mauritius Revenue Authority v Central Water Authority UKPC 4
Sherry v The Queen UKPC 7
Elgin Wright & Others v Buildings Heritage Limited UKPC 10
The Attorney General of the Turks and Caicos Islands and anotherv Richardson UKPC 8
Hendrick v Mutual Indemnity Limited and Others UKPC 13
Mutual Holdings Limited and others v Diane Hendricks and others UKPC 13
Thomas Townsend and Therese Townsend v Persistence Holdings Limited UKPC 12
New Falmouth Resorts Limited v International Hotels Jamaica Limited UKPC 11
Laing v The Queen UKPC 14
Terrence Calix v The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 15
Crawford Adjusters Limited and others v Sagicor General Insurance Limited and another UKPC 17
French v Public Prosecutor of the Central Department of Investigation and Prosecution in Lisbon Portugal UKPC 16
Prime Sight Limited v Edgar Charles Lavarello UKPC 22
Welch v The Attorney General UKPC 21
Cukurova Finance International Limited and another v Alfa Telecom Turkey Limited UKPC 20 & UKPC 25
The Appeal Commissioners v The Bank of Nova Scotia UKPC 19
Caribbean Steel Company Limited v Price Waterhouse UKPC 18
The Director General, Mauritius Revenue Authority v Paradis Brabant Hotel UKPC 24
Antigua Power Company Limited v The Attorney General of Antigua and Barbuda and others UKPC 23
Monica Jane Ramnarine v Chandra Bose Ramnarine UKPC 27
Ackerley v Her Majesty's Attorney General of the Isle of Man UKPC 26
Lundy v The Queen UKPC 28
Selassie v The Queen UKPC 29
Pearman v The Queen UKPC 29
General Construction Limited v Chue Wing & Co Ltd Ibrahim Cassam & Co Ltd UKPC 30
Bethel and Others v The Attorney General of the Commonwealth of Bahamas UKPC 31
Dominique Moss v The Queen UKPC 32

2014

Case nameCitationSubject
Piganiol v Smegh Ltée UKPC 1
Lawrence v The Queen UKPC 2
Daniel v The State UKPC 3
Holt v Her Majesty's Attorney General on behalf of the Queen UKPC 4
The Attorney General v HMB Holdings Limited UKPC 5
Real Time Systems Limited v Renraw Investments Limited and others UKPC 6
Ramdeen v The State UKPC 7
Commissioner of Police and Attorney General v Steadroy C O Benjamin UKPC 8
Quilvest Finance Limited and others v Fairfield Sentry Limited UKPC 9
UBS AG New York and Others v Fairfield Sentry Limited UKPC 9
Credit Suisse London Nominees Limited and another v Fairfield Sentry Limited UKPC 9
Lombard, Odier & CIE and others v Fairfield Sentry Limited UKPC 9
Fairfield Sentry Limited v Alfredo Migani and others UKPC 9
Den Danske A/S v Surinam Shipping Limited and others UKPC 10
Dhooharika v The Director of Public Prosecutions UKPC 11
Melvin Maycock Senior v The United States of America and another UKPC 12
Trevor Roberts and Devroy Moss v The Attorney General of the Commonwealth of the Bahamas and the Government of the United States of America UKPC 12
Sheldon Moore v The Commissioner of Police UKPC 12
Shanto Curry v The Commissioner of Police UKPC 12
Gordon Newbold v The Commissioner of Police UKPC 12
Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons v Samuel UKPC 13
Stoutt v The Queen UKPC 14
Cukurova Holdings A S v Sonera Holdings B V UKPC 15
Gayadeen and another v The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 16
Landmark Limited and another v American International Bank UKPC 17
Adele Shtern v Monica Cummings UKPC 18
Sabapathee v The Director of Public Prosecutions UKPC 19
Pfizer Limited v Medimpex Jamaica Limited and another UKPC 20
Beacon Insurance Company Limited v Maharaj Bookstore Limited UKPC 21
Yiacoub and another v The Queen UKPC 22
Bimini Blue Coalition Limited v The Prime Minister of The Bahamas and others UKPC 23
Dennis Dean and another v Arawak Homes Ltd UKPC 24
TLM Company Limited v Bedasie and another UKPC 25
Singh v The Public Service Commission UKPC 26
Beezadhur v The Independent Commission against Corruption and another UKPC 27
Jamaican Redevelopment Foundation Inc v Real Estate Board UKPC 28
Trevor Williamson v The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 29
Nelson and others v First Caribbean International Bank Limited UKPC 30
Alternative Power Solution Limited v Central Electricity Board and another UKPC 31
Lovell Romain v The Police Service Commission UKPC 32
Fortis TCI Limited v Islandcom Telecommunications Limited UKPC 33
Baldwin King and Hariette Richardson v Gershon Robertson UKPC 34
Price Waterhouse Coopers v Saad Investments Company Limited and another UKPC 35
Singularis Holdings Ltd v Price Waterhouse Coopers UKPC 36
Alhamrani and others v Alhamrani UKPC 37
Dixon v Kingdom of Spain UKPC 38
UC Rusal Alimina Jamaica Limited and others v Wynette Miller and others UKPC 39
Crociani and others v Crociani and others UKPC 40
Stichting Shell Pensioenfonds v Krys - British Virgin Islands UKPC 41Anti-suit injunctions relating to insolvency proceedings
Peerthum v The Independent Commission against Corruption and another UKPC 42
Mitchell v Georges UKPC 43

2015

Case nameCitationSubject
Assets Recovery Agency UKPC 1
Nilon Limited v Royal Westminster Investments S.A. - British Virgin Islands UKPC 2Rectification of the share register; anchor defendants; forum non conveniens
Alleyne and others v The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 3
The Presidential Insurance Company Ltd v Mohammed and others UKPC 4
Seetohul v Omni Projects Ltd UKPC 5
National Stadium Project Corporation v NH International Limited UKPC 6
Director of Public Prosecutions v Nelson UKPC 7
Gomes v The State UKPC 8
Pora v The Queen UKPC 9This case was the last one from New Zealand to be heard by the J.C.P.C..
Annissa Webster and others v The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 10
Central Bank of Ecuador and others v Conticorp SA and others UKPC 11
Fazal Ghany v Attorney General and Another UKPC 12
Credit Agricole Corporation and Investment Bank v Papadimitriou UKPC 13
Mauri Garments Trading and Marketing Limited v The Mauritius Commercial Bank Ltd UKPC 14
Rainbow Insurance Co Ltd v The Financial Services Commission and others UKPC 15
JMMB Merchant Bank Limited v The Real Estate Board UKPC 16
Gold Rock Corp Limited and another v Nylund Hylton UKPC 17
Duporte v The Queen UKPC 18
Eutetra Bromfield v Vincent Bromfield UKPC 19
Leymunlall Nandrame and others v Lomass Ramsaran UKPC 20
Brantley and others v Constituency Boundaries Commission and others UKPC 21
Elizabeth Ram v Motor and General Insurance Company Limited UKPC 22
Hall v Maritek Bahamas Ltd UKPC 23
Alcide v Desir and another UKPC 24
Saverettiar v Saverettiar UKPC 25
Republic Bank Limited v Lochan and another UKPC 26
Boufoy-Bastick v The University of the West Indies UKPC 27
Maharaj and another v Johnson and others UKPC 28
Peerless Limited v Gambling Regulatory Authority and others UKPC 29
Hickox and others v Brilla Capital Investment Master Fund SPC Limited and others UKPC 30
Misick and others v The Queen UKPC 31
Silver Point Condominium Apartments v Johann D Swart and others UKPC 32
Apollon Metaxides v Swart and others UKPC 32
Hunte and another v The State UKPC 33
Robinson v The State UKPC 34
The Federal Republic of Brazil and another v Durant International Corporation and another UKPC 35
ArcelorMittal Point Lisas Limited v Steel Workers Union of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 36
NH International Limited v National Insurance Property Development Company Limited UKPC 37
NH International Limited v National Insurance Property Development Company Limited UKPC 37
Mungalsingh v Juman UKPC 38
The Central Tenders Board and another v White UKPC 39
Brangman v The Queen UKPC 40
Cox v The Queen UKPC 40
Myers v The Queen UKPC 40
Pinard-Byrne v Lennox Linton UKPC 41
Milton and another v The Queen UKPC 42
The National Housing Trust v YP Seaton & Associates Company Limited UKPC 43
The Queen v Crawford UKPC 44
Total Mauritius Limited v Abdurrahman UKPC 45
Krys and others v KBC Partners LP and others UKPC 46
Insurance Company of the Bahamas Ltd v Eric Antonio UKPC 47
The Director General, Mauritius Revenue Authority v Chettiar and others UKPC 48

2016

Case nameCitationSubject
Anzen Limited and others v Hermes One Limited UKPC 1
Williams v The Bermuda Hospitals Board UKPC 4
Hallman Holding Ltd v Webster and another UKPC 3
Ameer Edoo v The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 2
Maritime Life Limited and others v The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 2
Steve Ferguson v The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 2
Vizcaya Partners Limited v Picard and another UKPC 5
Richard Brown v The Queen UKPC 6
Ruddock v The Queen UKPC 7
Advantage General Insurance Company Limited v The Commissioner of Taxpayer Appeals UKPC 8
Ennismore Fund Management Limited v Fenris Consulting Limited UKPC 9
Brown's Bay Resort Ltd v Pozzoni UKPC 10
Koo Seen Lin v Grewals Ltd UKPC 11
Grewals Ltd v Koo Seen Lin UKPC 11
Societe des Chasseurs de L'Ile Maurice and others v The State of Mauritius and another UKPC 13
Shophold Ltd v The Assessment Review Committee and another UKPC 12
Bade v The Queen UKPC 14This is the only case taken to the J.C.P.C. from the Solomon Islands since attaining independence in 1978.
Vendort Traders Inc v Evrostroy Grupp LLC UKPC 15
In the matter of the Baronetcy of Pringle of Stichill UKPC 16
The United Policyholders Group and others v The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 17
Wright v The Queen UKPC 18
Cassell and another v The Queen UKPC 19
Mascareignes Sterling Co Ltd v Chang Cheng Esquares Co Ltd UKPC 21
Bahamas Oil Refining Company International Limited v The Owners of the Cape Bari Tankschiffahrts GMBH & Co KG UKPC 20
The Superintendent of Prisons and another v Hamilton UKPC 23
Recreational Holdings 1 Ltd v Lazarus UKPC 22
Cenac and others v Schafer UKPC 25
Oliveira v The Attorney General UKPC 24
Janin Caribbean Construction Limited v Wilkinson and another and another UKPC 26
The Attorney General v Hall UKPC 28
Commissioner of Customs v Delta Petroleum Limited UKPC 27
Shavargo McPhee v The Queen UKPC 29
Madhewoo v The State of Mauritius and another UKPC 30
Tex Services Ltd v Shibani Knitting Co Ltd UKPC 31
Singularis Holdings Ltd v Price Waterhouse Coopers UKPC 33
PricewaterhouseCoopers v SAAD Investments Company Limited UKPC 33
PricewaterhouseCoopers v SAAD Investments Company Limited and another UKPC 33
Arorangi Timberland Limited and others v Minister of the Cook Islands National Superannuation Fund UKPC 32
Smith and others v Molyneaux UKPC 35
Arawak Homes Limited v The Attorney General and another UKPC 34
Scatliffe v Scatliffe UKPC 36
Barrow v Attorney General of Saint Lucia UKPC 38
Sam Maharaj v Prime Minister UKPC 37

2017

Case nameCitationSubject
McLeod v The Queen UKPC 1
Nazir Ali v Petroleum Company of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 2
Sandra Juman v The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago and another UKPC 3
Grove Park Development Ltd v The Mauritius Revenue Authority and another UKPC 4
The Attorney General v Samuel Knowles Jnr and another UKPC 5
Neil Hernandez v The State UKPC 6
Lester Pitman v The State UKPC 6
Akita Holdings Limited v The Honourable Attorney General of The Turks and Caicos Islands UKPC 7
Junkanoo Estate Ltd and others v UBS Bahamas Ltd UKPC 8
Archer and another v Fabian Investments Limited and others UKPC 9
Commodore Royal Bahamas Defence Force and others v Laramore UKPC 13
Attorney General v Dumas UKPC 12
Cono Cono and Co Ltd v Veerasamy and others UKPC 11
Sun Alliance Limited and another v Scandi Enterprises Limited UKPC 10
Scott v The Attorney General and another UKPC 15
Phillip v The Director of Public Prosecutions UKPC 14
Keramuth v The State of Mauritius UKPC 16
Sumodhee v The State of Mauritius UKPC 16
Sumodhee v The State of Mauritius UKPC 16
Marr v Collie UKPC 17
Lovelace v The Queen UKPC 18
Miller and another v Miller and another UKPC 21
Jamaica Public Service Company Ltd v The All Island Electricity Appeal Tribunal and others UKPC 20
Pearson v Primeo Fund UKPC 19
Mediterranean Shipping Company SA v Sotramon Limited UKPC 23
University of Technology, Jamaica v Industrial Disputes Tribunal and others UKPC 22
Rivnu Investment Limited and another v United Docks Limited and another UKPC 24
Sexius v The Attorney General of St Lucia UKPC 26
Lendore and others v The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 25
Chen v Ng UKPC 27
Fair Trading Commission v Digicel Jamaica Limited and another UKPC 28
Mohammed v Public Service Commission and others UKPC 31
Petroleum Company of Trinidad and Tobago Limited v Ryan and another UKPC 30
Meadows and others v The Attorney General and others UKPC 29
Hurnam v The Attorney General and others UKPC 33
Dave Persad v Anirudh Singh UKPC 32
Deslauriers and another v Guardian Asset Management Limited UKPC 34
Rolle Family and Company Limited v Rolle UKPC 35
DD Growth Premium 2X Fund v RMF Market Neutral Strategies Limited UKPC 36
Fishermen and Friends of the Sea v The Minister of Planning, Housing and the Environment UKPC 37
Cleare v The Attorney General and others UKPC 38
Hemery v Ramlogan UKPC 41
Paymaster Limited v Grace Kennedy Remittance Services Limited and another UKPC 40
Paymaster Limited and another v Grace Kennedy Remittance Services Limited UKPC 40
The Attorney General v River Dorée Holdings Limited UKPC 39
Staray Capital Limited and another v Cha, Yang UKPC 43
Alves v Attorney General of the Virgin Islands UKPC 42
O'Connor and others v The Proprietors, Strata Plan No. 51 UKPC 45
Whitlock and another v Moree UKPC 44

2018

Case nameCitationSubject
Beau Songe Development Limited v The United Basalt Products Limited and another UKPC 1
Julien and others v Evolving Tecknologies and Enterprise Development Company Limited UKPC 2
Almazeedi v Penner and another UKPC 3
A v R UKPC 4
Chandler v The State UKPC 5
Central Broadcasting Services Ltd and another v The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 6
Rawlinson and Hunter Trustees SA and another v Investec Trust Limited and another UKPC 7
Investec Trust Limited and another v Rawlinson and Hunter Trustees SA and another UKPC 7
Investec Trust Limited and others v Glenalla Properties Limited and others UKPC 7
Investec Trust Limited and others v Rawlinson and Hunter Trustees SA UKPC 7
Investec Trust Limited and another v Rawlinson and Hunter Trustees SA and another UKPC 7
Investec Trust Limited and others v Rawlinson and Hunter Trustees SA UKPC 7
Investec Trust Limited and others v Rawlinson and others UKPC 7
Investec Trust Limited and others v Glenalla Properties Limited and others UKPC 7
Ramsook v Crossley UKPC 9
Maharaj and another v Motor One Insurance Company Limited UKPC 8
Sagicor Bank Jamaica Limited v Taylor-Wright UKPC 12
Honourable Attorney General and another v Isaac UKPC 11
Guyah v Commissioner of Customs and another UKPC 10
De La Haye v Air Mauritius Ltd UKPC 14
Baptiste v Investment Managers Limited UKPC 13
Al Sadik v Investcorp Bank BSC and others UKPC 15
Jacpot Ltd v Gambling Regulatory Authority UKPC 16
Browne v Munokoa and another UKPC 18
Super Industrial Services Ltd and another v National Gas Company of Trinidad and Tobago Ltd UKPC 17
Singh v Rainbow Court Townhouses Ltd UKPC 19
Harding v Attorney General of Anguilla UKPC 22
Rangoonwala v Khan and others UKPC 21
Gany Holdings SA v Khan and others UKPC 21
Warren v The State UKPC 20
The Honourable Chief Justice of Trinidad and Tobago Mr Justice Ivor Archie O.R.T.T. v The Law Association of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 23
Fishermen and Friends of the Sea v Environmental Management Authority and others UKPC 24
University of Technology, Mauritius v Gopeechand UKPC 26
Bahamasair Holdings Limited v Messier Dowty Inc UKPC 25
Suppo v Jhundoo UKPC 29
Transpacific Export Services Ltd v The State and another UKPC 28
Bannerman Town, Millars and John Millars Eleuthera Association v Eleuthera Properties Ltd UKPC 27
Evans v The Queen UKPC 30
Davis v The Queen UKPC 30
Stubbs v The Queen UKPC 30
Boru Hatlari lle Petrol Taşima AŞ and others v Tepe Inşaat Sanayii AŞ UKPC 31
Long v Police Service Commission UKPC 32
Bissonauth v Sugar Insurance Fund Board UKPC 33

2019

Case nameCitationSubject
Nugent and another v Willers UKPC 1
Meyer v Baynes UKPC 3
Mexico Infrastructure Finance LLC v The Corporation of Hamilton UKPC 2
Cadet's Car Rentals and another v Pinder UKPC 4
Maharaj v National Energy Corporation of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 5
Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago v Maharaj UKPC 6
Seepersad v Ayers-Caesar and others UKPC 7
Director of Public Prosecutions v Jugnauth and another UKPC 8
Philomen Dean v Chanka Bhim UKPC 10
Causwell v The General Legal Council UKPC 9
Layne v Attorney General of Grenada UKPC 11
Maloo and others v Somar UKPC 13
Jamaicans for Justice v Police Service Commission and another UKPC 12
Galantis v Alexiou and another UKPC 15
Francis and another v Vista Del Mar Developments Ltd UKPC 14
Sahatoo v The Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 19
Singh v Public Service Commission UKPC 18
Gunesh v The National Transport Corporation and another UKPC 17
Byron v Eastern Caribbean Amalgamated Bank UKPC 16
Emmerson International Corporation v Renova Holding Ltd UKPC 24
Angteeah v Bathfield and others UKPC 23
The Port Authority of Trinidad and Tobago v Daban UKPC 22
Maharaj v Petroleum Company of Trinidad and Tobago Ltd UKPC 21
UBS AG New York and others v Fairfield Sentry Ltd and others UKPC 20
United Docks Ltd v De Spéville UKPC 28
The State of Mauritius and another v The CT Power Limited and others UKPC 27
The State of Mauritius and another v The CT Power Limited and others UKPC 27
Seukeran Singh v Commissioner of Police UKPC 26
Bermuda Bar Council v Walkers Limited UKPC 25
Volaw Trust and Corporate Services Ltd and its Directors and others v Her Majesty's Attorney General for Jersey UKPC 29
Volaw Trust and Corporate Services Ltd and its Directors and others v The Office of the Comptroller of Taxes and another UKPC 29
Ryan-Cox v Cox UKPC 32
Darroch v Her Majesty's Attorney General for the Isle of Man UKPC 31
East Asia Company Ltd v PT Satria Tirtatama Energindo UKPC 30
Schulze Allen v Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons UKPC 34
Bergan v Evans UKPC 33
Almarales and others v Director of Personnel Administration and another UKPC 35
Smart v Director of Personnel Administration and another UKPC 35
Simon and others v Lyder and another UKPC 38
AWH Fund Ltd v ZCM Asset Holding Company Ltd UKPC 37
Skandinaviska Enskilda Banken AB v Conway and another UKPC 36
Seebun v Domun and others UKPC 39
C v C UKPC 40
The Minister of Home Affairs and another v Barbosa UKPC 41
Mauritius Shipping Corporation Ltd v Employment Relations Tribunal and others UKPC 42
Canserve Ltd v The Republic of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 43
Nurse v Republic of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 43
Attorney General of Trinidad & Tobago v Ayers-Caesar UKPC 44
In the matter of Stanford International Bank Ltd UKPC 45
Mohammed v Gomez and others UKPC 46
Peepul Capital Fund II LLC and another v Vsoft Holdings LLC UKPC 47
De Zwarte Band and another v Kanhai and another UKPC 48

2020

Case nameCitationSubject
Attorney General of St Helena v AB and others UKPC 1
Saunders v The Queen UKPC 4
Pearson v Primeo Fund UKPC 3
Shanda Games Ltd v Maso Capital Investments Ltd and others UKPC 2
Shanda Games Ltd v Maso Capital Investments Ltd and others UKPC 2
Magner and another v Royal Bank of Scotland International Ltd UKPC 5
Elefterescu v The Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons UKPC 6
Ramadhar v Ramadhar and others UKPC 7
The Queen v Vasyli UKPC 8
Blackburn v LIAT Ltd UKPC 9
Bain v The Queen UKPC 10
Chief Fire Officer and another v Felix-Phillip and others UKPC 12
Commissioner of the Independent Commission of Investigations v Police Federation and others UKPC 11
Dave Lewin v Diah and others UKPC 11
The Minister of Energy and Energy Affairs v Maharaj and another UKPC 13
Lovering and another v Atkinson and others UKPC 14
Williams v The Supervisory Authority UKPC 15
Director of Public Prosecutions v Seeburrun UKPC 16
Director of Public Prosecutions v Lagesse UKPC 16
Lares v Lares and others UKPC 19
Attorney General of the Virgin Islands v Global Water Associates Ltd UKPC 18
Chief Personnel Officer v Amalgamated Worker's Union UKPC 17
Presidential Insurance Company Ltd v Twitz and another UKPC 20
Ciban Management Corporation v Citco (BVI) Ltd and another UKPC 21Duomatic principle
Chu v Lau UKPC 24
Delta Petroleum Ltd v British Virgin Islands Electricity Corporation UKPC 23
Webb v Webb UKPC 22
The Airport Authority v Western Air Ltd UKPC 29
Crick and another v Brown UKPC 32
Philip v Commissioner of Police and another UKPC 32
Livingston Properties Equities Inc and others v JSC MCC Eurochem and another UKPC 31Duomatic principle
Attorney General of the Turks and Caicos Islands v Misick and others UKPC 30
Ally Khan v Abdool UKPC 28
Ally Khan v Abdool UKPC 28
The Queen v Evans UKPC 27
Stubbs v The Queen UKPC 27
Davis v The Queen UKPC 27
Yearwood v Yearwood UKPC 26
National Stadium Project Corporation v NH International Ltd UKPC 25
Samsoondar v Capital Insurance Ltd UKPC 33

2021

Case nameCitationSubject
Ming Siu Hung and others v J F Ming Inc and another UKPC 1
Dass v Marchand and others UKPC 2
Friedland v Hickox - Judicial Committee of the Privy Council UKPC 3
Powell v Spence - Judicial Committee of the Privy Council UKPC 5
Byers and others v Ningning - Judicial Committee of the Privy Council UKPC 4
Betaudier v Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 7
Pickle Properties Ltd v Plant UKPC 6
Hinds and others v Director of Public Prosecutions UKPC 10
Silly Creek Estate and Marina Co Ltd v Attorney General Turks and Caicos Islands UKPC 9
RAV Bahamas Ltd and another v Therapy Beach Club Incorporated UKPC 8
FundHaven Limited and another v The Executive Director of the Securities Commission of the Bahamas UKPC 11
Brandt v Commissioner of Police and others UKPC 12
Commissioner of Prisons and another v Seepersad and another UKPC 13
Pleshakov v Sky Stream Corporation and others UKPC 15
Betamax Ltd v State Trading Corporation UKPC 14
Clarke and others v The State UKPC 16
Kerzner International Mauritius Holdings Ltd v Assessment Review Committee and another UKPC 18
Duncan and Jokhan v Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 17
Knowles and others v The Superintendent of Her Majesty's Fox Hill Prison and others UKPC 19
Royal Cayman Islands Police Association and others v Commissioner of the Royal Cayman Islands Police Service and another UKPC 21
Primeo Fund v Bank of Bermuda Ltd and another UKPC 22
Harvey and another v Brette and others UKPC 23
Gordon v Havener UKPC 26
Hurhangee v Ramsawhook and others UKPC 25
Convoy Collateral Ltd v Broad Idea UKPC 24
Convoy Collateral Ltd v Cho Kwai Chee UKPC 24
Maharaj and others v The State UKPC 27
Maharaj and others v The State UKPC 27
Hosein v Ramnarine-Hill UKPC 28
Sookhan v The Children's Authority of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 29
Charles B Lawrence & Associates v Intercommercial Bank Ltd UKPC 30
GibFibre Ltd v Gibraltar Regulatory Authority UKPC 31
Flashbird Ltd v Compagnie de Securite Privee et Industrielle SARL UKPC 32
Integrity Commission v Kikivarakis UKPC 33

2022

Case nameCitationSubject
Public Service Commission v Richards UKPC 1
Ciel Ltd and another v Central Water Authority UKPC 2
Momin v February Point Resort Estates Ltd UKPC 3
Framhein v Attorney General of the Cook Islands UKPC 4
Framhein v Attorney General of the Cook Islands UKPC 4
First Caribbean International Bank Ltd and another v Interested Creditors UKPC 7
Day and another v The Government of the Cayman Islands and another UKPC 6
Attorney General for Bermuda v Ferguson and others UKPC 5
Indra Williams v Casepak Company Ltd UKPC 9
Prickly Bay Waterside Limited v British American Insurance Company Limited UKPC 8
Lescene Edwards v The Queen UKPC 11
Nature Resorts Ltd v First Citizens Bank Ltd UKPC 10
Enal v Singh and others UKPC 13
Devon Hewey v The Queen UKPC 12
Gem Management Ltd v Firefox Ltd and others UKPC 17
Energizer Supermarket Ltd v Holiday Snacks Ltd UKPC 16
Dr Kongsheik Achong Low v Brian Lezama UKPC 15
Ma v Wong and others UKPC 14
Royal Bank of Scotland International Ltd v JP SPC 4 and another UKPC 18
Boodram v Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 20
Jay Chandler v The State UKPC 19
Gol Linhas Aereas S.A v MatlinPatterson Global Opportunities Partners II L.P. and others UKPC 21
St Nicholas Grammar School Ltd v Sylvie Arnulphy and another UKPC 23
La Brea Environs Protectors v The Petroleum Company of Trinidad and Tobago and another UKPC 22
SR Projects Ltd v Rampersad, the Liquidator of the Hindu Credit Union Co-Operative Society on behalf of the Hindu Credit Union Co-Operative Society Ltd UKPC 24
MacKenzie Frank and another v Attorney General of Antigua and Barbuda UKPC 25
Satyanand Maharaj v Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 26
Suraj and others v Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 26
Smith and another v Attorney General of Trinidad & Tobago and others UKPC 28
Ennismore Consulting Ltd v Fenris Consulting Ltd UKPC 27
Jesus Alexander Rodriguez Martinez and another v Chief Immigration Officer UKPC 29
Mohan Jogie v Angela Sealy UKPC 32
Michael Paul Chen-Young and others v Eagle Merchant Bank Jamaica Ltd and 3 others UKPC 30
Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago v Akili Charles No 2 UKPC 31
Estate of Dame Bernice Lake QC and another v Attorney General of Anguilla UKPC 33
Estate of Dame Bernice Lake QC v Attorney General of Anguilla UKPC 33
Glory Trading Holding Ltd v Global Skynet International Ltd and another UKPC 35
Emlyn Quashie v Ayana Solomon UKPC 34
ITG Ltd and others v Fort Trustees Ltd and another UKPC 36
Equity Trust Ltd v Halabi UKPC 36
The Central Bank of Trinidad and Tobago v Maritime Life Ltd UKPC 37
Roopchand v Tesheira UKPC 38
Gulf View Medical Centre Ltd v Tesheira UKPC 38
CMK BWI Ltd and 7 others v Attorney General of the Turks and Caicos Islands UKPC 40
A&A Mechanical Contractors and Company Ltd v Petroleum Company of Trinidad & Tobago UKPC 39
Flora Moses v Selwyn Moses UKPC 42
Sancus Financial Holdings Ltd and others v Holm and another UKPC 41
Dawn Satterswaite and 2 others v Bobbette Smalling UKPC 44
Jack Austin Warner v Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 43
Katic v Republic of Croatia UKPC 45
Philip Brelsford and 3 others v Providence Estate Ltd and another UKPC 46
Phyliss Rampersad and another v Deo Ramlal and 3 others UKPC 50
Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago v Akili Charles UKPC 49
Sagicor Bank Jamaica Ltd v YP Seaton UKPC 48
Grand View Private Trust Company and another v Wen-Young Wong and others ; UKPC 47
Grand View Private Trust Company and another v Wen-Young Wong and others ; UKPC 47
Kevin Stuart v Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 53
Kwok Kin Kwok v Yao Juan UKPC 52
Jean-Rony Jean Charles v The Honourable Carl Bethel and 3 others UKPC 51
Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago v JM UKPC 54
Water and Sewerage Authority of Trinidad and Tobago v Darwin Azad Sahadath and another UKPC 56
Robert Gormandy and 2 others v Trinidad and Tobago Housing Development Corporation UKPC 55
C-Care Ltd v Employment Relations Tribunal and 5 others UKPC 58
Dr Ramraj Deonarine and 4 others v Lauralee Ramcharan UKPC 57

2023

Case nameCitationSubject
Traille Caribbean Ltd v Cable & Wireless Jamaica Ltd UKPC 19
Carriacou Devcor Ltd v Margaret Corion and another UKPC 1
Responsible Development for Abaco Ltd v The Right Honourable Perry Christie and others UKPC 2
Lux Locations Ltd v Yida Zhang UKPC 3
Malik Cox v The King UKPC 4
Chandra Silochan and another v Rickie Cedeno UKPC 5
The Attorney General and another v The Jamaican Bar Association UKPC 6
The General Legal Council and another v The Jamaican Bar Association UKPC 6
HEB Enterprises Ltd and another v Bernice Richards UKPC 7
Justin Ramoon v Governor of the Cayman Islands and another UKPC 9
Dorsey McPhee v Colina Insurance Ltd UKPC 8
James Miller v The King UKPC 10
Charles Edward Porter and another v Robert Stokes UKPC 11
Douglas Ngumi v The Attorney General of The Bahamas and 3 others UKPC 12
Attorney General v Shannon Tyreck Rolle and 4 others UKPC 13
Tafari Morrison v The King UKPC 14
Rodriguez Jean Pierre v The King UKPC 15
Lea Lilly Perry and another v Lopag Trust Reg and another No 2 UKPC 16
Ravi Balgobin Maharaj v The Cabinet of the Republic of Trinidad and Tobago and another UKPC 17
Vinson Ariste v The King UKPC 18
Alphamix Ltd v The District Council of Riviere du Rempart UKPC 20
Robert Tantular v His Majesty's Attorney General UKPC 21
Tan Chi Fang and 3 others v His Majesty's Attorney General No 2 UKPC 21
Tan Chi Fang and 3 others v His Majesty's Attorney General UKPC 21
Ernest Hilaire v Allen Chastanet UKPC 22
The Permanent Secretary, Ministry of Social Development and Family Services and another v Ruth Peters UKPC 23
Blue Lagoon Beach Hotel & Co Ltd v Assessment Review Committee and another UKPC 24
Ray Morgan v The King UKPC 25
The Chairman of the Board of Inland Revenue v Finbar Boland and 15 others UKPC 27
Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago v Trinsalvage Enterprises Ltd UKPC 26
Caryn Moss v The King UKPC 28
Matadai Roopnarine v Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago UKPC 30
Winston Finzi v Jamaican Redevelopment Foundation Inc. and others UKPC 29
Sassy Garcia v Arima Door Centre Holding Company Ltd UKPC 31
Roger Watson v The King UKPC 32
FamilyMart China Holding Co Ltd v Ting Chuan Holding Corporation UKPC 33
Rollin Clifton Bertrand and 2 others v Anthony Elias UKPC 34
Stanford Asset Holdings Ltd and another v AfrAsia Bank Ltd UKPC 35
Attorney General of Trinidad and Tobago v Vijay Maharaj Substituted on behalf of the Estate of Satnarayan Maharaj for Satnarayan Maharaj and another UKPC 36
Surendra Dayal v Pravind Kumar Jugnauth and 7 others UKPC 37
Michel Lafresiere v New Mauritius Hotels Ltd UKPC 38
Renraw Investments Ltd and 2 others v Real Time Systems Ltd UKPC 39
Primeo Fund v Bank of Bermuda Ltd and another UKPC 40
Anthony Henry and another v Attorney General of St Lucia UKPC 41
Keith Arjoon and 2 others v Maria Daniel UKPC 42
Francis Chitolie and Another v Saint Lucia National Housing Corporation UKPC 43
Harold Chang v The Hospital Administrator and 2 others UKPC 44