Coenraets was hired as an assistant coach to Amy Rodriguez for National Women's Soccer League club Utah Royals on 7 June 2024. He was elevated to interim head coach following Rodriguez's dismissal on 30 June, when the Royals were bottom of the NWSL. Coenraets oversaw a winning record over the rest of the year as the Royals won their group at the 2024 NWSL x Liga MX Femenil Summer Cup and rose to 10th place out of 14 in the regular season. On 24 October 2024, he was promoted to head coach through the 2027 season.