| Year | Award | Nominated work | Result |
| 2002 | Contemporary Gospel Recorded Song of the Year | "There's a Liftin' of the Hands" | Nomitated |
| 2003 | Contemporary Gospel Album of the Year | Real | Nomitated |
| 2003 | Urban Recorded Song of the Year | "Get Up" | Nomitated |
| 2005 | Contemporary Gospel Song of the Year | "Again I Say Rejoice" | Won |
| 2005 | Contemporary Gospel Album of the Year | Live From Another Level | Won |
| 2005 | Male Vocalist of the Year | Live From Another Level | Nomitated |
| 2005 | Song of the Year | "Friend of God" | Nomitated |
| 2006 | Contemporary Gospel Song of the Year | "Not Forgotten" | Won |
| 2006 | Song of the Year | "Friend of God" | Nomitated |
| 2006 | Praise & Worship Album of the Year | Alive in South Africa | Nomitated |
| 2006 | Long Form Music Video of the Year | Live From Another Level | Nomitated |
| 2007 | Long Form Music Video of the Year | Alive in South Africa | Nomitated |
| 2007 | Contemporary Gospel Song of the Year | "Turn It Around" | Won |
| 2007 | Contemporary Gospel Album of the Year | It's Not Over | Won |
| 2007 | Choral Collection of the Year | Again I Say Rejoice: Celebrating The Songs Of Israel Houghton | Nomitated |
| 2007 | Contemporary Gospel Recorded Song of the Year | "Favor" | Nomitated |
| 2008 | Contemporary Gospel Album of the Year | A Deeper Level | Won |
| 2008 | Producer of the Year | A Deeper Level | Nomitated |
| 2008 | Contemporary Gospel Song of the Year | "Say So" | Won |
| 2009 | Contemporary Gospel Album of the Year | Change The World | Won |
| 2010 | Urban Song of the Year | "Just Wanna Say" | Won |
| 2010 | Contemporary Gospel Song of the Year | "The Power of One " | Won |
| 2010 | Contemporary Gospel Song of the Year | "Every Prayer" | Nomitated |
| 2011 | Contemporary Gospel Album of the Year | Love God, Love People | Won |
| 2011 | Male Vocalist of the Year | Love God, Love People | Nomitated |
| 2011 | Contemporary Gospel Song of the Year | "You Hold My World" | Nomitated |
| 2013 | Long Form Video of the Year | Jesus at the Center | Nomitated |
| 2013 | Spanish Language Album of the Year | Jesus En El Centro | Nomitated |
| 2013 | Gospel Performance of the Year | "It's Not Over " | Nomitated |
| 2013 | Traditional Gospel Recorded Song of the Year | "It's Not Over " | Nomitated |
| 2014 | Traditional Gospel Album of the Year | Duets | Won |
| 2014 | Contemporary Gospel/Urban Recorded Song of the Year | "Sunday Kind of Love" | Nomitated |
| 2015 | Traditional Gospel Recorded Song of the Year | "How Awesome Is Our God" | Won |
| 2015 | Gospel Artist of the Year | Himself | Nomitated |
| 2016 | Urban Worship Album of the Year | Covered: Alive in Asia | Nomitated |
| 2019 | Contemporary Gospel Album of the Yeaer | Road To DeMaskUs | Nomitated |
| 2022 | Contemporary Gospel Album of the Yeaer | Clarity | Won |
| 2025 | Gospel Worship Recorded Song of the Year | "One Hallelujah" | Nomitated |
| 2025 | Spanish Language Recorded Song of the Year | "Coritos de Fuego" | Won |
| 2025 | Traditional Gospel Album of the Year | "Then and Now " | Nomitated |
| Year | Award | Nominated work | Result |
| 2005 | CD of the Year | Live from Another Level | Won |
| 2005 | Male Vocalist of the Year | Live from Another Level | Won |
| 2005 | Artist of the Year | Live from Another Level | Nomitated |
| 2005 | Producer of the Year | Live from Another Level | Nomitated |
| 2006 | Music Video of the Year | Live from Another Level | Nomitated |
| 2007 | CD of the Year | ALIVE in South Africa | Nomitated |
| 2007 | Contemporary CD of the Year | ALIVE in South Africa | Nomitated |
| 2007 | Contemporary Male Vocalist of the Year | ALIVE in South Africa | Nomitated |
| 2007 | Male Vocalist of the Year | ALIVE in South Africa | Nomitated |
| 2007 | Urban/Inspirational Single / Performance of the Year | "Turn It Around" | Nomitated |
| 2009 | Contemporary CD of the Year | Live: A Deeper Level | Nomitated |
| 2009 | Contemporary Group/Duo of the Year | Live: A Deeper Level | Nomitated |
| 2009 | Group/Duo of the Year | Live: A Deeper Level | Nomitated |
| 2009 | Praise and Worship CD of the Year | Live: A Deeper Level | Nomitated |
| 2010 | Male Vocalist of the Year | The Power of One | Nomitated |
| 2010 | Praise and Worship CD of the Year | The Power of One | Nomitated |
| 2012 | Contemporary Male Vocalist of the Year | Love God. Love People | Nomitated |
| 2012 | Male Vocalist of the Year | Love God. Love People | Nomitated |
| 2012 | Praise and Worship CD of the Year | Love God. Love People | Nomitated |
| 2012 | Producer of the Year | Love God. Love People | Nomitated |
| 2014 | Contemporary Group/Duo of the Year | Jesus at the Center: Live | Nomitated |
| 2014 | Group/Duo of the Year | Jesus at the Center: Live | Nomitated |
| 2014 | Praise and Worship CD of the Year | Jesus at the Center: Live | Nomitated |
| 2016 | Contemporary Group/Duo of the Year | Covered: Alive in Asia | Nomitated |
| 2016 | Group/Duo of the Year | Covered: Alive in Asia | Nomitated |
| 2016 | Praise and Worship CD of the Year | Covered: Alive in Asia | Nomitated |
| 2016 | Special Event CD of the Year | Covered: Alive in Asia | Nomitated |
| 2018 | Urban/Inspirational Single or Performance of the Year | Reckless Love | Nomitated |
| 2018 | Recorded Music Packaging of the Year | Road to DeMaskUs | Nomitated |
| 2022 | Contemporary Duo/Group Chorus of the Year | Feels Like Home | Nomitated |
| 2022 | Contemporary Male Artist of the Year | Feels Like Home | Nomitated |
| 2022 | Duo/Group Chorus of the Year | Feels Like Home | Nomitated |
| 2022 | Male Artist of the Year | Feels Like Home | Nomitated |
| Year | Album details | Peak chart positions |
| 1997 | Whisper It Loud
| |
| 2001 | New SeasonReleased: July 31Label: IntegrityFormat: CD | |
| 2001 | Nueva Generación Released: AugustLabel: IntegrityFormat: CD | |
| 2002 | RealReleased: October 29Label: Integrity Format: CD | No. 33 on Top Christian Albums No. 13 on Top Gospel Albums |
| 2004 | Live From Another LevelReleased: May 4Label: Integrity Format: CD/DVD | No. 146 on Billboard 200 No. 5 on Top Christian Albums No. 1 on Top Gospel Albums No. 3 on Heatseekers Albums |
| 2005 | Alive in South AfricaReleased: October 25Label: Integrity Format: CD/DVD | No. 62 on Billboard 200 No. 3 on Top Christian Albums No. 2 on Top Gospel Albums |
| 2006 | A Timeless ChristmasReleased: September 26Label: Integrity Format: CD | No. 40 on Top Christian Albums No. 11 on Top Gospel Albums No. 32 on Top Holiday Albums |
| 2007 | A Deeper LevelReleased: September 4Label: Integrity Format: CD/DVD | No. 48 on Billboard 200 No. 3 on Top Christian Albums No. 1 on Top Gospel Albums |
| 2009 | The Power of OneReleased: March 24Label: Integrity/ColumbiaFormat: CD/Digital download | No. 34 on Billboard 200 No. 1 on Top Christian Albums No. 1 on Top Gospel Albums No. 19 on Digital Albums |
| 2010 | Love God, Love PeopleReleased: August 31Label: Integrity/ColumbiaFormat: CD/Digital download | No. 27 on Billboard 200 No. 1 on Top Christian Albums No. 1 on Top Gospel Albums No. 18 on Digital Albums |
| 2012 | Decade ''''Released: March 5Label: IntegrityFormat: CD/Digital download | No. 10 on Top Gospel Albums |
| 2012 | Jesus at the Center: LiveReleased: August 14Label: Integrity/ColumbiaFormat: CD/DVD | No. 32 on Billboard 200 No. 1 on Top Christian Albums No. 2 on Top Gospel Albums No. 16 on Digital Albums |
| 2013 | Jesús En El Centro: En Vivo Released: August 14Label: Integrity/ColumbiaFormat: CD/DVD | No. 23 on Top Latin Albums No. 11 on Latin Pop Albums No. 48 on Top Christian Albums No. 16 on Top Gospel Albums |
| 2014 | The Very Best of Israel & New Breed Released: January 19Label: IntegrityFormat: CD/Digital download | No. 34 on Top Gospel Albums |
| 2015 | Covered: Alive in AsiaReleased: July 24Label: RCA InspirationFormat: CD/Digital download | No. 48 on Billboard 200 No. 1 on Top Christian Albums No. 1 on Top Gospel Albums No. 11 on Digital Albums |
| 2018 | The Road To DeMaskUsReleased: September 28Label: Provident Label Group/RCAFormat: CD/Digital download | No. 15 on Top Christian Albums No. 2 on Top Gospel Albums |
| 2021 | Feels Like Home, Vol. 1 Released: February 26 Label: District 11 Entertainment Format: Digital download, vinyl | |
| 2021 | Feels Like Home, Vol. 2 Released: April 2 Label: District 11 Entertainment Format: Digital download, vinyl | |
| 2025 | Coritos, Vol. 1 Released: May 9 Label: District 11 Entertainment Format: Digital download, vinyl | |
| 2025 | Coritos, Vol. 2 Released: September 19 Label: District 11 Entertainment Format: Digital download, vinyl | |