Each CD in the set is named after one of the original group members, created by long-time Kiss fan Paul "DJ Flare" Hall and co-produced with Jeff Fura. In 1996, the 'Kiss-Icons' logos were created by AjaxGarcia, a famous Los Angeles-based artist. Garcia is known as a founding member of the 1990s punk group The Napoleon Blownaparts.
Gordon S. Miller writing for Blogcritics said: "There’s nothing new for members of the KISS Army and it’s a poor introduction to new listeners." AllMusic wrote: "True fans have all of this material and could arrange it any way they want, but Ikons saves them the trouble of generating their own member specific playlists, which in all likelihood, would only be slightly better."