Human Tissue Act 2004


The Human Tissue Act 2004 is an act of the Parliament of the United Kingdom, that applied to England, Northern Ireland and Wales, which consolidated previous legislation and created the Human Tissue Authority to "regulate the removal, storage, use and disposal of human bodies, organs and tissue." The Act does not extend to Scotland; its counterpart there is the Human Tissue Act 2006.

Background

The Act was brought about as a consequence of, among things, the Alder Hey organs scandal, in which organs of children had been retained by the Alder Hey Children's Hospital without consent, and the Kennedy inquiry into heart surgery on children at the Bristol Royal Infirmary. A consultative exercise followed the Government's Green Paper, Human Bodies, Human Choices, and earlier recommendations by the Chief Medical Officer, Sir Liam Donaldson.

The Act

The Act allows for anonymous organ donation, and requires licences for those intending to publicly display human remains, such as BODIES... The Exhibition. Recent calls have been made for the reform of this Act due growing concerns around the sale and trade of human remains.
The Act also specifies that in cases of organ donation after death the wishes of the deceased takes precedence over the wishes of relatives, but a parliamentary report concluded in 2006 that the Act likely would fail in this regard since most surgeons would be unwilling to confront families in such situations.
The Act prohibits selling organs. In 2007 a man became the first person convicted under the Act for trying to sell his kidney online for £24,000 in order to pay off his gambling debts.

Regulations

The following orders have been made under this section:
*
  • Application

There is no official report on the number of restitutions that have been permitted under the Human Tissue Act 2004. In the United Kingdom, museums are not required to disclose such information. The table below therefore establishes a non-exhaustive list of human remains that have been restituted following the implementation of the Human Tissue Act.
InstitutionApplicantObject of the requestOutcome of the requestDate and place of returnSource
British MuseumThe Tasmanian Aboriginal Centre and the Australian GovernmentTwo Cremation Ash BundlesApproved2006 – Tasmania Aboriginal Centre
British MuseumNew Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa
Seven preserved tattooed heads and nine human bone fragments
Partially Approved2008 – Te Papa Tongarewa, New Zealand
British MuseumThe Torres Strait Islander traditional owners with the support of the Australian GovernmentTwo modified skullsRejected-
World Museum of LiverpoolUnknownFive human remainsApproved2007 – Museum of New Zealand Te Papa Tongarewa
World Museum of LiverpoolAustralian Office of Indigenous Policy Coordination – Australian GovernmentA skullApproved2009 – Ngarrindjeri people in Australia
World Museum of LiverpoolUnknownA mummified babyApproved2010 – Meuram Tribe from the Torres Strait Islands
National History Museum of LondonUnknownTorres Strait Islander BonesApproved2007