| Year | Winner | Position | School | Born |
| 1981 | | Center | Minnesota | Roseau, Minnesota |
| 1982 | | Left wing | Bowling Green | Guelph, Ontario |
| 1983 | | Defense | Harvard | Burlington, Massachusetts |
| 1984 | | Defense | Minnesota–Duluth | Minneapolis, Minnesota |
| 1985 | | Right wing | Minnesota–Duluth | Pine Falls, Manitoba |
| 1986 | | Center | Harvard | Burlington, Massachusetts |
| 1987 | | Center | North Dakota | Thunder Bay, Ontario |
| 1988 | | Goaltender | Minnesota | Duluth, Minnesota |
| 1989 | | Left wing | Harvard | Tulsa, Oklahoma |
| 1990 | | Center | Michigan State | Lansing, Michigan |
| 1991 | | Center | Boston College | Cranston, Rhode Island |
| 1992 | | Left wing | Maine | Shediac, New Brunswick |
| 1993 | | Left wing | Maine | Vancouver, British Columbia |
| 1994 | | Left wing | Minnesota–Duluth | Grand Rapids, Minnesota |
| 1995 | | Center | Bowling Green | Parma, Ohio |
| 1996 | | Center | Minnesota | White Bear Lake, Minnesota |
| 1997 | | Center | Michigan | Pitt Meadows, British Columbia |
| 1998 | | Left wing | Boston University | Trumbull, Connecticut |
| 1999 | | Center | New Hampshire | Fernie, British Columbia |
| 2000 | | Defense | Boston College | Boston, Massachusetts |
| 2001 | | Goaltender | Michigan State | East Lansing, Michigan |
| 2002 | | Defense | Minnesota | Golden Valley, Minnesota |
| 2003 | | Left wing | Colorado College | Liptovský Mikuláš, Czechoslovakia |
| 2004 | | Right wing | Minnesota–Duluth | Saint-Joseph-de-Beauce, Quebec |
| 2005 | | Center | Colorado College | Roseville, Minnesota |
| 2006 | | Defense | Denver | Anchorage, Alaska |
| 2007 | | Left wing | North Dakota | Calgary, Alberta |
| 2008 | | Center | Michigan | Northville, Michigan |
| 2009 | | Defense | Boston University | North Bellmore, New York |
| 2010 | | Center | Wisconsin | Plantation, Florida |
| 2011 | | Left wing | Miami | Grosse Pointe Woods, Michigan |
| 2012 | | Center | Minnesota–Duluth | Duluth, Minnesota |
| 2013 | | Center | St. Cloud State | Duluth, Minnesota |
| 2014 | | Left wing | Boston College | Salem, New Jersey |
| 2015 | | Center | Boston University | North Chelmsford, Massachusetts |
| 2016 | | Left wing | Harvard | Boston, Massachusetts |
| 2017 | | Defense | Denver | Sun Prairie, Wisconsin |
| 2018 | | Center | Northeastern | Braintree, Massachusetts |
| 2019 | | Defense | Massachusetts | Calgary, Alberta |
| 2020 | | Defense | Minnesota–Duluth | Hibbing, Minnesota |
| 2021 | | Right wing | Wisconsin | Stevens Point, Wisconsin |
| 2022 | | Goaltender | Minnesota State | Downers Grove, Illinois |
| 2023 | | Center | Michigan | Nobleton, Ontario |
| 2024 | | Center | Boston University | North Vancouver, British Columbia |
| 2025 | | Left Wing | Michigan State | Hudson, Wisconsin |