In the 1909 Egg Bowl in which Ole Miss defeated Mississippi State9 to 5, Kinnebrew was called by the Jackson Clarion-Ledger "the particular star of his team."
1910
He was selected [College Football College Football All-Southern Team|All-Southern Team|All-Southern] in 1910. Kinnebrew played in a game on a team of All-Southern all stars against Harvard Law School. Former Sewanee player Silas Williams scored the only and deciding points for Harvard. "The Southerners showed unexpected strength in individual defensive work. Kinnebrew, the gianttackle, who made an all Southern eleven this season and who intends to enter Harvard Law School after finishing is course at the University of Mississippi, played against Captain Fish and held his own, according to the verdict of an enthusiastic crowd who flocked to the side lines in spite of inclement weather."