Cavefish


Cavefish or cave fish is a generic term for fresh and brackish water fish adapted to life in caves and other underground habitats. Related terms are subterranean fish, troglomorphic fish, troglobitic fish, stygobitic fish, phreatic fish, and hypogean fish.
There are more than 200 scientifically described species of obligate cavefish found on all continents, except Antarctica. Although widespread as a group, many species have very small ranges and are threatened.
Cavefish are members of a wide range of families and do not form a monophyletic group. Typical adaptations include reduced eyes and depigmentation.

Adaptations

Many aboveground fish may enter caves on occasion, but obligate cavefish are extremophiles with a number of unusual adaptations known as troglomorphism. In some species, notably the Mexican tetra, shortfin molly, Oman garra, Indoreonectes evezardi, and a few catfish, both "normal" aboveground and cavefish forms exist.
Many adaptions seen in cavefish are aimed at surviving in a habitat with little food. Living in darkness, pigmentation and eyes are useless, or an actual disadvantage because of their energy requirements, and therefore typically reduced in cavefish. Other examples of adaptations are larger fins for more energy-efficient swimming, and a loss of scales and swim bladder. The loss can be complete or only partial, for example resulting in small or incomplete eyes, and eyes can be present in the earliest life stages but degenerated by the adult stage. In some cases, "blind" cavefish may still be able to see: Juvenile Mexican tetras of the cave form are able to sense light via certain cells in the pineal gland, and Congo blind barbs are photophobic, despite only having retinas and optical nerves that are rudimentary and located deep inside the head, and completely lacking a lens. In the most extreme cases, the lack of light has changed the circadian rhythm of the cavefish. In the Mexican tetra of the cave form and in Garra andruzzii the circadian rhythm lasts 30 hours and 47 hours, respectively. This may help them to save energy. Without sight, other senses are used and these may be enhanced. Examples include the lateral line for sensing vibrations, mouth suction to sense nearby obstacles, and chemoreception. Although there are cavefish in groups known to have electroreception, there is no published evidence that this is enhanced in the cave-dwellers. The level of specialized adaptations in a cavefish is generally considered to be directly correlated to the amount of time it has been restricted to the underground habitat: Species that recently arrived show few adaptations and species with the largest number of adaptations are likely the ones that have been restricted to the habitat for the longest time.
Some fish species that live buried in the bottom of aboveground waters, live deep in the sea or live in deep rivers have adaptations similar to cavefish, including reduced eyes and pigmentation.
File:Cryptotora thamicola.jpg|thumb|The waterfall climbing cavefish has several adaptions that allow it to climb and "walk" in a tetrapod-like fashion
Cavefish are quite small with most species being between in standard length and about a dozen species reaching. Only three species grow larger; two slender Ophisternon swamp eels at up to in standard length and a much more robust undescribed species of mahseer at. The very limited food resources in the habitat likely prevents larger cavefish species from existing and also means that cavefish in general are opportunistic feeders, taking whatever is available. In their habitat, cavefish are often the top predators, feeding on smaller cave-living invertebrates, or are detritivores without enemies. Cavefish typically have low metabolic rates and may be able to survive long periods of starvation. A captive Phreatobius cisternarum did not feed for a year, but remained in good condition. The cave form of the Mexican tetra can build up unusually large fat reserves by "binge eating" in periods where food is available, which then allows it to survive without food for months, much longer than the aboveground form of the species.
In the dark habitat, certain types of displays are reduced in cavefish, but in other cases they have become stronger, shifting from displays that are aimed at being seen to displays aimed at being felt via water movement. For example, during the courtship of the cave form of the Mexican tetra the pair produce turbulence through exaggerated gill and mouth movements, allowing them to detect each other. In general, cavefish are slow growers and slow breeders. Breeding behaviors among cavefish vary extensively, and there are both species that are egg-layers and ovoviviparous species that give birth to live young. Uniquely among fish, the genus Amblyopsis brood their eggs in the gill chambers.

Habitat

Although many cavefish species are restricted to underground lakes, pools or rivers in actual caves, some are found in aquifers and may only be detected by humans when artificial wells are dug into this layer. Most live in areas with low or moderate water current, but there are also species in places with very strong current, such as the waterfall climbing cavefish. Underground waters are often very stable environments with limited variations in temperature, nutrient levels and other factors. Organic compounds generally only occur in low levels and rely on outside sources, such as contained in water that enters the underground habitat from outside, aboveground animals that find their way into caves and guano from bats that roost in caves. Cavefish are primarily restricted to freshwater. A few species, notably the cave-dwelling viviparous brotulas, Luciogobius gobies, Milyeringa sleeper gobies and the blind cave eel, live in anchialine caves and several of these tolerate various salinities.

Range and diversity

The more than 200 scientifically described obligate cavefish species are found in most continents, but there are strong geographic patterns and the species richness varies. The vast majority of species are found in the tropics or subtropics. Cavefish are strongly linked to regions with karst, which commonly result in underground sinkholes and subterranean rivers.
With more than 120 described species, by far the greatest diversity is in Asia, followed by more than 30 species in South America and about 30 species in North America. In contrast, only 9 species are known from Africa, 5 from Oceania, and 1 from Europe. On a country level, China has the greatest diversity with more than 80 species, followed by Brazil with more than 20 species. India, Mexico, Thailand and the United States of America each have 9–14 species. No other country has more than 5 cavefish species.
File:Amblyopsis hoosieri 29330.jpg|thumb|The Hoosier cavefish from Indiana in the United States was only described in 2014
Being underground, many places where cavefish may live have not been thoroughly surveyed. New cavefish species are described with some regularity and undescribed species are known. As a consequence, the number of known cavefish species has risen rapidly in recent decades. In the early 1990s only about 50 species were known, in 2010 about 170 species were known, and by 2015 this had surpassed 200 species. It has been estimated that the final number might be around 250 obligate cavefish species. For example, the first cavefish in Europe, a Barbatula stone loach, was only discovered in 2015 in Southern Germany, and the largest known cavefish, Neolissochilus pnar, was only definitely confirmed in 2019, despite being quite numerous in the cave where it occurs in Meghalaya, India. Conversely, their unusual appearance means that some cavefish already attracted attention in ancient times. The oldest known description of an obligate cavefish, involving Sinocyclocheilus hyalinus, is almost 500 years old.
Obligate cavefish are known from a wide range of families: Characidae, Balitoridae, Cobitidae, Cyprinidae, Nemacheilidae, Amblycipitidae, Astroblepidae, Callichthyidae, Clariidae, Heptapteridae, Ictaluridae, Kryptoglanidae, Loricariidae, Phreatobiidae, Trichomycteridae, Sternopygidae, Amblyopsidae, Bythitidae, Poeciliidae, Synbranchidae, Cottidae, Butidae, Eleotridae, Milyeringidae, Gobiidae and Channidae. Many of these families are only very distantly related and do not form a monophyletic group, showing that adaptations to a life in caves has happened numerous times among fish. As such, their similar adaptions are examples of convergent evolution and the descriptive term "cavefish" is an example of folk taxonomy rather than scientific taxonomy. Strictly speaking some Cyprinodontidae are also known from sinkhole caves, famously including the Devils Hole pupfish, but these lack the adaptations typically associated with cavefish. Additionally, species from a few families such as Chaudhuriidae, Glanapteryginae and Sarcoglanidinae live buried in the bottom of aboveground waters, and can show adaptions similar to traditional underground-living fish. It has been argued that such species should be recognized as a part of the group of troglobitic fish.

Species

, the following underground-living fish species with various levels of troglomorphism are known. Phreatobius sanguijuela and Prietella phreatophila, the only species with underground populations in more than one country, are listed twice. Excluded from the table are species that live buried in the bottom of aboveground waters and undescribed species.
FamilySpeciesCountryYear of descriptionNotes
CharacidaeAstyanax aeneusMexico1860Species includes both aboveground and belowground forms. Sometimes considered a part of Astyanax mexicanus
CharacidaeAstyanax mexicanus Mexico1853Species includes both aboveground and belowground forms. Cave form sometimes considered a separate species, A. jordani
CharacidaeStygichthys typhlops Brazil1965
CyprinidaeAnchicyclocheilus halfibindusChina1992Sometimes considered a species in the genus Sinocyclocheilus, or a synonym of Sinocyclocheilus microphthalmus
CyprinidaeBarbodes micropsIndonesia1868Formerly placed in Barbus or Puntius instead. Aboveground populations have also been assigned to this species, but its taxonomy is unresolved and a review has suggested that at least some of the underground populations might belong to Puntius binotatus or an undescribed species instead.
CyprinidaeBarbopsis devecchi Somalia1926
CyprinidaeCaecobarbus geertsii DR Congo1921
CyprinidaeCaecocypris basimi Iraq1980
CyprinidaeGarra barreimiae Oman1956Species includes both aboveground and belowground forms. A population in the United Arab Emirates has been reported to be underground, but this is incorrect
CyprinidaeGarra dunsirei Oman1987
CyprinidaeGarra lorestanensisIran2016
CyprinidaeGarra tashanensisIran2016
CyprinidaeGarra typhlops Iran1944Formerly in its own genus Iranocypris
CyprinidaeGarra widdowsoni Iraq1955Formerly in its own genus Typhlogarra, but genetics show that it belongs in Garra
CyprinidaeLonganalus macrochirousChina2006
CyprinidaeNeolissochilus pnarIndia2023Originally tentatively identified as a troglobitic form of the golden mahseer.
CyprinidaeNeolissochilus subterraneusThailand2003
CyprinidaeGarra andruzziiSomalia1924Originally described in the monotypic genus Phreatichthys
CyprinidaePoropuntius speleopsThailand1991
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus albeoguttatusChina1998
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus altishoulderusChina1992
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus aluensisChina2005
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus anatirostris China1986
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus angularis China1990
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus anophthalmus China1988
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus anshuiensisChina2013
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus aquihornesChina2007
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus biangularisChina1996
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus bicornutusChina1997
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus brevibarbatusChina2009
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus broadihornesChina2007
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus cyphotergousChina1988
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus flexuosdorsalisChina2012
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus furcodorsalis China1997
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus guanyangensisChina2016
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus huanjiangensisChina2010
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus hugeibarbusChina2003
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus hyalinus China1993
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus jinxiensisChina2012Proposed moved to monotypic genus Pseudosinocyclocheilus in 2016
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus jiuxuensisChina2003
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus lingyunensisChina2000
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus longibarbatusChina1989
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus longifinusChina1996
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus luolouensisChina2013
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus luopingensisChina2002
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus macrophthalmusChina2001
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus macroscalusChina2000
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus maculatusChina2000
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus maitianheensisChina1992
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus malacopterusChina1985
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus mashanensisChina2010
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus microphthalmus China1989
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus multipunctatusChina1931
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus oxycephalusChina1985
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus purpureusChina1985
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus qiubeiensisChina2002
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus rhinocerousChina1994
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus robustusChina1988
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus tianeensisChina2003
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus tianlinensisChina2004
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus tileihornesChina2003
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus xunlensisChina2004
CyprinidaeSinocyclocheilus yishanensisChina1992
CyprinidaeSpeolabeo hokhanhiVietnam2018
CyprinidaeSpeolabeo musaeiLaos2011Formerly in genus Bangana
CyprinidaeTroglocyclocheilus khammouanensisLaos1999
CyprinidaeTyphlobarbus nudiventrisChina1982
BalitoridaeCryptotora thamicola Thailand1988
CobitidaeBibarba parvoculusChina2015
CobitidaeCobitis damlaeTurkey2014First described as a species of cavefish based on a single specimen, but a later review suggested that it was found in an area without underground waters and only is an albinistic individual of the aboveground Cobitis fahireae
CobitidaePangio bhujiaIndia2019
CobitidaeProtocobitis anteroventrisChina2013
CobitidaeProtocobitis polylepisChina2008
CobitidaeProtocobitis typhlopsChina1993
NemacheilidaeBarbatula barbatula Germany1758Aboveground populations widespread in Europe. Belowground population only discovered in 2015 and tentatively included in this species based on genetic evidence. Only known cavefish in Europe
NemacheilidaeClaea dabryiChina1874Traditionally in genus Schistura or Triplophysa. Species includes both aboveground and belowground populations; the latter sometimes recognized as a separate subspecies microphthalmus.
NemacheilidaeDraconectes narinosusVietnam2012
NemacheilidaeEidinemacheilus proudloveiIraq2016
NemacheilidaeEidinemacheilus smithi Iran1976Formerly in genus Noemacheilus or Paracobitis
NemacheilidaeHeminoemacheilus hyalinusChina1996
NemacheilidaeIndoreonectes evezardiIndia1872Species includes both aboveground and belowground forms
NemacheilidaeNemacheilus troglocataractus Thailand1989
NemacheilidaeOreonectes acridorsalisChina2013
NemacheilidaeOreonectes anophthalmusChina1981
NemacheilidaeOreonectes barbatusChina2013
NemacheilidaeOreonectes daqikongensisChina2016
NemacheilidaeOreonectes donglanensisChina2013
NemacheilidaeOreonectes duanensisChina2013
NemacheilidaeOreonectes elongatusChina2012
NemacheilidaeOreonectes furcocaudalisChina1987
NemacheilidaeOreonectes guananensisChina2011
NemacheilidaeOreonectes luochengensisChina2011
NemacheilidaeOreonectes macrolepisChina2009
NemacheilidaeOreonectes microphthalmusChina2008
NemacheilidaeOreonectes shuilongensisChina2016
NemacheilidaeOreonectes translucensChina2006
NemacheilidaeSchistura deansmartiThailand2003
NemacheilidaeSchistura jarutaniniThailand1990
NemacheilidaeSchistura kaysoneiLaos2002
NemacheilidaeSchistura larketensisIndia2017
NemacheilidaeSchistura lingyunensisChina1997Sometimes in genus Triplophysa
NemacheilidaeSchistura mobbsiVietnam2012
NemacheilidaeSchistura oedipusThailand1988
NemacheilidaeSchistura papuliferaIndia2007
NemacheilidaeSchistura sijuensisIndia1987
NemacheilidaeSchistura spekuliVietnam2004
NemacheilidaeSchistura spiesiThailand2003
NemacheilidaeSpeonectes tiomanensisMalaysia1990Formerly in genus Sundoreonectes
NemacheilidaeTriplophysa aluensisChina2000
NemacheilidaeTriplophysa dongganensisChina2013
NemacheilidaeTriplophysa fengshanensisChina2013
NemacheilidaeTriplophysa gejiuensisChina1979
NemacheilidaeTriplophysa huanjiangensisChina2011
NemacheilidaeTriplophysa jiarongensisChina2012
NemacheilidaeTriplophysa langpingensisChina2013
NemacheilidaeTriplophysa lihuensisChina2012
NemacheilidaeTriplophysa longibarbataChina1998Includes Paracobitis maolanensis and P. posterodorsalus as synonyms, which may be valid species
NemacheilidaeTriplophysa luochengensisChina2017
NemacheilidaeTriplophysa macrocephalaChina2011
NemacheilidaeTriplophysa qiubeiensisChina2008
NemacheilidaeTriplophysa rosaChina2005
NemacheilidaeTriplophysa shilinensisChina1992
NemacheilidaeTriplophysa tianeensisChina2004
NemacheilidaeTriplophysa xiangshuingensisChina2004
NemacheilidaeTriplophysa xiangxiensisChina1986
NemacheilidaeTriplophysa yunnanensisChina1990
NemacheilidaeTroglocobitis starostini Turkmenistan1983
AmblycipitidaeXiurenbagrus dorsalisChina2014
AstroblepidaeAstroblepus pholeterEcuador1962
AstroblepidaeAstroblepus riberaePeru1994
CallichthyidaeAspidoras mephistoBrazil2017Formerly included in aboveground species A. albater
ClariidaeClarias cavernicola Angola1936
ClariidaeHoraglanis abdulkalamiIndia2012
ClariidaeHoraglanis alikunhiiIndia2004
ClariidaeHoraglanis krishnai India1950
ClariidaeUegitglanis zammaranoiSomalia1923
HeptapteridaePimelodella kroneiBrazil1907
HeptapteridaePimelodella spelaeaBrazil2004
HeptapteridaeRhamdia enfurnadaBrazil2005
HeptapteridaeRhamdia guasarensisVenezuela2004
HeptapteridaeRhamdia laluchensis Mexico2003
HeptapteridaeRhamdia laticauda typhlaBelize1982Other subspecies found in aboveground habitats in Mexico and Central America
HeptapteridaeRhamdia macuspanensis Mexico1998
HeptapteridaeRhamdia quelen urichiTrinidad1926Other subspecies found widely in aboveground habitats in South and Central America
HeptapteridaeRhamdia reddelli Mexico1984
HeptapteridaeRhamdia zongolicensis Mexico1993
HeptapteridaeRhamdiopsis krugiBrazil2010
IctaluridaePrietella lundbergi Mexico1995
IctaluridaePrietella phreatophila Mexico1954Listed twice
IctaluridaePrietella phreatophila United States1954Listed twice
IctaluridaeSatan eurystomus United States1947
IctaluridaeTrogloglanis pattersoni United States1919
KryptoglanidaeKryptoglanis shajiiIndia2011Found both underground and aboveground
LoricariidaeAncistrus cryptophthalmusBrazil1987
LoricariidaeAncistrus formosoBrazil1997
LoricariidaeAncistrus galaniVenezuela1994
PhreatobiidaePhreatobius cisternarumBrazil1905
PhreatobiidaePhreatobius dracunculusBrazil2007
PhreatobiidaePhreatobius sanguijuelaBolivia2007Listed twice
PhreatobiidaePhreatobius sanguijuelaBrazil2007Listed twice
SiluridaePterocryptis buccata Thailand1998Species includes both aboveground and belowground forms
SiluridaePterocryptis cucphuongensisVietnam1978
TrichomycteridaeGlaphyropoma spinosumBrazil2008
TrichomycteridaeItuglanis bambuiBrazil2004
TrichomycteridaeItuglanis boticarioBrazil2015
TrichomycteridaeItuglanis epikarsticusBrazil2004
TrichomycteridaeItuglanis mambaiBrazil2008
TrichomycteridaeItuglanis passensisBrazil2002
TrichomycteridaeItuglanis ramiroiBrazil2004
TrichomycteridaeSilvinichthys bortayroArgentina2005
TrichomycteridaeTrichomycterus daliBrazil2011
TrichomycteridaeTrichomycterus chabertiBolivia1968
TrichomycteridaeTrichomycterus itacarambiensisBrazil1996
TrichomycteridaeTrichomycterus rosablancaColombia2018
TrichomycteridaeTrichomycterus rubbioliBrazil2012
TrichomycteridaeTrichomycterus sandovaliColombia2006
TrichomycteridaeTrichomycterus santanderensisColombia2007
TrichomycteridaeTrichomycterus sketiColombia2010
TrichomycteridaeTrichomycterus spelaeusVenezuela2001
TrichomycteridaeTrichomycterus uisae Colombia2008
SternopygidaeEigenmannia vicentespelaeaBrazil1996
AmblyopsidaeAmblyopsis hoosieri United States2014
AmblyopsidaeAmblyopsis rosae United States1898
AmblyopsidaeAmblyopsis spelaea United States1842
AmblyopsidaeForbesichthys agassizii United States1872Found belowground, but also nearby in aboveground waters during the night
AmblyopsidaeSpeoplatyrhinus poulsoni United States1974
AmblyopsidaeTyphlichthys subterraneus United States1859Possibly a species complex and T. eigemanni may be a valid species
BythitidaeDiancistrus typhlopsIndonesia2009
BythitidaeLucifuga dentata Cuba1858
BythitidaeLucifuga lucayana Bahamas2006
BythitidaeLucifuga simileCuba1981
BythitidaeLucifuga spelaeotes Bahamas1970
BythitidaeLucifuga subterranea Cuba1858
BythitidaeLucifuga teresinarumCuba1988
BythitidaeOgilbia galapagosensis Ecuador1965Arguably not a true cavefish, as places it inhabits also can be described as lagoon crevices
BythitidaeTyphliasina pearsei Mexico1938
PoeciliidaePoecilia mexicana Mexico1863Species includes both aboveground and belowground forms
SynbranchidaeRakthamichthys digressusIndia2002
SynbranchidaeRakthamichthys indicusIndia1961Originally described as Monopterus indicus by K. C. Eapen, but as this name was already taken by the Bombay swamp eel, it was redescribed as Monopterus eapeni in 1991. When the species was moved to the genus Rakthamichthys, the indicus specific epithet was revived.
SynbranchidaeRakthamichthys roseniIndia1998
SynbranchidaeOphisternon candidum Australia1962
SynbranchidaeOphisternon infernale Mexico1938
CottidaeC. bairdi—cognatus species complex United States1850/1836Aboveground forms relatively widespread in North America and Siberia, underground form only in Pennsylvania
CottidaeCottus carolinae United States1861Aboveground forms relatively widespread in the United States, underground form only in West Virginia
CottidaeCottus specus United States2013Formerly included in C. carolinae
ButidaeBostrychus microphthalmusIndonesia2005The family Butidae was formerly considered a subfamily of Eleotridae
ButidaeOxyeleotris caecaPapua New Guinea1996The family Butidae was formerly considered a subfamily of Eleotridae
ButidaeOxyeleotris colasiIndonesia2013Has mistakenly been reported to occur in Papua New Guinea, but it is from Western New Guinea, the Indonesian part of the island. The family Butidae was formerly considered a subfamily of Eleotridae
EleotridaeCaecieleotris morrisi Mexico2016
MilyeringidaeMilyeringa brooksiAustralia2010The family Milyeringidae was formerly considered a subfamily of Eleotridae
MilyeringidaeMilyeringa justitia Australia2013The family Milyeringidae was formerly considered a subfamily of Eleotridae
MilyeringidaeMilyeringa veritas Australia1945The family Milyeringidae was formerly considered a subfamily of Eleotridae
MilyeringidaeTyphleotris madagascariensisMadagascar1933The family Milyeringidae was formerly considered a subfamily of Eleotridae
MilyeringidaeTyphleotris mararybeMadagascar2012The family Milyeringidae was formerly considered a subfamily of Eleotridae
MilyeringidaeTyphleotris paulianiMadagascar1959The family Milyeringidae was formerly considered a subfamily of Eleotridae
GobiidaeCaecogobius cryptophthalmusPhilippines1991
GobiidaeCaecogobius personatusPhilippines2019
GobiidaeGlossogobius ankaranensisMadagascar1994
GobiidaeLuciogobius albusJapan1940
GobiidaeLuciogobius pallidusJapan1940
AenigmachannidaeAenigmachanna gollum India2019One of two species in a unique fish family closely related to true snakeheads. Displays relatively few troglomorphisms despite living in underground aquifers, and thus could either be a recent arrival to the subterranean ecosystem or possibly a subtroglophile that periodically moves between the underground and surface.
AenigmachannidaeAenigmachanna mahabaliIndia2019One of two species in a unique fish family closely related to true snakeheads. Displays relatively few troglomorphisms despite living in underground aquifers, and thus could either be a recent arrival to the subterranean ecosystem or possibly a subtroglophile that periodically moves between the underground and surface.