| Year | Player | Position | Team | Ref | Other finalists |
| 2004 | | IF/P | | | Brad Corley, OF,
Jarrett Hoffpauir, IF, |
| 2005 | | OF | | | Stephen Head, IF/P,
Craig Newton, C, Delta State
Garner Wetzel, OF, Millsaps |
| 2006 | | IF | | | Toddrick Johnson, OF,
Zach Penpraise, IF |
| 2007 | | C | Mississippi State Bulldogs | | Zack Cozart, SS,
Thomas Royals, P, Belhaven |
| 2008 | | P | | | Tyler Conn, C,
Rickey Noland, C, Delta State |
| 2009 | | IF/P | Belhaven Blazers | | Scott Bittle, 1B,
Brian Dozier, 2B, |
| 2010 | | P | | | Todd McInnis, P,
Connor Powers, 1B, |
| 2011 | | OF | | | Jarrod Parks, 3B, Mississippi State
B. A. Vollmuth, SS, |
| 2012 | | P | Mississippi State Bulldogs | | Colton Mitchell, P, Delta State
Alex Yarbrough, 2B, |
| 2013 | | OF | Mississippi State Bulldogs | | Josh Branstetter, P, Delta State
Andrew Pierce, P,
Stuart Turner, C,
Bobby Wahl, P, |
| 2014 | | OF | Ole Miss Rebels | | Tyler Akins, P/1B, Belhaven
Chris Ellis, P, Ole Miss
Jacob Lindgren, P, Mississippi State
Ross Mitchell, P, Mississippi State |
| 2015 | | P | | | Wes Rea, 1B, Mississippi State
Melvin Rodriguez, IF,
Keith Shumaker, P/IF, Millsaps
Scott Weathersby, P, |
| 2016 | | OF | Mississippi State Bulldogs | | Dakota Hudson, P, Mississippi State
Reid Humphreys, IF/P, Mississippi State
Will Robertson, OF, Delta State
J. B. Woodman, OF, Ole Miss |
| 2017 | | 1B | Mississippi State Bulldogs | | Taylor Braley, 3B/P,
Dylan Burdeaux, 1B,
Zach Shannon, 1B/P, Delta State
Matt Wallner, OF/P, |
| 2018 | | P | | | Jake Mangum, OF, Mississippi State
Ryan Olenek, IF/OF, Ole Miss
Luke Reynolds, IF,
Zach Shannon, 1B/P, Delta State |
| 2019 | | OF | Mississippi State Bulldogs | | Tyler Keenen, 3B, Ole Miss
Grae Kessinger, SS, Ole Miss
Ethan Small, P, Mississippi State
Matt Wallner, OF, Southern Miss |
| 2021 | | OF | Mississippi State Bulldogs | | Kevin Graham, OF, Ole Miss
Gunnar Hoglund, P, Ole Miss
Doug Nikhazy, P, Ole Miss
Landon Sims, P, Mississippi State |
| 2022 | | P | Southern Miss Golden Eagles | | Tim Elko, IF/OF, Ole Miss
RJ Yeager, IF, Mississippi State
Harrison Haley, P, Delta State
Brett Sanchez, P, Belhaven |
| 2023 | | OF/C | | | Ty Hill, IF, Jackson State
Hunter Hines, IF/OF, Mississippi State
Slade Wilks, OF, Southern Miss
Tanner Hall, P, Southern Miss |
| 2024 | | OF | Mississippi State Bulldogs | | Ethan Lege, OF, Ole Miss
Dalton McIntyre, OF, Southern Miss
Brett Sanchez, P, Belhaven
RJ Stinson, OF, William Carey |
| 2024 | | P | Southern Miss Golden Eagles | | Drake Fontenot, P, Delta State
Luke Hill, 3B, Ole Miss
Nick Monistere, 2B, Southern Miss Golden Eagles
Ace Reese, 3B, Mississippi State Bulldogs |